It was never intended as such, hence my spiel in the opening message.
I'm not Japanese, i'm not intimately familiar with Japanese culture, i don't speak Japanese, and i don't feel it's a requisite to learn Japanese to be entertained by some anime. Of that i've watched i can't recall anything that's been really badly dubbed, and if it was i wouldn't watch it because i'd find it irritating, or if it was something really good i'd put up with subs.
However, i'd rather see things in my own language. Is it going to ruin my enjoyment if the anime is slightly westernised or changed a bit because of it? I doubt it (I promise i won't tell the creators if you don't either...) I play video games made in Japan with English VA's and i don't really see that much difference from watching animes with English dubs.The language differences alone (pitch, pacing, tonality) make it more difficult to "relate" to the characters and situations i watch.
I understand most people who are really into anime like it in it's original language. I also know i'm missing out on some really good anime that's not dubbed yet. Perhaps i'm just lazy. Who knows and who cares? I just wanted some recommendations of good English dubs....
I don't particularly enjoy listening to japanese VA's (i watch dub wherever possible), but you do miss out on a ton of good animes that way, and even still you have to wait quite a while for animes to be dubbed.
Anyway I only read the OP so forgive me if any of these were suggested.
Pani Poni Dash (comedy, it's hilarious but a little dated graphically)
Ef - A Tale of Memories (drama, romance, some comedy)
Ef - A Tale of Melodies (just released, drama, romance. Dunno how the dub is though, i've only seen Memories so far, it was solid)
Air (you watched Clannad/Kanon/Angel Beats, but not Air?)
The Third (action, comedy, drama)
When They Cry (pure epic, only season 1 is dubbed though...gotta ride the sub train for season 2. Worth it though)
Chobits (comedy, drama, ...romance?)
Darker than BLACK (...epic? I dunno tags for it. Action, bit of drama)
Fate/stay night (doesn't have shit on the VN or Fate/zero, but hell it's still great)
Kurokami (comedy?, action, drama, bit of romance but not really)
Phantom ~Requiem for the Phantom~ (Pure. Win.)
Shuffle! (comedy, drama, romance)
Shakugan No Shana (again, season 1 is dubbed...S2 and 3 unfortunately aren't. Good series though)
Strawberry Marshmallow (comedy)
Strike Witches (it's remarkably serious considering all the pervy/ecchi crap they mix in, action)
Utawarerumono (drama, action)
Eden of the East (dubbed and even all the movies are AFAIR, great series)
Canaan (drama, action, a decent amount of comedy mixed in)
Bolded are my 3 top choices, though they're all good.
Ef is a pretty visual anime, and i've yet to see one like it. It's quite beautiful.
Phantom is just epic.
I never realized I had so many dubbed animes in my folder till I scrolled through it to make a list, haha.