How we cover AI-assisted projects - GBAtemp community check-in

GBAtemp Banner.png

It’s about that time of year again where I check in with the community to see if we can get the front page aligned with what people are interested in knowing and what people are interested in talking about. As the title might have given away, there’s one topic more hot than most at the moment, and that’s AI.

I am a C++ developer by trade, and my place of employ has just started to roll out Claude licences for those interested, so the topic of AI assisted programming is very much on my mind. I’m not just going to go out there and say “AI bad”. I don’t necessarily think it’s a productive conversation to have. The reality is that we’re going to see more projects that make use of it in some form, and some are likely to warrant attention.

Going forwards, I think it’s important that we highlight when projects we do feature make use of AI, and to what extent if such information is available. My hope is that this will strike a reasonable balance of being able to share projects that might look interesting, and giving people who want to avoid AI related projects a simple indicator.

Obviously not every project is going to be so open with their usage, and we have no intention of starting witch hunts by deep diving code and looking for em dashes in the comments. The aim here is to make whatever public information there is accessible for people reading here, and just make things a touch clearer for the people who are looking for that kind of disclaimer.

With that aside though, I am interested to know what the general consensus is among the user base. Are you open to playing ports assisted by AI if it’s the only port available, or happens to offer something unique? Do you draw the line at vibe coding, or do you avoid any project that has Claude listed as a contributor? We sadly don’t have access to polls on the front page any more, but I will make sure to keep up with any replies as they come in.
 
I have a big ego by the way I am well aware
It’s not ego it’s literal mental illness and you need to get away from the keyboard and on some medication.
Post automatically merged:

bad faith you refused to answer my question when I asked does fraud occur.
The topic had nothing to do with fraud. See this is what “bad faith” means.
Post automatically merged:

The way you just create meaning for things and then defend that fictional meaning is very AI of you, that’s why I believe this to be some kind of AI induced psychosis instead of a normal shitposter meltdown
 
It’s not ego it’s literal mental illness and you need to get away from the keyboard and on some medication.
Post automatically merged:


The topic had nothing to do with fraud. See this is what “bad faith” means.
this is a matter of two camps you just want your ai disclosure and your being a whiny bitch because someone is challenging you against the idea and pointing out good reasons why its bad and you keep failing to contribute to my arguments in good faith. mean while I am just concerned about the safety and mental health risks of the devs whether it is valid to have the ai tag or not.
Post automatically merged:

every anti ai person I have ever met on the internet is usually a whiny bitch
Post automatically merged:

its typical in their personality
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Beware
this is a matter of two camps you just want your ai disclosure and your being a whiny bitch because someone is challenging you against the idea and pointing out good reasons why its bad and you keep failing to contribute to my arguments in good faith. mean while I am just concerned about the safety and mental health risks of the devs whether it is valid to have the ai tag or not.
My point in this thread was absolutely not that everybody should disclose AI usage, my point was while I would like it GBATemp should not concern itself with it when it comes to reporting releases. These are completely distinct things and you are the only one struggling to get it
 
this is a matter of two camps you just want your ai disclosure and your being a whiny bitch because someone is challenging you against the idea and pointing out good reasons why its bad and you keep failing to contribute to my arguments in good faith. mean while I am just concerned about the safety and mental health risks of the devs whether it is valid to have the ai tag or not.
Post automatically merged:

every anti ai person I have ever met on the internet is usually a whiny bitch
Post automatically merged:

its typical in their personality
You don’t know anything about health, least of all mental health. Clearly.
Post automatically merged:

they let AI live rent free in their heads
YOU LITERALLY PAY FOR THAT SHIT. You fucking stupid 😹
 
My point in this thread was absolutely not that everybody should disclose AI usage, my point was while I would like it GBATemp should not concern itself with it when it comes to reporting releases. These are completely distinct things and you are the only one struggling to get it
kay let me see it again when did you say that? link me.
 
Reporting the existence of these projects is not endorsing them. I don’t think we need to be at all concerned with AI use unless doing actual reviews or sponsored bits. I think AI assisted projects should declare their use at a minimum, but whether they do or not should not preclude them from a headline.
IKYFL
 
found it. ok you still said hear that I think AI assisted projects should declare their use at a minimum, but whether they do or not should not preclude them from a headline. and I think that is where I took issue with what you said.
 
Vibecode is the future of coding.
vibecode feels so gen z ngl. I wish they'd just call it something normal.
Post automatically merged:

alright thinking about it now. I take it back. so, you don't support gbatemp reporting on it? thats how that reads. alright I apologize I can read things stupid sometimes you do deserve an apology here. I am sorry for the stress.
 
found it. ok you still said hear that I think AI assisted projects should declare their use at a minimum, but whether they do or not should not preclude them from a headline. and I think that is where I took issue with what you said.
Nah you’re suffering paranoid delusions and creating boogie men that you then prop yourself against as some weird paragon while simultaneously refusing basic facts about the technology. It’s weird fucking behavior however you slice it
 
Nah you’re suffering paranoid delusions and creating boogie men that you then prop yourself against as some weird paragon while simultaneously refusing basic facts about the technology. It’s weird fucking behavior however you slice it
eh I dont care. I am just tired of seeing anti ai haters get there way. i don't believe in appeasing people just because they think they can just make up community morals and expect everyone follow them. is what it is though.
 
How about declaring that you use a calculator? I won't, because I'm afraid people might think less of me when they discover that I didn't do the calculation by hand, the way a truly capable human being obviously should. Heaven forbid anyone find out that I used a calculator.
 
eh I dont care. I am just tired of seeing anti ai haters get there way. i don't believe in appeasing people just because they think they can just make up community morals and expect everyone follow them. is what it is though.
It’s clear you don’t believe in following the rules of the forum or basic decorum between your fellow human. It’s psychosis and you need help
 
It’s clear you don’t believe in following the rules of the forum or basic decorum between your fellow man. It’s psychosis and you need help
if I get banned I don't care. is what it is.
Post automatically merged:

I am tired of people... actually so, its not just this whole issue of AI I have "world fatigue" man.
 
if I get banned I don't care. is what it is.
Post automatically merged:

I am tired of people... actually so, its not just this whole issue of AI I have "world fatigue" man.
“Mmmmm oppress me daddy”
Post automatically merged:

if I get banned I don't care. is what it is.
Post automatically merged:

I am tired of people... actually so, it’s not just this whole issue of AI I have "world fatigue" man.
SEEK 👏 PROFESSIONAL 👏 HELP 👏
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Gamehopper
Im Happy if its AI assisted - If the dev knows how to code and uses it to assist or automate certain task. But if the "dev" doesnt understand what the ai is producing then they arent capable of saying its safe.
Bad developers are nothing new. They have been around since the day that job was created. AI can cause a lot of harm, but that one is pretty far down the list of things to worry about.
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum