Dbrand no longer selling PS5 faceplates after Sony threatens legal action

01Fyh83PRMdYEFlybucKJSl-1..1634410607.jpg

Selling faceplates for the PlayStation 5 seems to be a lost cause. Last year, a storefront called PlateStation, which was selling customized faceplates for the PS5, was forced to stop after threat of legal action from Sony. A few months later, Dbrand, known for their tech decals decided to get in on the market, by offering their own black faceplates called "darkplates" for the console, even going so far as to joke about the matter by advertising them and saying, "go ahead, sue us" to Sony. The latter took it seriously, as they've done just that. A cease and desist order was issued by Sony to Dbrand, which resulted in the latter being forced to remove their PS5 faceplates from sale; if you now attempt to visit the store page link for them, it redirects you to a list of news reports specifically about Dbrand taking the darkplates off the market.

Quotes from the letter were posted by Dbrand's marketing team to the brand's subreddit, with a breakdown of the incident from their point of view. Sony alleges that the shapes used on the darkplates infringe upon their trademarked PlayStation face button symbols. Dbrand clearly uses a cheeky spin on the PlayStation look by using the same square, circle, triangle, cross look: a cross-shaped skull and bones, a circular radioactive symbol, a square robot head, and a triangle with a rune in the center. That isn't the only issue with the darkplates, though, as further on in the letter, Sony's legal team mentions that "the two vertical faceplates has become exclusively associated with [Sony] in the minds of consumers, and has come to symbolize considerable goodwill", meaning they find the sale of third-party faceplates to be an issue regardless.

Quote from Dbrand:
While we strongly believe in the consumer's right to customize and modify their hardware with aftermarket components, your Darkplates are now a collector's item. You know what they say - you either die a Darkplates owner, or you live long enough to see yourself become the scalper.

In closing, fuck you and especially fuck Sony. Talk soon.

:arrow: Source: Legal document (courtesy of Vox Media)
 

Xzi

Arm Cannon Enthusiast
Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2013
Messages
13,438
Trophies
2
Location
Spiraling Out
Website
gbatemp.net
XP
13,722
Country
United States
I could see the platestation name confusion thing but this... don't know what got into Sony here.
Uhh...probably this:
saying, "go ahead, sue us" to Sony
After a stunt like that you would think they'd at least be willing to risk taking the matter to court, and not wimp out the second Sony simply "threatens" legal action.
 
Last edited by Xzi,

FAST6191

Techromancer
Editorial Team
Joined
Nov 21, 2005
Messages
34,320
Trophies
2
Website
trastindustries.com
XP
23,403
Country
United Kingdom
Every console manufacturer is super greedy now. Microsoft is the lesser of the evils, though Windows has its share of problems
From where I sit Microsoft pioneered the use of chips to lock down third party controllers (not that I have liked any third party controllers since the 16 bit era) so are far from saints in this one.

Custom plates though... that pretty much has always been the domain of consumers whether it has been phone shells*, car parts, laptop covers... even more so when you seemingly build it with the intention of allowing end users to do things basically trivially.

The scope of law to do things under is also seriously limited; assuming you are not troubling copyright with the art you put into it, or trademarks maybe (the send up these guys did of the PS button logo thing in most things I have ever seen would be hard pressed to say risks confusion of endorsement by Sony, aka one of the main points of trademarks) then you are pretty much in design rights and registered design (both occasionally called slightly different things in different countries but much the same idea and implementation, industrial design right is a reasonable start for a search with the US usually going for design patents) which usually specifically excludes bolt on parts and you are then down to trade dress colours and shapes maybe for specific classes of items (amusingly enough the "Samsung made a phone with rounded corners" thing starts to come into focus there).
I could see them getting something on the defensive front to avoid the "haha Sony can't make custom parts for own device" thing if someone else slips in there but actively pursuing it... the mind boggles. The closest I have is they don't want scantily clad anime characters or whatever showing up in videos made by the kids but that is weak, though maybe it is the pure greed thing and they think they can monopolise or bless those that prostrate to them for the chance to make (and have approved).

*granted there was that apple thing a while back with the backplates of different colours but that seemed to be more the guy speaking to the factory in China to get unauthorised parts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: remiferia

SG854

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2017
Messages
4,456
Trophies
1
XP
5,950
Country
Fiji
This is greedy. Just like the right to repair these companies are just plain greedy.

I had no idea geometric shapes were trademarked. And what's stupid is that it was a cheeky spin on these shapes.



the two vertical faceplates has become exclusively associated with [Sony] in the minds of consumers, and has come to symbolize considerable goodwill", meaning they find the sale of third-party faceplates to be an issue regardless
This is bullshit reason and Sony knows this is not the reason why they shut this down. Goodwill my ass. It's all greed and control of the market. It's bullshit to think a 3rd party item will ruin poor little weak helpless Sony's image boo who.

Imagine Nintendo coming out and saying these 3rd party controllers ruin Nintendo's image of goodwill so we are shutting them down.
 

SilverWah

CVS2 best game period.
Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
179
Trophies
0
Age
24
Location
Wah City
XP
1,435
Country
Netherlands
*Sony creates a console with customisable features*
'Dear ladies and gentleman, introducing faceplates for more money down the road!'
*3rd parties fabricate faceplates for said console*
'Oh no no no, that's not allowed. We want that money. You don't deserve our profits. We'll meet in court for your misdeeds'.
 

pedro702

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2014
Messages
11,298
Trophies
1
Age
31
XP
6,271
Country
Portugal
how are faceplates illegal? i mean there are faceplates for 3ds consoles for years, phone covers and so on, and a faceplate is just plastic so i dont think sony can stop anyone from making plastic plates that happen to fit into a ps5 console... unless they pust ps logo on them i dont see any grounds to forbid anyone imo.

switch has so many custom stuff to buy like buttons and covers and shells and whatnot and now sony doesnt want to allow ps5 to be costumizable?

im guessing they really want to sell those special edition ps5 consoles down the line where the only difference will be faceplates.
 
Last edited by pedro702,
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • phalk @ phalk:
    I only do anything in my life to allow me to be lazier
    +1
    Gift
  • mr_switch @ mr_switch:
    same
    Gift
  • Veho @ Veho:
    TRJ, I learned all those in school/college.
    Gift
  • Veho @ Veho:
    As part of some course or other.
    Gift
  • Veho @ Veho:
    I forgot to list Assembler, Pascal and Matlab scripting.
    Gift
  • phalk @ phalk:
    I know some pascal, c, php
    Gift
  • phalk @ phalk:
    and I'm a History teacher
    Gift
  • Veho @ Veho:
    Went over the basics in all of them, never took it anywhere.
    Gift
  • Veho @ Veho:
    I do use bash for my job though. It's useful.
    Gift
  • phalk @ phalk:
    Assembler is something I always wanted to learn
    Gift
  • phalk @ phalk:
    but.... nah
    Gift
  • Veho @ Veho:
    No point really.
    Gift
  • Veho @ Veho:
    Even the simplest device these days runs some sort of high level language.
    Gift
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    @Veho all the IT stuff i've learned in school has been extremely basic... i knew most of it already
    Gift
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    it's better to learn on your own, it goes much faster than the snail pace they teach you at in school
    Gift
  • Coto @ Coto:
    assembly is actually great, gets you to run everything about 80% faster than C massaged code
    Gift
  • Coto @ Coto:
    assembler syntax is dead easy, but "how to put pieces together" logic requires to have in mind the original idea, and the CPU layout, and that's like double the work of C stuff. It's best to write C first, add some unit tests, then go assembly, then run the unit tests
    Gift
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    it can run faster than compiled code, but modern compilers are really good at optimization and you need to be even better at assembly to do a better job
    Gift
  • Coto @ Coto:
    with that all your assembler base will actually work
    Gift
  • Coto @ Coto:
    even on embedded systems, without a damned debugger
    Gift
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    syntax is easy but the code is hard to read, you can't look at a piece of code and expect to understand it without looking at all the code around it to see how it all works together so it takes much longer to read the code, it takes longer to write it too because what might be 1 line of code in C might be 20 lines of assembly
    Gift
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    the language is very simple to understand (because it's barely a language at all) understanding how all the instructions work together to form a whole is another matter, in general it's such a pain to work with that i would never recommend it unless you have a need for it. don't listen to this guy and learn assembly just because you want to make your code run faster, you are wasting your time, but if you run into a situation where your code isn't fast enough even after you enabled -Ofast and you NEED it to be faster, then you can consider assembly
    Gift
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    @Coto have you tried -Ofast btw? ;)
    Gift
  • Gift
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    I have o fast before but I suspect we are talking different Os lol
    Gift
    Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo: I have o fast before but I suspect we are talking different Os lol