Chinese Learning Group
A place to share resources and tidbits for learning chinese
Chinese Learning Group

Chinese Learning Group

Chinese covers of the same song

  • Thread starter Thread starter x65943
  • Start date Start date
  • Views Views 246
  • Replies Replies 0

x65943

Attack car enjoyer
Supervisor
GBAtemp Patron
Joined
Jun 23, 2014
Messages
7,595
Solutions
3
Reaction score
50,700
Trophies
11
Location
Taekwondo Gym
XP
47,363
Country
United States
Faye Wong covered a lot of western songs, including famously Dreams by the Cranberries

She is from Beijing, but her early career was in Hong Kong - and as such the first cover 梦中人 "dreamer" was in Cantonese - a light hearted song with similarities to the original. She later created a Mandarin cover 挣脱 "throw off, break away" which keeps the general structure, but is much darker in tone, and there is a question if you can really call it a cover purely (both released in 1994)

Below is a comparison of the lyrics of the two

Some choice comparisons:

Cantonese
Follow with a ten-minute kiss
Mandarin
Let’s end it, don’t linger

Cantonese
Never been this close to you
Mandarin
I thought my tears were worth it

Cantonese
Dream lover
Mandarin
Love is extinguished

Cantonese
For ten thousand minutes of your kisses
Mandarin
Waving goodbye to yesterday


1753901860653.png
1753901938625.png


 

Group statistics

Group owner:
x65943
Members:
63
Threads:
21
Messages:
32

Site & Scene News