Ocarina of Time overthrown

[coolbho3000]

http://www.gamerankings.com/itemrankings/s....asp?rankings=y

Hope this will last!

 

[fightabunny]

Dear God.

The apocalypse has arisen.

 

[Hooya]

Kinda awesome that 4 of the top 6 are Nintendo games, and 3 of the top six are Half Life 2, essentially. Way to be Nintendo!

 

[Mieki]

OH NOES!

But at least it's Mario...

 

[2cb2ct7]

Yeh I am not that surprised actually... Nintendo has been the most innovative of the home console companies since its conception.

Where are all the PS and XBOX fanbois now huh?!

(I'm no fanboy BTW, I own a Wii, X360, NDS and PSP

)

 

[Lumstar]

Well, here I am.

An Xbox fanboy who did *NOT* buy Halo 3, Bioshock, or The Orange Box.

 

[2cb2ct7]

Well, here I am.

An Xbox fanboy who did *NOT* buy Halo 3, Bioshock, or The Orange Box.

Well obviously you're no fanboy

 

[CockroachMan]

How can the Orange Box be judge as only one game!?

 

[TheStump]

^ good point, thats like saying. Warcraft III battle chess is a single game.
Its sort of just a pack! each game is separate and should be judged like that. I could just release a box set of HL:2, Mario Galaxy and Zelda and call it the awesome box, would this go to number 1?

 

[Digeman]

I could just release a box set of HL:2, Mario Galaxy and Zelda and call it the awesome box

That comment made my day!

 

[cubin']

tekken 3 and soul caliber? they're good games but not top 10 good. metroid prime 3 shouldn't be up there either IMO.

haven't played enough galaxy yet but it seems pretty good

dunno about best game of all time though?

 

[OSW]

whats with this site? how popular is it?

i don't think it's fair considering how long ocarina of time has been out in comparison to orange box and mario galaxy! they haven't had the time to properly even out ratings from the numbers of voters.

 

[jumpman17]

The site doesn't average user ratings. It averages ratings from sites like IGN and Gamespot and magazines too.

 

[Maikel Steneker]

Nice

Yesterday it had an average of 97,5%, which made it a close second to Ocarina of Time. I hope it will stay this way for a while!

 

[coolbho3000]

The site doesn't average user ratings. It averages ratings from sites like IGN and Gamespot and magazines too.

That's only because user ratings are fanboy altered.

 

[Trulen]

Ocarina of Time!?
Overthrown!!?

Finally.

Ocarina of Time was good, no doubt about it.

But the best Zelda experience I've ever had was Link to the Past. Now THAT was a Zelda game.

But I've had more fun playing some other games than the Zelda series.

 

[hollabackitsobi]

lol top 3 are Nintendo franchise headliners. Only Nintendo could beat themselves...but Ocarina and especially MAJORA will always be classics. I think Majora is the best game of all time, I love EVERYTHING about that game. No seriously, I adore it. I was so much a part of my childhood and it was such a fun and wonderful game...

 

[Foie]

Hey, the "trio" take up the top three spots! Mario, Zelda, and Metroid

I REALLY need to get Galaxy now.

 

[Seraph]

tekken 3 and soul caliber? they're good games but not top 10 good. metroid prime 3 shouldn't be up there either IMO.

haven't played enough galaxy yet but it seems pretty good

dunno about best game of all time though?

It's actually the first Metroid Prime which I think is deserving of that position(actually it deserves #2). I don't think SMG gave me the same feeling when I played MP and Ocarina of Time/Majora's Mask. I wish they could have just changed things back to first game for MP's sequels, and I sort of view MM as one huge side quest to OoT. Soul Calibur was an awesome game though so not really sure if it deserves it or not.

Compare the number of reviews for each game on the site though. Metroid Prime and RE4 manage to stay up there with their approximate 100 reviews. And I feel those titles deserve top spots. If you also look on other sites, SMG hasn't passed Zelda because of different number of reviews on both titles.

 

[Linkiboy]

Even though I am a huge Zelda fanboy, Galaxy deserves that spot.