The Saga of the Fake adata 128 gb cards...

So, I'm a member of a facebook group that buys and sells stuff, mostly it's used stuff like designer handbags and other things.

I was browsing and saw a post for "Brand New adata 128 gigabyte micro SD cards" for $35 a piece. So red flags are raised and I was thinking "How the hell can someone offer these for such a cheap price?" (Keep in mind that these retail for $54.99 + taxes.) I go online and ask the seller why they are so cheap - and she says that she bought them in bulk. That's reasonable, and I think that adata are a smaller brand, so there is less of an issue of getting faked cards.

We set up a meeting time, and I go and meet up with her at a local McDonalds. I pay $90 for three of the cards, and they came wrapped up nicely in foam/bubble wrap.

I finally get home after buying cold medicine and eating lunch at a pizza place, and I excitedly toss one of the cards onto the laptop. It is mounted as a separate drive, and boom - it shows up as 250 gigabytes. Warning, warning, warning. So I grab h2testw and start running it on the card. 16 hours later, it shows me that the card is just an 8 gb card faked into a full 250 gb card. Keep in mind that it's like 7:50 am in the morning when I find this out later.

I text the seller all morning and not a single answer. I'm getting mad because it's a waste of my damn time and my money and the seller still does not respond. I go out with my dad for lunch and we head to the library. All the time my phone is turned on - and I even phoned the seller three times normally from my cell phone. It's like 1:30 pm now. I finally get home again and I decide to file a police report online - my hometown as a great system, although it's unfriendly to those to don't read English. I took photos of the memory cards AND the h2testw results. Luckily, because these serve as evidence in my police report. So after all that, I end up filing the report, and I finally got in touch with the seller via facebook messaging. (I settle with ordering two 64 gb cards from Amazon to replace the junk I had.)

She asks me to check out the rest of the cards and I do. One of them reports as 32 gb, and the other was a 250 gb card. I tell her that I've filed a police report and she gets angry. She finally calms down when I tell her that she probably has been ripped off as well. I finish the testing of the "32 gb" card, and it reports that it's a single 16 gb card that again has been faked to report it as 32 gb on a computer. She uses my photo of the h2testw to talk to the wholesaler, and we conclude the conversation saying that we should meet up next week for a refund. She also removes the adverts from the "buy and sell" place that we are both using.

So Friday rolls around, and I get a email saying that my police report has been approved. I fill in a supplemental form that reports the rest of our conversation and now I'm just waiting for a bloody answer.

TL:DR: I buy high capacity 128 gb adata cards from a local seller, and find out that they are "really bad fakes". I try to get in touch with the seller, fail and finally resort to filing a police report along with the photo proof of those awful fakes. We finally talk and the seller removes her advertisements from the site, and she gets in touch with the wholesaler. The police approve my case and actually give me a case number.

Pictures of the Cards in Question:

August 19 2016 Update:
Yes, I'm an idiot and didn't notice the SDHC thing on it. I blame the fact that I had the sniffles from a nasty ass cold (still sick, but medicine is making me feel...at least human).

So, we talked, and the idiot lady has tested her micro SD cards, and she was getting the 250+ gb results on her end. Problem is that she's just a cell phone tech, so that she just knows how to test with cell phone apps, which really don't do a good job on them. And she got stonewalled by the wholesaler (not surprised, because honey, they are a big time scammer - and I don't care how much positive feedback they have).

She's not shipping them back because it's hella expensive, but she's selling them locally (I'm going to be avoiding adata brand micro sds for a long while now). She promised me a full refund (because I told her that I modify Nintendo 3DSes for extra money), and that I can keep the shitty card I opened. Hooray, now I have a fake adata branded micro SD adapter. I don't know if I should cry OR cheer.

On the front with the police report, I added in extra information, that I've spoken to the seller and she promised me a full refund. And they emailed me back that they won't pursue the matter now. I feel like adding another form and asking them to check up on her. I just hope her other customers realize that they got scammed and go to the police.

You know what's shitty? She didn't respond me to until I threatened her with the cops. I still smell a scammer, but whatever...
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people

Comments

sdhc should have pulled the alarm bells, no respectable sd manufacturer makes a misstake like that... up till 2 gb is sd, from above 2 gb up to 32 gb's is sdhc and above is called sdxc (limits of xc are still uncertain to me)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
Just looking at that packaging and the card alone smells of fake all over it, and I wouldn't have even sealed a deal then and instead cancelled it off. Anything sounding too good to be true, is always a catch.
 
T
Hope you the best of luck. Something similar that happened to me is, on Amazon I bout a micro sd card with adapter. To my surprise even though it wasn't advertised I got a straight up microsd to USB adapter too so bonus! The micro sd works, only weird thing is that it's printed (wasn't advertised by the way) as 2 gb micro SDHC! Didn't do anything with the seller though because I got a bonus item plus it works! Again best of luck though :P
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
@ Jack Daniels - I was sick as a dog, and I bought stuff from her because it would arrive sooner than my Amazon order, and I thought I could put it a cheap high capacity thing into my phone.

I still feel like she's a filthy scammer. Her posting on that site just used a stock picture of the adata 128 SDXC card, probably pulled from some legit site, instead of actually taking a photo of the real card. They were wrapped in foam/bubble wrap, probably to throw off people that they looked strange. And her reaction to me using h2testw was strange - maybe your test program corrupted it? Yeah, because the gold standard in testing SD cards can corrupt a card.

She can't be this much of an idiot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
personally wouldnt buy any SD cards unless i can go back to where i bought it i.e they are being sold in a real shop (by the shop, not just some random guy asking to meet in pcworld) you really should have just bought the one at first if you did feel like taking the risk

also try put out a lil PSA on the buying group and local gumtree/craigslist sites to stop he offloading them on other unsuspecting people.

just out of curiosity if you have a android phone with a SD slot can you give this app a try
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.humanlogic.sdi&hl=en_GB
i just had a lil test, all my genuine cards checked out, and i have one fake SD which was identified as invalid, just wondering if this could help people out and about quickly identify fake SD card, only problem is its based on the vendor info of the card, idk how hard it would be for people to spoof that info to pass as legit
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
I agree with Vins.
This is exactly the reason why I buy me SD cards in stores.
Preferably the ones that are a tenner more then the normal ones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
tbh $35 is a reasonnable price for a 128GB micro SD card. I got a (legit, of course) 128GB SanDisk Ultra micro SD for €40 on amazon back in february.
 
he did buy it in a store....McDonalds :tpi:

but yeah, always buy from reputable retail stores where you know you can get a refund if it does turn out to be fake, as i have read a few stories of people getting the odd fake even from normal retail shops, idk if they were full of crap, if someone bought one and took a fake back, resulting in a fake being sold or if some fakes slipped into the supply chain but always shop where you know you can get a refund,


also people wanting to meet up away from their home is another telltale sign that someone is fully aware of a issue and wants to make sure you cant go knocking when you find out the issue....ofc it could just be paranoia on their part, but for me if im buying something from a local resale page and the seller wants to meet up away from their home it would make me want to think twice about what could be wrong
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
@ gamesquest1 I sell stuff away from home because I live at home, and I hate my parents to constantly be involved in what I'm doing. (Which is modding and selling 3DSes, because they are nosey and want to know why I'm making money like that. The job market is shit? I can't network to save my life?)

I usually buy my sd cards in store, but this sickness kind of caught me off-guard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
no problem with people who do prefer to make deals away from their home, its just adds another warning flag if your already suspicious, kinda like a 3 strikes and your out,
1. commonly risky item (i.e larger sized SD cards for being fake, mobile phones for being stolen and getting blocked after buying)
2. cheaper than normal price
3. no address you can chase them up at if things go wrong
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person

Blog entry information

Author
astrangeone
Views
393
Comments
32
Last update

More entries in Personal Blogs

More entries from astrangeone

General chit-chat
Help Users
    K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2: https://youtu.be/yvivDdRirLA?si=R7xWO-6_-Qa0DDml