Pokemon Diamond: (the first pokemon game I ever played)
At first I was like: What? Pokemon? That's fuckin' kiddie shit.
But then I was like: Check out mah BAD-ASS Heracross! In a premier ball, yo!
Rune Factory:
At first I was like: I've gotta grow crops? Are you serious? Where's the action in that?
But then I was like: Woot! My strawberry crops are coming in, and after that I'm forging the Heaven Asunder sword and kicking some ass!
Peggle DS:
At first I was like: What is this? Some love-child of pinball and plinko?
But then I was like: OMG you're gonna love this game! It's like the love child of pinball and plinko!
World of Goo:
At first I was like: Man, this looks like my 4 year old niece drew it. NES games looked better than this shit.
But then I was like: Waaaaiiiit fooorrr iiiitttt NOW! Add-a-black-goo-move-that-balloon-add-another-goo! WOO HOO! I got the obsessive compulsion distinction! Take THAT, Fisty!
("Are you playing that game on a...toaster?" "Yeah. It's also running on the deep fryer and that dead badger over there, but the controls are easier on the toaster.")
Rhythm Heaven:
At first I was like: Oh blah blah, tap with the beat, this is gonna suuuuck.
But then I was like: *catches himself singing Moai Doo-Wop in his head at work*