[Essentials] Manga

[GameSoul]

Oh well, I guess I'll be on it

 

[OmerMe]

WTF? why are -1 posts are allowed? that's just stupid
I really think you shouldn't allow that, the point of the game is to let people raise points, besides no one but him made a -1 post

 

[.::5pYd3r::.]

WTF? why are -1 posts are allowed? that's just stupid
I really think you shouldn't allow that, the point of the game is to let people raise points, besides no one but him made a -1 post

The kids fried, just ignore him.

GTO
Akira
FMA
Bleach

 

[DaRk_ViVi]

WTF? why are -1 posts are allowed? that's just stupid
I really think you shouldn't allow that, the point of the game is to let people raise points, besides no one but him made a -1 post

Right, I think -1 posts are just useless.

 

[Blake1710]

+1 Hellsing, Full Metal Alchemist, Naruto and Deathnote

hellsing for sure

 

[OmerMe]

The OP should do a recount and exclude Tropicana's post or something..

 

[Mangofett]

Keep Tropicana's post, but make a new rule on the limit of -1s you can do.

 

[Klx5]

BERSERK (hell yeah)
GANTZ
FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST
NARUTO
BLEACH
SHAMO

 

[Shakraka]

WTF? why are -1 posts are allowed? that's just stupid
I really think you shouldn't allow that, the point of the game is to let people raise points, besides no one but him made a -1 post

1. It's not a game, it's a list of opinions.
2. It's his opinion and just because it doesn't match with everyone else's opinions, doesn't mean it needs to be discarded.
3. -1 votes for:
Naruto
One Piece
Bleach
Now he's not the only one that did -1 votes.

When you make a thread asking for what people think, you're going to get objective opinions. That is the truth, and the only one to blame is the op for making this list of opinions.

 

[GameSoul]

Keep Tropicana's post, but make a new rule on the limit of -1s you can do.

Yeah, I'll most likely limit the -1 rule to 5 or something, but I really don't feel comfortable keeping the rule, so I'll recount everything and update the topic with the new posts coming in. I'd really like to have just a library and if there happens to be too many essential or recommended series I'll just create a new category or raise the # of votes needed. Sorry everyone for the inconvenience.

*NEW* The -1 rule no longer applies in this essentials list.

 

[airpirate545]

+1to Parasyte. Best manga I've read in a while.

 

[xcalibur]

-1 to all of these

Yotsuba&!
Neon Genesis Evangelion
NHK ni Yokoso
Full Metal Alchemist
Slam dunk
Rozen Maiden

2. It's his opinion and just because it doesn't match with everyone else's opinions, doesn't mean it needs to be discarded.

How delightfully hypocritical. His opinions shouldn't be discarded yet he clearly denounces everyone elses.
Brilliant logic right there.

 

[Shakraka]

2. It's his opinion and just because it doesn't match with everyone else's opinions, doesn't mean it needs to be discarded.

How delightfully hypocritical. His opinions shouldn't be discarded yet he clearly denounces everyone elses.
Brilliant logic right there.

So that brings me back to square one, is his opinion invalid because he thinks other people's opinions are invalid? His opinion is that everything that he put a -1 vote for is what he thinks doesn't belong on the list, the very same list that was made to listen to everyone's opinion, not just the majority.

Instead of getting rid of a certain manga from the list entirely, the OP should leave the votes at (0) to show that a person(s) suggested it, but another person(s) doesn't agree with the vote(s) for that manga.

 

[da_head]

Everything I've listed here, will get a -1.
Ichigo 100%

u sir, have just lost my respect. who the fuck do you think you are doing -1 posts? what a bullshit elitist way of thinking. u remind me of my friend who refuses to watch ANYTHING mainstream. i know a lot of mainstream is bad *cough* bleach, but simply not watching it because of that, is pretty fuckin stupid.

assuming you've read all the manga u've "-1" (which u prob have), i still don't see why u can just cancel out someone else's previous suggestion.

[/rant]

EDIT: o and err

Deathnote
Liar's game
Suzuka
DNAngel
Full metal panic
Naruto (yeah i went there)
Blue Heaven
Shamo
I's

that's all i can remb for now

 

[cocomonk22]

Detective Conan and Rurouni Kenshin.

 

[Pyrofyr]

One PIece

Great Teacher Onizuka

God those were great MangA!

A VERY rare Manga to find that's amazing is called "IO"

It's about scuba diving and little girls, it's crazy!

!1

Found it on OneManga though http://www.onemanga.com/IO/ (To prove it exists)

 

[GameSoul]

List updated. A few moves ups and recounts here and there.

 

[xcalibur]

2. It's his opinion and just because it doesn't match with everyone else's opinions, doesn't mean it needs to be discarded.

How delightfully hypocritical. His opinions shouldn't be discarded yet he clearly denounces everyone elses.
Brilliant logic right there.

So that brings me back to square one, is his opinion invalid because he thinks other people's opinions are invalid? His opinion is that everything that he put a -1 vote for is what he thinks doesn't belong on the list, the very same list that was made to listen to everyone's opinion, not just the majority.

Instead of getting rid of a certain manga from the list entirely, the OP should leave the votes at (0) to show that a person(s) suggested it, but another person(s) doesn't agree with the vote(s) for that manga.

This is an essentials topic. A topic where you post your essentials. True, there is nothing in the rules about -1 posts, but that goes against the entire point of this thread. When voting on a ameshow, you're not given the option to vote for your favourite contestant. You're not supposed to vote everyone else down. Thats a retarded way of doing things.

Tropicana can fuck off with his bullshit elitist and possibly trolly comment. I can tell his post is intentionally flame-inducing because all he did was copypaste everything in the list and gave it a -1.

Consider it successfull if it was. I fucking raged.

 

[GameSoul]

List updated.

 

[ZonMachi]

Hmm time to refresh my memory of favorite mangas

Elfen Lied
Trigun
Trigun Maximum
D. Gray Man
Full Metal Alchemist
Slam Dunk
D-Ash
Detective Conan
Watashi no Messiah Sama
Hana Kimi
Dragonball
Air Gear
Ranma 1/2
NHK ni Yokoso
Bitter Virgin
Ruroni Kenshin
Samurai Deeper Kyo
Until Death Do Us Apart
Love Hina
Living Game
D.N. Angel
Midori no Hibi
Pretty Face

that's all I can think of right now and please excuse any accidental duplicates