Nintendo DS: 2D Games vs 3D games

Discussion in 'General Off-Topic Chat' started by tigris, Feb 20, 2011.

?

2D Nintendo DS or 3D Gameplay?

  1. 2D Flat Sprites (e.g, Chrono Trigger)

    1 vote(s)
    100.0%
  2. 3D Polygonal Models (e.g, FFCC Series)

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  3. 3D Condensed Sprite Models [idk what they're called](e.g, DQIX, SaGa 2)

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  1. tigris
    OP

    tigris Sentient Existential Anthropomorphic Sweet Potato

    Member
    2,689
    239
    Jun 19, 2010
    The Tibetan Himalayas
    Just to defuse some of the hype, which game type do you like on the original Nintendo DS?



    [​IMG]
    2D (examples being proper game remakes from NES, SNES, etc. and native 2D games)
    • Chrono Trigger
    • Dragon Quest IV: Realms of Revelation



    [​IMG]
    3D (examples being native 3D 'compressed sprite' games like DQIX and Inazuma Eleven, and also real 3D Polygonal models.)
    • Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles
    • Suikoden Tierkreis


    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    3D Condensed (examples being DQIX and SaGa 2, compressed sprites which appear to be more visually pleasing when presented to you)
    • Dragon Quest IX
    • SaGa 2
     
  2. Ikki

    Ikki GBATemp's grumpy panda.

    Member
    2,797
    49
    Jun 1, 2010
    Uruguay
    Montevideo
    It depends on the game. Some devs use each style better than others. Thus I won't vote.
     
  3. Fear Zoa

    Fear Zoa Still Alive

    Member
    1,437
    422
    Jun 18, 2009
    United States
    Maryland
    I really like the style of the FFCC series ...but thats just the way they used it....chrono trigger is well done too.....I like all the art styles as long as they are used correctly
     
  4. ineap09

    ineap09 GBAtemp Regular

    Member
    285
    0
    Nov 18, 2010
    Guyana
    Many places. O_O MemeLove: 4/5
    I can't vote. When all are done well, there's no way I could choose one over the other.
     
  5. machomuu

    machomuu Drops by occasionally

    Member
    8,441
    599
    Sep 4, 2009
    United States
    The Courtroom
    It's not really fair to count Chrono Trigger as it's a port, not a remake (though it has a better translation and a few new scenarios).

    Also, I can't vote as the experience varies on the game. I mean, I believe Rune Factory 3 would be just as fun as a 2D game
     
  6. Raika

    Raika uguu

    Member
    4,866
    10
    Sep 15, 2008
    uguu
    I like all of them... [​IMG]
     
  7. PeregrinFig

    PeregrinFig A miserable little pile of secrets

    Member
    667
    0
    Jun 18, 2010
    United States
    Michigan
    I didn't vote, because it all depends on the game, not the graphical style. All of the example games listed that I've played were good games, but the graphics weren't the reason for this.
     
  8. tigris
    OP

    tigris Sentient Existential Anthropomorphic Sweet Potato

    Member
    2,689
    239
    Jun 19, 2010
    The Tibetan Himalayas
    I mean, purely for graphical style, guys. Purely based on the game, which style would suit it best.
     
  9. Narayan

    Narayan desu~

    Member
    2,921
    825
    Sep 29, 2010
    i can't vote yet. i don't understand much of 2D and 3D. where does, TWEWY, Touch Detective, Kingdom Hearts: ReCoded, Final Fantasy The 4 Heroes of Light, Mario and Luigi Bowser's Inside Story and Rune Factory 3 belong?
     
  10. KingVamp

    KingVamp Great... AETHER!

    Member
    10,149
    1,870
    Sep 13, 2009
    United States
    I like all graphical styles tho...

    Wait never mine I see then my answer still stands.
     
  11. Shabutie78

    Shabutie78 GBAtemp Fan

    Member
    437
    12
    Jul 6, 2010
    United States
    TWEWY - 2D sprites
    touch detective - "3D condensed"
    Kingdom Hearts - "3D condensed"
    FF:4HOL - 3D polygons
    mario RPG 3 - 2D sprites
    rune factory 3 - 3D polygons

    also, tigris, you put DQIX in as examples for two different art styles.
     
  12. Narayan

    Narayan desu~

    Member
    2,921
    825
    Sep 29, 2010
    based on this, i can't really choose just one, cause i like these games' graphics.

    but if i have to really choose it's 3d condensed but twewy looks so good. pokemon too.
     
  13. Shabutie78

    Shabutie78 GBAtemp Fan

    Member
    437
    12
    Jul 6, 2010
    United States
    to be honest, i can't choose one either.
    but i think that since the DS can't really pull off general 3D all that well, 2D sprite games look best on it.
    look at shantae: risky's revenge, super mario RPG, or final fantasy tactics advance 2.
    now compare those to general 3D games on the DS and it puts them to shame :/

    that doesn't mean i like 2D sprite games the most though, i think game developers know when to use which type of graphics for each game, and consider the limits of the DS's graphics. i like them all.

    except, i think new super mario brothers should have been 2D sprites.
    the 3D is too cheap, and doesn't give SMB justice.
    during the life span of the DS i have been waiting for a 2D sprite traditional sidescrolling SMB (think new super mario brothers with mario rpg or even super mario world style graphics)
    but obviously that's not gonna happen :/