I highly recommend Retro Game Challenge if you were playing games in the 1980's. This game is a gift to everyone who grew up on the nes. Doesn't matter what genre you like, because it includes many genres. Truly my GOTY choice so far, and its only FEB. LOL "Beer Shower"
Also, I have been playing Dragon Quest IV, and am up to chapter 4. Its a great RPG that actually makes me work for my goals. ie: having to really search for info, and look everywhere to proceed, while sometimes being stumped for hours. I am playing every day so I can be ready for Dragon Quest V. But that might have to wait, because the Fan-translation of DQ III Super Famicom is coming VERY soon. Anyway, some of the post PSX Final Fantasy only people might not like it, but I sure do.