Zelda after the Ocarina of Time remake: classic or open world?

With the Ocarina of Time remake selling 5.2 million copies in four days, we ask whether the next mainline Zelda should be linear, open world or a blend of the two?

83 replies Share
  • Like
  • Angry
  • Love
Zelda after the Ocarina of Time remake: classic or open world?

Not unlike the Sonic franchise and its split fanbase, The Legend of Zelda now also finds itself split between two distinct gameplay styles. Before 2017, the series was predictable, following a formulaic pattern for its mainline entries, which is perhaps why Nintendo made such a radical departure in the critically acclaimed Breath of the Wild.

That game and its follow-up, Tears of the Kingdom, shook up the series with an open-world approach that Nintendo has said outright was an attempt to get back to the spirit of the original 1986 game. The linear story beats were gone, and so was the old loop of dungeon, new item or upgrade, next area, rinse and repeat. Instead there was an open-world Hyrule you could approach in almost any order, with more freedom than the series had ever offered. Some would argue, however, that the removal of the hand-crafted dungeons and items meant losing a big part of what makes Zelda feel like Zelda.

The Ocarina of Time remake, which sold more than 5.2 million copies in its first four days, has us wondering what its success means for the series. We can only guess why Nintendo went back to OOT now. Perhaps it was a way for the younger generation of developers to understand what made the classic games work. Or was it a chance for Nintendo to get to grips with the Switch 2 hardware and test the waters of the new art style before committing to the next mainline game?

Whatever the reason for the remake, where do you think Nintendo will go with the next entry in the series? Will it follow a more classic, linear and story-driven beat or will they continue the more open-world approach of Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom? Regardless, both approaches have produced some of the best games ever made and there's no denying the series is in good hands.

Would you prefer a more classic or open-world approach for the next mainline Zelda game or perhaps a blend of the two that finds a middle ground?

Let us know your thoughts below.

What approach would you prefer for the next mainline Zelda?

  • Classic, linear and story-driven, like Ocarina of Time

    Votes: 139 40.3%
  • Open-world, like Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom

    Votes: 49 14.2%
  • A combination of the two approaches

    Votes: 132 38.3%
  • I have full faith in Nintendo to make the right decision

    Votes: 20 5.8%
  • I've never played a Zelda game in my life or don't care

    Votes: 5 1.4%

  • Total voters
    345
 

Related news

Discussion

In my opinion the ideal balance would be a semi-open world that is at most twice as large as that of OoT. Enough to fill it with things to explore, but small enough to not feel repetitive and empty. And please make it less linear (like A Link Between Worlds, for instance), so the player can choose what to explore next.

Oh yeah, and please give me actual dungeons instead of shrines. That would be cool.
 
obviously the answer is always both. There's no stopping them from having botw open world with proper dungeon. Heck make them all connected like eden ring and you have a chance to surpass that game
 
Both are good, why should we pit both against each other? Zelda game have always been the greatest adventure games ever regardless.
 
I want The Wind waker 2.
I want it so bad. Please Nintendo, please, I beg you
Oh do I have some great news for you. Nintendo actually released it all the way back in 2007! It's called Phantom Hourglass!

(I actually really love Phantom Hourglass and especially Spirit Tracks, the train was so fun)
 
Both are too empty in the end...
They should have give them more life, specially during exploration in both case...
 
Last edited by rudras,
  • Like
Reactions: AndeRei
Since they made so much money with the OoT remake, I think Nintendo is going to do the Majora's Mask remake next.

Open world games cost them a lot of time and money, a remake is easier and costs less.
 
Since they made so much money with the OoT remake, I think Nintendo is going to do the Majora's Mask remake next.

Open world games cost them a lot of time and money, a remake is easier and costs less.
especially as with the n64 and 3ds, they're already have the engine and 3d models
It would be free money to remake majora
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marc_LFD
Why not both?

You guys know that Zelda Ocarina of Time, while "linear" is incredibly open world if you resort to glitches, right?

For intance... getting the Deku Shield from Dodongo's Cavern before talking to Mido is entirely possible... also first entering the Deku Tree with Boomerang, Bombs, Hylian Shield, Din's Fire is also possible.
Gainning access to Shadow Temple right as you get Hookshot and Master Sword is also possible, even acquiring the Hoover Boots right after Dampe's Race is possible... and the linearity gets broken after defeating Volvagia, meaning, the player can do Water/Shadow/Spirit in any order...
The items after Bow, Megaton Hammer and Longshot are entirely optional, meaning you can beat every dungeon without elemental arrows, stones, child items, and whatnot...

I personally believe, it should be like OoT, but not a watered-down Dark Souls like BoTW and TotK... maybe... add a lot of side quests, give reasons to replay after the main story is done... we're no longer in 1998!
 
  • Like
Reactions: CoolMe
Nintendo would just do what they do. They don't follow trends or what they think customers or their investors want.

That is why they keep chugging along nicely, releasing several acclaimed hits a year and why Sony and Xbox don't release much to and when they do they average "mehs".

A I'd love a Hyrule Warriors that's more like the first one and a Link Berween World's remake. Or start doing the handheld ones that don't have the word "Awakening".

Anways, CDI games to be announced as cannon next week with each getting open world remakes.
 

Site & Scene News

New Hot Discussed User Submitted