I'm still a big Outrun fan!!! From the moment I saw/played it in, what was it, 1989 or something I fell in love with it. Everybody thought or still thinks that's a fantastic racer. Well, according to today's standards it shouldn't get more then a 3.5 also because the collision detection and depth is very poor compared to games from our time. With this in mind I play Burnout Legends. When I play a new racer I try to always compare it to Outrun, and I find Burnout Legends a fanatastic game to play...
See, and that's why so many people think different about this kind of game (the same goes with Ford Racing 3), there are people who compare these kind of games to other racers on PS2, XBOX, etc. and they spit on it, and there are people, like me, with a very retro approach to games, and they probably like it very much, cause they compare it to eighties and nineties games.
Well, there you have my rating-theory