I don't know if I would like AC on PS3/360 in the first place. I loved Prince of Persia, but getting killed in one hit in AC is kinda turn down. (I think they are both developed by UBI Montreal, correct me if I'm wrong)
You can't 10:1 so yeah he's gotta fall, but they could have let some breating room. But I have no problem block & counter since Heavenly Sword so let's see.
As far as DS version's concerned, if the environment isn't interactive, 2 thumbs down, losing one of the biggest strength of the game in a port doesn't deserve to be sold. And dynamic crowd, I can let that slip since DS cartridge can hold so much.