Issue 2 Voting

Discussion in 'General Off-Topic Chat' started by Kyoji, May 2, 2007.

  1. Kyoji
    OP

    Kyoji ウッーウッーウマ

    Member
    5,474
    1
    Apr 15, 2003
    United States
    :'(
    Rules:
    -You CANNOT vote for yourself!
    -voting is open to everyone!
    -Votes will be given in a hierarchal manner. IE, person one receives 5 points, person two 4 points, so on and so forth. You must vote for 5 people, and follow this format:
    Vote 1
    Vote 2
    Vote 3
    etc

    Contestants:
    Tshu - Link
    Jax - Link
    Lagman - Link
    Mthrnite - Link
    Dirtie - Link
    Kyoji - Link
    Psyfira - Link

    Honorable Entrants (Didnt meet the requirements, but good show regardless)
    deufeufeu - Link
    newkidontheblock - Link
    TPi - Link Link2
    AshuraZero - Link
     


  2. lagman

    lagman I wish I was green.

    Former Staff
    4,071
    2
    Nov 5, 2003
    Mexico
    Me, To You
    1-Dirtie
    2-Tshu
    3-Mthrnite
    4-Kyoji
    5-Psyfira
     
  3. Dirtie

    Dirtie :'D

    Former Staff
    3,705
    5
    Sep 9, 2003
    New Zealand
    Zealer
    1. newkidontheblock
    2. tshu
    3. Lagman
    4. Kyoji
    5. AshuraZero
     
  4. Kyoji
    OP

    Kyoji ウッーウッーウマ

    Member
    5,474
    1
    Apr 15, 2003
    United States
    :'(
    Can't vote for non contestants....
     
  5. Dirtie

    Dirtie :'D

    Former Staff
    3,705
    5
    Sep 9, 2003
    New Zealand
    Zealer
    I don't care >_<


    :'(
     
  6. TPi

    TPi One Tired Raccoon

    Former Staff
    1,197
    0
    Aug 22, 2004
    Canada
    1. tshu
    2. dirtie
    3. kyoji
    4. ashurazro
    5. newkidontheblock

    i don't see why you singled out newkidontheblock's entry with dirtie's voting and not ash :? imo if mthrnite's qualifies ash's qualifies and i like the honorable entries anyways. :X
     
  7. skullstatue

    skullstatue Banned

    Banned
    463
    0
    Dec 3, 2006
    United States
    1.Tshu
    2.Psyfira
    3.Mthrnite
    4.Kyoji
    5.Dirtie
     
  8. AshuraZro

    AshuraZro Belongs in a museum.

    Member
    2,418
    111
    Feb 21, 2004
    Canada
    Saskatchewan
    1. tshu (no surprises! :'D)
    2. Dirtie
    3. Psyfira
    4. Mthrnite
    5. Kyoji
    6. Jack Bauer


    newkidontheblock is too pro to be represented by a number!
     
  9. newkidontheblock

    newkidontheblock Member

    Newcomer
    18
    0
    Nov 17, 2006
    Afghanistan
    1. Dirtie
    2. Tshu
    3. AshuraZero
    4. Tpi
    5. newkidontheblock

    Great work everyone [​IMG]

    PS - 7. Dirtie [​IMG]
     
  10. bunsy

    bunsy Advanced Member

    Newcomer
    88
    0
    Nov 23, 2005
    newkidontheblock
    Tshu
    Dirtie
    Psyfira
    Mthrnite
     
  11. Kyoji
    OP

    Kyoji ウッーウッーウマ

    Member
    5,474
    1
    Apr 15, 2003
    United States
    :'(
    Please amend your vote to reflect this.
     
  12. fischju_original

    fischju_original I used to be a jerk before i got banned

    Banned
    1,014
    0
    Jul 22, 2006
    United States
    Mthrnite
    Tshu
    Lagman
    Dirtie
    Psyfira
     
  13. mthrnite

    mthrnite So it goes.

    Former Staff
    4,529
    944
    Jun 30, 2006
    United States
    th' south
    Respectfully, I don't see any difference between mine and AshuraZero's.
    I'm a little confused about that...
    .. then again I'm not the sharpest bulb in the shed.
    Could you clarify for me?
     
  14. Kyoji
    OP

    Kyoji ウッーウッーウマ

    Member
    5,474
    1
    Apr 15, 2003
    United States
    :'(
    His is uh...Mario. Yes, yours is invader Zim, but it's a parody. Ashura's is more like Mario with some design elements from phoenix wright games.
    If he can offer a good argument against me to include it, I will. But until then my decision stands.
     
  15. mthrnite

    mthrnite So it goes.

    Former Staff
    4,529
    944
    Jun 30, 2006
    United States
    th' south
    1. Jax (cuz his made me laugh the hardest)
    2. Dirtie (cuz it's just immaculate, time well spent)
    3. Psyfira (cuz it's clever and pretty, yes, her too)
    4. Tshu (cuz it's all like, arty and stuff)
    5. lagman (cuz he's my bestest friend [​IMG] )

    Mucho Luvvo to TPi [​IMG]
     
  16. AshuraZro

    AshuraZro Belongs in a museum.

    Member
    2,418
    111
    Feb 21, 2004
    Canada
    Saskatchewan
    "Ashura's is more like Mario with some design elements from phoenix wright games."

    And mthrnite's is like invader zim with some design elements from invader zim. Oh and different style text still saying "Pheonix Wright". Not that I'm saying yours is bad mthrnite, I liked it. But I guess that's where I goofed, changing the title is a no no. And leaving out a subtitle. I did change the little twinkle to a star I guess, to be a bit different, and I left out the all important pointing. So I strayed from the formula a bit. In the end, it comes down me to entering something that, regardless of quality, has not broken the 3 rules set by you any more than the other entries. And yet, it's not considered an entry. So this is your personal opinion, rather than a vote which is the idea of these competitions, that it is not a parody of Phoenix Wright. Next time I'll make something you like rather than something I do so I can get in.
     
  17. tshu

    tshu On epic journey, brb.

    Member
    1,301
    6
    Sep 21, 2005
    Canada
    1) Dirtie
    2) AshuraZro
    3) Psyfira
    4) Kyoji
    5) Jax
     
  18. Kyoji
    OP

    Kyoji ウッーウッーウマ

    Member
    5,474
    1
    Apr 15, 2003
    United States
    :'(
    Yes, it is my personal opinion, as these are my competitions. Your entry says "Super Mario Brothers" with nothing to indicate its no different than the other 100 Mario titles. Mthrnite's is exactly what it says: A Phoenix Wright game, but set in the Invader Zim world. He used Phoenix Wright more as a label for a genre than he did as a title of a specific game.

    Yes, polish wise, yours is one of the best. I have nothing against you, or your entry, other than the fact it does not meet the requirements I very clearly stated. In future contests I will try and be more specific. It was a pretty simple guideline, but for some reason half the entrants had a difficult time following it. Oh well, next time I guess.
     
  19. deufeufeu

    deufeufeu GBAtemp Advanced Fan

    Member
    880
    0
    Nov 21, 2005
    Perhaps it is time to change a bit the modus operandi of these contests.
    After all, is it really necessary to have someone splitting entries between the one fulfilling his requests and the others ? Democracy is, imho, a better choice here. The votes for Ash entries, is clearly a sign of its legitimacy in this contest. Why not let the others decide for themselves.
    In terms of democracy, I've also an issue with the voting. Do you realize that if you vote, you strictly decrease the rank of your own entry ? So it is always better to pass on voting. In future issue, it will be better to force everyone who has entered the contest to vote.
    Another idea, is to make blind voting. That is we send you our entries, and you make a topic with entry 1, entry 2, ect... At the end, you reveal the name of the author of each entry. It will make far more interesting sessions.

    Edit: After all, here is my vote with Ash in it because I respect you rules Kyoji
    1) Tshu (this is an art contest, you made an art entry, [​IMG] )
    2) Psyfira (cute phoenix)
    3) Dirtie
    4) Kyoji
    5) lagman
     
  20. Costello

    Costello Headmaster

    Administrator
    12,393
    5,640
    Oct 24, 2002
    1. tshu (5 points)
    2. mthrnite (4 points)
    3. Psyfira (3 points)
    4. Dirtie (2 points)
    5. lagman (1 point)