Gaming Heart Gold or Soul Silver?

[The Catboy]

Originally I had pokemon silver, so I'm going with soulsilver :3

Same reason why I choose Soul Silver as well

Oh nozzzzzzzz! You broke your leet post

On noooo~~~ I didn't even notice that >.

 

[Guild McCommunist]

Ho-oh sucks balls. 4x Rock weakness blows, especially with all the powerful Rock moves introduced in the 4th Gen.

Lugia is a lot better. Better typing, no 4x weakness, better moves, etc.

Silver also looks cooler than Gold.

Still, I'd just buy neither and pirate them.

 

[outgum]

Silver, box arts better...
Plus has some good exclusives

 

[Ryukouki]

Originally I had Pokemon Silver but now I want Heart Gold and Soul Silver.

 

[KoopaTim]

Ho-oh sucks balls. 4x Rock weakness blows, especially with all the powerful Rock moves introduced in the 4th Gen.

Lugia is a lot better. Better typing, no 4x weakness, better moves, etc.

Silver also looks cooler than Gold.

Still, I'd just buy neither and pirate them.

Funny thing is, if you like Lugia better he's in Heart Gold at lvl 70, so the most used argument not to get one game or the other just turns invalid.

 

[kineticUk]

Soul Silver.

 

[elixirdream]

Heart Gold..
i like how ho-oh looks

 

[Brocktree]

Heart Gold. 'cause Ho-oh is colourful.

 

[Aeladya]

Ho-oh looks like it's going to eat me...I'll stick with SoulSilver thanks

. I can't be haunted by that cover

.

 

[Raika]

I used to own the GBC Silver version, so I guess I'll go with Heart Gold now, that and I find the Heart Gold exclusives more appealing than the Soul Silver ones.

 

[Revolution89]

Soul Silver, I still have my silver catridge(covered in dust in my closet with my gboy) and Lugia is one of my fav legend.

 

[5%]

Originally I had pokemon silver, so I'm going with soulsilver :3

Same reason why I choose Soul Silver as well

Likewise EH!! Oh man, The days of playing Silver on the GBC...Those were the days man, those were the days...The young days where I would be able spot the dolphins first before the couple:

 

[ericling]

I am gettting Soul Silver!
The pokemon I like most in the Soul Silver except Groudon.
I want Kyogre~

 

[SonicRax]

Both: I'm gonna 'acquire' SoulSilver once it's out, and then buy HeartGold, because it's the version I played through when I was a kid.

 

[Leamonde.Halcyon]

Oh wow I remember that picture XD
I saw it first when I was 10 and saw dolphins. I didn't see it again until i was 17 and did a double take

Soul Silver all the way. I had a great game on my original Silver cartridge but it got stolen, along with my gameboy color out of my backpack at school. :/ That was incredibly depressing.

 

[5%]

Oh wow I remember that picture XD
I saw it first when I was 10 and saw dolphins. I didn't see it again until i was 17 and did a double take

Wow, it's been around for that long huh? Man, I wonder if I can get it as a poster...I'd frame it & hang it up in my living room. One of the greatest illusions ever without eh doubt EH

 

[Hakoda]

I'm going with Soul Silver

 

[Leamonde.Halcyon]

Oh wow I remember that picture XD
I saw it first when I was 10 and saw dolphins. I didn't see it again until i was 17 and did a double take

Wow, it's been around for that long huh? Man, I wonder if I can get it as a poster...I'd frame it & hang it up in my living room. One of the greatest illusions ever without eh doubt EH

Well I'm 21 now and I first saw it when I was 10

I don't know if it's been around longer but that's the minimum.
It would be a great poster if I didn't live at home and have 2 sisters at 11 and 6. My mom would kill me.

 

[5%]

Oh wow I remember that picture XD
I saw it first when I was 10 and saw dolphins. I didn't see it again until i was 17 and did a double take

Wow, it's been around for that long huh? Man, I wonder if I can get it as a poster...I'd frame it & hang it up in my living room. One of the greatest illusions ever without eh doubt EH

Well I'm 21 now and I first saw it when I was 10

I don't know if it's been around longer but that's the minimum.
It would be a great poster if I didn't live at home and have 2 sisters at 11 and 6. My mom would kill me.

Lol I'd get the poster solely for my parents outraged reactions..."What are you talking about? It's just a poster of dolphins!"

 

[dukemagus]

someone highlight the dolphins please... i can't see it

and i will get soul silver... lugia looks cooler

Ho-oh sucks balls. 4x Rock weakness blows, especially with all the powerful Rock moves introduced in the 4th Gen.

Lugia is a lot better. Better typing, no 4x weakness, better moves, etc.

Still, I'd just buy neither and pirate them.

Karen, Elite 4 Says

"Strong Pokémon. Weak Pokémon. That is only the selfish perception of people. Truly skilled trainers should try to win with their favorites. I like your style. You understand what's important. Go on--the Champion is waiting."