Hacking SX OS will be better than Atmosphere.

[kingfrost]

Simply - can't. But you ever heard of deducing?

Dedecution is another word for a hypothesis which is another word for a theory.

Which means you haven't got any factual proof.

 

[lordelan]

I love Shiny's work but as he's been banned from ReSwitched's Discord it's no suprise he doesn't have that much love for them.

 

[Naked_Snake]

Inb4 deleted

--------------------- MERGED ---------------------------

SciresM hasn’t been banned you wanker

 

[CTCaer]

From what I seen a lot of expert devs are saying that atmosphere code is very shitty
And SX OS is made by a experimented and professional team so I’m certain their cfw is way better

That speculation is not correct though.
Open source programs need to be at least decent.

On the other hand closed source code is almost always a mess, because the main driver here is "make something that just works".

Most companies I worked for, had a hacky "just able to work" code.

In the end, I don't understand why there's a need to have such a comparison. I thought that the user only wants something that just works and has what he needs.

 

[Jackson98]

I wouldn't be surprised if SX OS turned out superior to Atmosphere, however I wouldn't be surprise if SX OS is much more likely to get you banned, as its mainly targeting piracy, whereas Atmosphere's main focus is emulation.

 

[Red1Reaper]

Dedecution is another word for a hypothesis which is another word for a theory.

Which means you haven't got any factual proof.

hypothesis and theory are not the same word, https://www.diffen.com/difference/Hypothesis_vs_Theory

 

[Rune]

I like how this thread is just speculation lmao

I don't like it at all. I'm getting tired of this shit.

 

[Red1Reaper]

I don't like it at all. I'm getting tired of this shit.

I was mostly making a little fun of the OP sience a few minutes ago he posted that exact phrase in another thread, then go and create a thread about speculation, i just liked the irony
This is what i mean:

I like how this thread is just speculation lmao

 

[leon315]

i wonder how much money did TX pay to this troll to discredit Atmosphere....

 

[NeoSlyde]

Really? Because by making the thread, you obviously wanted a discussion exactly like this otherwise you would have kept it to yourself. Or perhaps even titled it differently.

You dug your grave. Now lie in it.

Lol like I care

 

[lembi2001]

Inb4 deleted

--------------------- MERGED ---------------------------

SciresM hasn’t been banned you wankerView attachment 131352

no one said he had did they??

 

[kingfrost]

hypothesis and theory are not the same word, https://www.diffen.com/difference/Hypothesis_vs_Theory

Only scientifically and this isn't science. They are synonyms in the English language.

Use a thesaurus if you don't believe me.

no one said he had did they??

Yeah I don't see where anyone said that either.

 

[Deleted-351540]

Lol like I care

But you do. You made the thread to start controversy, then got butthurt when we called you out on it.

You care.

 

[NeoSlyde]

But you do. You made the thread to start controversy, then got butthurt when we called you out on it.

You care.

lol nah

 

[aerios169]

Well gateway was better than Luma, right now luma is the best, is just time to it happens there too

 

[NeoSlyde]

Well gateway was better than Luma, right now luma is the best, is just time to it happens there too

How much time between the two?

 

[IPLbug]

Ha. Ha. No.

To offer the opinion of a former 3DS CFW dev, Atmosphere is pretty freaking well coded. It's taking so long because they're not patching components of the OS, they're writing open source reimplementations with extra functionality to support the CFW use case.



If you find reading and understanding an unfamiliar codebase to be a nightmare, you should quit programming. People do this all the time - it's in the nature of open source to need to do this, or for that matter, multiple people working on the same project.



Decide the specifications of the project before you implement it. I've been bit by that more than once.



I disagree. Atmosphere is organized in a rational manner. It's componentized, and how it functions from a higher level is clear: it's not patching anything, it's replacing chunks of the OS with re-implementations. Each of these individual components are obviously in flux, but what they must provide for API is already quite well defined by nintendo. It's lacking in the documentation department, but that's to be expected at the moment.



No, it will not be more polished. It will be ready first, but it will not be more polished. Atmosphere is taking so long because they're doing it the right way, as in zero code patches but replaced components of the OS. This is in contrast to every other CFW in existence which uses some if not all code patches. These people have been doing reverse engineering, documentation, and programming for years. I find it hard to believe an unknown team who's contributed nothing can do a better job and isn't just leeching off open source work.

Also, paid professionals do not make for a better product nor code.

It's not about understanding a code base it rather I'll say my work ethic.
I hate sloppy code and I know it could have been done more efficiently in terms of atmosphere There many areas where you could save tons of time using more complicated methods now(delaying release time a bit) making future code maintenance a lot easier in my eyes vs the current approach that from past exp I know will be a pain to maintain structure wise.

On the subject of tx OS you can have your opinion/bias but you can't say from what's been show it's not a way cleaner option vs the hetake builds in the wild at this moment in time. Just from a operation stand point there payload seems a lot more polished(gui,options ease of use ) atlest for the general public. But that's just my opinion and it mite be strictly bias as I Mainly deal with POS software with bug hunting as a hobby.

You do make some points I can agree with but with not many so let's cut it down to agree to disagree before the kids start taking thread to flame on others work with no respect to its maker

 

[Ooka]

"open source is almost always better"

https://www.coredna.com/blogs/comparing-open-closed-source-software

The quality of hobby work does not compare to the work that people create for their livelyhood, for lots of reasons. I love open source and am part of a few open source projects myself, but I would always pick the paid alternatives for a production environment.

 

[TheFatassOfKicka]

This is what happens when you don't think things through before you make silly claims.

 

[leonmagnus99]

it was whoever gets them gamez backup to load first wins, tx did that and won over tons of ppl i guess.

no biggie, but in the end the non dongle requirement CFWs are usually the ones that come on top.