Discord announces age verification system to roll out in march

  • Thread starter Thread starter Noctosphere
  • Start date Start date
  • Views Views 4,388
  • Replies Replies 57
  • Likes Likes 6
Matrix is rough, but well established in open source communities and as secure as the people in the chat, probably the successor to IRC.

Stoat chat mimics discord well and there's no issues with custom emoji and stuff, but it's been a bit rough since they were driven from the Revolt name, there's no notifications at all (great for people who don't want notification spam, I guess). Probably the comfiest alternative for me. Self hosting is also possible, though I haven't tried it out. iOS app disappeared off of Testflight, but the android app works okay I guess.

There was another one like the above, Fluxer, but they never sent me an account verification email and I pretty much gave up on that immediately with no phone apps.

But yeah, as an Australian hit with Discord's age verification, based on under-16 social media laws that require nothing of them, right after a Nitro price rise, I'm not on there anymore and I'm learning to live with that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lightwo
Cancelled my Nitro and looking to jump ship, what's the next Discord?
As pointed out earlier, there's Matrix, and also more niche protocols like XMPP. Both offer encryption with no backdoors I'm aware of, which is a whole lot better than most alternatives.

Signal isn't really comparable, I don't use it due to sketchy origins and requiring a phone (not just a number, but a client that is installed on/acts as if it was on a phone), but if people at large started using it, I'd consider again.



As for registering on Matrix, you can find servers here and here. Do not register on Matrix.org, it defeats the decentralised nature of the protocol.

The reference desktop client is Element and has all the features, but it uses Chromium (like Discord), so expect high memory usage. The client I recommend is Nheko; it's not the shiniest client out there, but it doesn't chew resources and has most Matrix features you would expect.

FluffyChat is a well-known Android/iOS client. As I don't use Android or iOS nowadays, I can't say much about it, but it should be okay.



As for registering on XMPP, you can find servers here and here (Movim is an extension of XMPP, but essentially is the same thing). There are fewer XMPP users compared to Matrix users, so you may have a harder time finding rooms/contacts, but it doesn't hurt to use both XMPP and Matrix.

The desktop client most people use is Gajim, it is quite usable and feature-packed, but doesn't receive major new features. There's also Dino if you use Linux, and want things like modern VoIP that works with Cheogram/Conversations while sacrificing a lot of niche features Gajim has.

Cheogram is a feature-packed client for Android which is most recommended over the project it's based on, Conversations. There's also Monal for iOS, but I can't say anything about it.
 
Last edited by lightwo,
I hope that's going to push some communities away from exclusively using Discord.

On the flip side, it would be a tragedy if people at large accepted the measures as beneficial for child safety while blissfully ignoring their own privacy and safety. I can't wait to be surrounded by people who assume the worst out of anyone who doesn't comply with this bullshit...
Ya'll have a naive take. The laws this is being made in compliance to can affect anything that has a certain size of user base as long as it's a "user 2 user" platform. Anything that isn't state-ran is now at risk of getting fined if they don't implement "online-safety".

If GBATemp wasn't a mostly forgotten site there'd be reason to fear it coming here as well, because the truth is that if Online Regulators in UK, Australia or EU, found GBATemp they'd hit it with a compliance fine too.

It's getting fucking bad, over here, and it's all because they've realized online communities have a real impact on politics.
 
If GBATemp wasn't a mostly forgotten site there'd be reason to fear it coming here as well

Ouch, what a way to tell someone, they ain't shit! And not important enough!

***On Topic Though***

Either way I'm old now, and I don't need discord, I only used it for mods and early access games.
But I'll leave that to Twitter now, and I'll miss my streams with friends, watching movies together in private rooms.

But someone else will do the same in the future. Cancelled Nitro and will delete my account in 10 days!

Goodbye Discord.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Skelletonike
Ouch, what a way to tell someone, they ain't shit! And not important enough!

***On Topic Though***

Either way I'm old now, and I don't need discord, I only used it for mods and early access games.
But I'll leave that to Twitter now, and I'll miss my streams with friends, watching movies together in private rooms.

But someone else will do the same in the future. Cancelled Nitro and will delete my account in 10 days!

Goodbye Discord.
It was a compliment. GBATemp is great because it didn't kowtow to stay relevant to the public eye, and that means it's not overrun by astroturfers from some police department acting like online users, unlike Reddit and 4chan, and probably Discord in a hot minute.
 
I'm in the UK and while I can't see the odd NSFW post or channel it doesn't bother me in the slightest. I'm not giving Discord any information.
 
  • Like
Reactions: linkenski
I'm in the UK and while I can't see the odd NSFW post or channel it doesn't bother me in the slightest. I'm not giving Discord any information.
Keep it that way. For every person that uploads their data, we give away another piece of the true internet, and if platforms die out and services die out because people aren't verifying, then whether that's what they wanted or not, there's no place for chatrooms that de-anonymize its users, and then that plan can't continue to any government that thought they were about to run a full technocratic surveillance society.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lightwo
if only governments paid attention to that discord breach month's ago (and p*rn sites) age verification company databases are identity theives play ground sadly i'd have more confidence if the damn pentagon ran the verification sites at least their encryption (might) stand a chance
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marc_LFD
if only governments paid attention to that discord breach month's ago (and p*rn sites) age verification company databases are identity theives play ground sadly i'd have more confidence if the damn pentagon ran the verification sites at least their encryption (might) stand a chance
So far, I've heard of two differents projects to verify age online while protecting privacy.
The first is an internet passport. Some kind of ID number linked to you through your ISP. If a website (i.e. porn) needs age verification, you give this ID on an age verification online service (like a cloudflare popup that verifies that you aren't a bot), you enter this ID and it'll check with your ISP for a "feedback", telling the AVOS (nice acronym, right?) that you are indeed an adult in your country (or a teenager, i.e. for facebook, which requires you to be at least 14 in some countries), without telling anything about your actual identity. While entering your ID over and over again could indeed be a pain in the ass, I think that you should only enter it after pressing the "Yes, I am over 18" and when creating an account. Once you created your account, just log in with the "remember me" checked on, and you'd no longer need to type it over and over again (Maybe a refresh verification every few months?)

The other project I've heard of, which is less conveniant, but even better for privacy protection, is to give this job to actual store. Instead of having to give an ID number, you would go to actual stores that are used to do ID check (Liquor store, casino, etc.) where you would get a QR code that would basically do the same as mentionned above, only tell to the AVOS "Yes, this person is an adult" or "Yes, this person is at least 14". The only downside I can see for this is that you'd have to move your fat ass to get that QR code 😹

EDIT : NVM, just remembered of another big downside. You know, when you were 16, but had a friend who was 18? Remember when you asked your friend to buy alcohol for you? That's definitely gonna happen with this too, so...
 
Protecting children should NOT be Discord's responsibility. It should be the parent's to watch what their child are doing on internet and not let them roam mindlessly online.
You seem blissfully unaware of why you ALREADY should not support Discord or use their servers. I'll let you google it. Or you can watch Gamers Nexus' latest video to learn more. (Prolly a LOT more.)

And you obviously are not a parent either, or you'd understand why these corps that market to children DO need to be held responsible for what their platforms enable.
 
You seem blissfully unaware of why you ALREADY should not support Discord or use their servers. I'll let you google it. Or you can watch Gamers Nexus' latest video to learn more. (Prolly a LOT more.)

And you obviously are not a parent either, or you'd understand why these corps that market to children DO need to be held responsible for what their platforms enable.
And you obviously are unaware of how much you should watch your children instead of relying on corporations to do your job, because that's what happen when parents can't do their job.
 
I mean why should i waste precious time on discord if they are better apps but i wont give `em my valuable info.
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum