1. alexander1970

    OP alexander1970 Pink Profilepagebackground for Christmas please.
    Member

    Joined:
    Nov 8, 2018
    Messages:
    11,185
    Country:
    Austria
    Hello.:)

    Today I made my first Experience with this "Kind" of Games.I was never interested before so I had no Idea what this could be.

    Medieval Dynasty (Steam) PC

    The Game looks awesome and the Gameplay sounds also very promising and very interesting.

    Thank God,I have read a little in the Reviews.
    This Game is far from "finished".....

    So it is like the good old Demos on the Magazine CDs/DVDs earlier ?
    But.....19,99 Euro for an far from "ready to go" Game ?
    As I said, I was new to this type of Game and was really surprised.

    Playing Alpha/Beta Tester and should PAY for this Game DEMO ?

    I have really missed a lot in Gaming the last Years I think.:(

    How about you,fellow Gaming Community ?
    What is your "Point of View" ?

    Thank you for your Opinons and Contributions.:)
     
    Last edited by alexander1970, Sep 22, 2020
  2. emigre

    emigre i am a free i am not man a number
    Member

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2009
    Messages:
    8,366
    Country:
    United Kingdom
    There's nothing wrong with it.

    Early access helps ease the cashflow problem when it comes to games. Users should be fully aware when they get something in early access, they're not having a full game or things may change.

    The issue is if the Devs or Piblisher are misleading (AKA lie) about the level of completion, contents and so on.
     
    Flame, Taleweaver and alexander1970 like this.
  3. Taleweaver

    Taleweaver Storywriter
    Member

    Joined:
    Dec 23, 2009
    Messages:
    7,690
    Country:
    Belgium
    Heh...it's a nice post and an honest question, but...is this really your first encounter? It's almost as if you've been living under a rock for almost four or five years. :P

    No, this is certainly NOT comparable. While both are meant to get the word out for the game, they do so in very different styles. In fact, the "getting the word out" is perhaps the only similarity.

    Demo's are when parts of a game that is "done" (or 'gone gold', to use the proper term) are publicly released for the general audience for free. This gives them an idea of what the game looks like, how it plays and whether or not it plays smoothly.This might be only a few levels, a few characters of the total roster, or even have some important parts (weapons) missing.

    Early access games aren't done yet. You pay either full price or a part of it(1), but in a state that might not represent the game how it ends up being. The idea is that developers listen to suggestions and crowdsource bug-finding, whereas eager gamers can get their hands on games before the "main audience" gets it.

    The definition of "a state that might not represent the game" is a bit of a dodgy one, though. Some developers release an open access the moment they've got a working beta version, others when they've squished all bugs they've found and want to test the audience's waters early.

    A few examples from my own experience:
    -factorio has been in early access for nearly ten years. The devs have always added and tweaked their game, so by the time I got in (only a few months before actual release) I couldn't get it to crash no matter what I tried. The fact that people have put many tens of thousands of gaming hours into it also meant the thing was as stable as it could be
    -parkitect was a fun one to watch develop (it was a rollercoaster tycoon kind of game). Nearly every week, there were blog posts of what the developers were doing, what was added, tweaked or fixed. I (finally) got the game well after a year of such weekly updates, but the game was still quite barren. That is to say: it had just a sandbox mode where you could plop down rides and 'somewhat' monitor your peeps. The whole scenario and premade parks were added much later. Rides and stalls were also only gradually added, though it had quite a decent selection when I got around to buying it.
    -cook, serve, delicious 2 was...a different kind of early access. I can't really remember how I got in touch with the (sole) developer, but we mailed each other even before he came around to publicly announcing the sequel to CSD 1 (which I absolutely adore). However, it quickly became clear that when he had his group of testers, he had done most of the ground work. This isn't to say we weren't influential, but it meant actively searching for bugs and QoL improvements that might or might not make the cut.

    In any case: I would look at early access games individually. I've read 'reviews' on quite a few games that were abandoned before they ever really got to a state of being ready. You also pay full price for a game of which you know will be of lesser quality than upon release. So I'd only buy it if A) you are certain that the game is of decent stable quality (factorio is the de facto example), B) you're a big fan of what the developers want to achieve (CSD 2, in my case), and/or C) you've got enough trust that they keep working at it until release (the weekly updates of parkitect drew me over the line).
    Ideally, I'd go only for it if at least two of those match,but ey...it's your money. :P


    Nope. As outlined earlier: you pay for the full game. If you want, you can even buy the game and then leave it in your backlog until it "properly" releases. In a way, you lend the developer the cost to create the game. He just repays with the game, that's all.

    (1): I've seen games that were in development for years and gradually became more expensive. Or from the other perspective: the earlier you buy the game, the cheaper you'll get it.
     
    Last edited by Taleweaver, Sep 22, 2020
  4. Tom Bombadildo

    Tom Bombadildo Dick, With Balls
    Reviewer

    Joined:
    Jul 11, 2009
    Messages:
    13,630
    Country:
    United States
    emigre hit the nail on the head, there's nothing wrong with Early Access itself, it's a good way for small teams to get the financial backing they need to actually make the game they want to make.

    Without Early Access we probably wouldn't have things like Factorio, Subnautica, Dead Cells, Ark, Kerbal Space Program, Besiege, Darkest Dungeon, Don't Starve, DayZ, PUBG, etc etc, all excellent games that likely wouldn't have taken off in the state they are had the devs not been able to get some cash flow going early on.

    You just have to make sure you curb your expectations when you see an Early Access game, if you're buying into XYZ whatever expecting anything other than a buggy mess with none of the promised features than you're just better off waiting for the game to release.
     
    Flame and alexander1970 like this.
  5. alexander1970

    OP alexander1970 Pink Profilepagebackground for Christmas please.
    Member

    Joined:
    Nov 8, 2018
    Messages:
    11,185
    Country:
    Austria
    Fascinating,my Friend.:D

    Thank you for your Explanations.
    As I said,I had nothing to do with that Kind of Games.

    I do not meant,Early Access Games has no "Justification for existence".:D

    My "first Look" was - Demo/unfinished Game and I should pay for it ? :blink:


    One Point I not agree::rofl2:

    Bought Resident Evil 2 + 3 Remake long before the released....69,99 € for each and now...79,98 @ in Bundle.....:teach:
    but ok - no Early Access Games,I think.:P


    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Thank you for your Perspektive(s).:)
    I will make possible "future" Early Access Buys according to these selection Criterias:

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Thank you for your Contribution.:)
    As I said:

    I was surprised,because I did not know about this Kind of Games.
    My "old fashioned" Demo Game Thoughts were not correct here.:)
     
    Flame likes this.
Draft saved Draft deleted
Loading...

Hide similar threads Similar threads with keywords - Opinion, Access, Early