I consider this one special because it was still back in the day when the N64 was relevant. This was 2000, maybe 2001 tops. We all loved to rent WcW/nWO Revenge and Wrestlemania 2000 and play mutliplayer so we just thought this would be a good time.
It was like... unanimous disdain. Both me and my cousins agreed it was the worst game we had ever rented. We could barely play it. It wasn't easy to return it so we just played the other game we had rented instead of this one.
I still remember how unanimous the sentiment was. It was like we were watching something sacrilegeous. Years went by and we all remembered: yeah, that was the worst game we've played. 20 years have passed and I don't keep in touch with any of my two female cousins but I'm sure if mention it they will still remember how much we loathed this one.
Surely I played something worse on emulators as years passed by, but that doesn't change how much this one left a mark.