Zelda after the Ocarina of Time remake: classic or open world?
With the Ocarina of Time remake selling 5.2 million copies in four days, we ask whether the next mainline Zelda should be linear, open world or a blend of the two?
By
Shaun James
·
GBAtemp Administrator
- 2 min read
- 4,045 views
Not unlike the Sonic franchise and its split fanbase, The Legend of Zelda now also finds itself split between two distinct gameplay styles. Before 2017, the series was predictable, following a formulaic pattern for its mainline entries, which is perhaps why Nintendo made such a radical departure in the critically acclaimed Breath of the Wild.
That game and its follow-up, Tears of the Kingdom, shook up the series with an open-world approach that Nintendo has said outright was an attempt to get back to the spirit of the original 1986 game. The linear story beats were gone, and so was the old loop of dungeon, new item or upgrade, next area, rinse and repeat. Instead there was an open-world Hyrule you could approach in almost any order, with more freedom than the series had ever offered. Some would argue, however, that the removal of the hand-crafted dungeons and items meant losing a big part of what makes Zelda feel like Zelda.
The Ocarina of Time remake, which sold more than 5.2 million copies in its first four days, has us wondering what its success means for the series. We can only guess why Nintendo went back to OOT now. Perhaps it was a way for the younger generation of developers to understand what made the classic games work. Or was it a chance for Nintendo to get to grips with the Switch 2 hardware and test the waters of the new art style before committing to the next mainline game?
Whatever the reason for the remake, where do you think Nintendo will go with the next entry in the series? Will it follow a more classic, linear and story-driven beat or will they continue the more open-world approach of Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom? Regardless, both approaches have produced some of the best games ever made and there's no denying the series is in good hands.
Would you prefer a more classic or open-world approach for the next mainline Zelda game or perhaps a blend of the two that finds a middle ground?
Let us know your thoughts below.














