GTA VI scores 99 on Metacritic, tying Ocarina of Time's 1998 record

Rockstar's open-world sequel has matched the highest score in Metacritic history, with over 145 reviews in, though critics flag frame rate dips and no 60fps mode.

109 replies Share
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Wow
GTA VI scores 99 on Metacritic, tying Ocarina of Time's 1998 record

The review embargo for Rockstar Games' Grand Theft Auto VI lifted today and the verdict is about as close to unanimous praise as it gets.

With more than 145 critic reviews counted, it is currently sitting at a 99 score on Metacritic and a 98 average on OpenCritic where 100% of critics recommend it. That 99 puts it level with the 1998 N64 edition of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - the highest-rated game in Metacritic's history - the very game whose Switch 2 remake sold more than 5.2 million copies in four days earlier this month.

Reviewers have reportedly clocked anything from 70 to 200+ hours into the game. If we were to focus on the single most impressive part of the game most critics are raving about, it's the density of the world and NPC AI, as well as the environmental detail and the way its systems bounce off each other across the various areas in the game. With the map reporting to be 2~3x bigger than that of GTA V.

The main story follows Jason and Lucia who give off a "Bonnie and Clyde" dynamic and this is also getting high praise with the game taking a more serious tone compared to the often slapstick, shock humor style GTA V went for - some critics compare the tone to something more like Red Dead Redemption 2. Missions also reportedly give you far more freedom in how you play and approach missions than ever before . Previous Rockstar games were often said to have quite rigid guidelines for missions where they expect you to play in a specific way and would often unfairly fail you if you went off script.

Unfortunately it's not all sunshine and rainbows - there's no 60fps performance mode available and several reviews mention frame rate dips that distract from the experience a bit. The lowest score tracked at launch is an 80/100 from ScreenHub, which points to slow pacing, repetitive missions and survival chores.

Grand Theft Auto VI is already available in various regions but is unlocking in various regions over the next 16 hours from the time of this post.

If you're playing let us know what you think in the thread below! Do you agree with the near unanimous praise?

:arrow: GTA VI on MetaCritic
:arrow: GTA VI on OpenCritic

Thread rules:

  • Not interested in GTA VI or don't have anything constructive to say? Please go elsewhere
  • Posting unmarked spoilers will result in a ban
  • Keep it civil
 

Discussion

I think it’s too early to say how good the game is. It just came out a few hours ago and it’s probably at the very least, a 20 hour game, and a review is already out? I dunno, I’d say to give it a bit more time to marinate and then we can say how good it actually is
Well the critics have had it for who knows how long? As said in the article some have clocked in between 70-200+ hours already so I think the critic reviews are trustworthy.
 
Well the critics have had it for who knows how long? As said in the article some have clocked in between 70-200+ hours already so I think the critic reviews are trustworthy.
Ohhh yeah I completely overlooked that lol, you’re right, then it’s probably safe to say it’s a pretty darn good game! It’s really fun seeing so many people excited about it, and who knows, maybe customer reviews will also reach that score! :grog:
 
Nice Easter Egg, again :D

I will check back when PC port (or recomp) is out. Until then, sucks to be a GTA fan with no other way to play the game.
Post automatically merged:

Years and billions, yet can't even keep 30fps. Fixed hardware, Rockstar know exactly what they are targeting and still can't do it. That alone should knock it from 10/10, but GTA games always get a free pass on performance.
I'm fairly certain the idea is to re-release the game on more powerful upcoming consoles, much like GTAV. Having been released at the tail end of the current generation, it feels more than likely.
 
Last edited by lightwo,
Honestly, i think it's suspicious. Such high scores, game isn't even released yet.... sure these are not player reviews, but i would still not trust it too much. Don't forget this game was hyped like crazy, i wouldn't trust these critics to be unbiased any day, but this is just suspicious.
 
99!?! I didn't think a game would get 99% in this day and age, especially after Ocarina of Time's remakes didn't get that score. I guess the long wait paid off! I hope the long wait for Half-Life 3 and the Elder Scrolls 6 pays off too.
A remake will never get that score.
 
IT DESERVES THE 99/100 METASCORE!!! :D

...the mouse/car/helicopter/tank/ gbatemp banhammer/Musk starlink cannon minigame, that is. Not played GTA 6 yet.

I thought the release date was tomorrow. Not that I care, as I'll probably have to wait like 29 Claude tokens until someone compiles a PC clone. ;)
 
You really think they spent 10 years on it?
I don't. They started the planning and some stuff, but there's no way they spent 10 years on it.
5 years, tops.
Don't forget a lot of the game development can be sped up by learnings, tools and resources from previous games, either GTA or RDR.
Well... There's Skull & Bones.....
Years and billions, yet can't even keep 30fps. Fixed hardware, Rockstar know exactly what they are targeting and still can't do it. That alone should knock it from 10/10, but GTA games always get a free pass on performance.
You had Skull and Bones which never even came out until 2024. Reviews absolutely bombed hard because it felt incomplete due to lots of delays that caused the game to be behind.

I mean @shaunj66 spent 10 minutes creating game on a budget of a coffee. Its 10/10

if GTA 6 isn't 10/10 ill be fuming that's for sure.
 
Last edited by Flame,
The extremely high metascore/the consistently high review scores has surprised me a bit.

Given how much that Rockstar/T2 has invested in it, I was certainly expecting it to be a well-reviewed game. This is a situation where they are going to polish a game to within an inch of its life, as they aren't under any real time or financial constraints to get the game shipped.

That said, the sheer number of perfect scores is unexpected. And part of me wonders if we've reached the point where even a 10/10 has been watered down some. All of these reviewers and they cannot find anything wrong with the game? There's not a character that bugs you, a performance hiccup in an intense firefight, a mini-game that doesn't quite hit, some lines of dialogue that fall flat or rely on unearned pathos?

I don't believe anything is perfect (except Dr. Pepper, of course). So seeing so many perfect scores seems a bit too good to be true.
 
i mean @shaunj66 spent 10 minutes creating game on a budget of a coffee. 10/10

if GTA 6 isnt





I mean @shaunj66 spent 10 minutes creating game on a budget of a coffee. Its 10/10

if GTA 6 isn't 10/10 ill be fuming that's for sure.
Well.... If p1ngpong was holding the banhammer, it'd have been 11/10.
 
The framerate feels like mud and the cars handle like GTA 4. If you liked that game you'll love this.

Realism of stuff is off the charts so far. Good and bad, seems harder to cause mayhem without cops being all over you. Hasn't really grabbed me yet but only 3 hours in.
 

Site & Scene News

New Hot Discussed User Submitted