Umm...Turns out I named it "payload" instead of "payloads" *facepalm* Renamed it and now when I hold start it boots GodMode9, but it gives me this error: "Warning: slot0x05 crypto fail! Could not set up slot0x05keyY. Continue?" And then it gives me yes or no option.
Asked the discord again, they said to try putting the aeskeysdb.bin fine in the /files9 folder, so you could try that.