Review cover Retro-Bit Sega Saturn Controller (Hardware)
Official GBAtemp Review

Product Information:

Retro-Bit has partnered up with Sega to release brand new official controllers for the Sega Genesis and the Sega Saturn, as well USB controllers for use on PC and Mac. We’ll be taking a look at the Saturn controllers on offer.

attachFull164057

Original Quality for an Brand New Controller.

attachFull164052

One of the more worrying things most people think when they see a “brand new” controller for a retro system is “How does it compare to the original?” Whether it’s a third party controller improving upon the original, or a modern re-release for PCs, most gamers picking up something like this usually worry first about that nostalgic, rose-tinted glasses feel. And this is where Retro-Bit’s collaboration with Sega pays off: The Retro-Bit Saturn controllers really do look and feel just like the originals. Let’s take a look at their offerings, and see what’s included in each box when you order your own console or USB Sega Saturn controller.

Review imageReview imageReview image

Taking a look at the boxes themselves, you’ll notice Sega and Retro-Bit opted to use one of the original box designs for their Saturn controllers that released in the EU instead of the boring, bland white box used in the US which is a nice touch for collectors. When you open each box, all you’ll find is a plastic insert, and the controller itself. There’s no fancy thank you note, no instruction manuals, and no long winded warranty slip. Just the controller, the plastic it sits in, and that’s it. Each controller is based off the slimmer JP form factor, which is a nice bonus, and features the same circle D-pad, 7 button design as the original controller along with 2 shoulder buttons, and a 10ft long fairly sturdy cable, which is perfect for the console variation but a tad excessive with the USB version. The USB version of the controller supports PC, Mac, and Steam, and holding down the start button for 5 seconds allows you to switch between DirectInput and X-input...although this information isn’t actually provided anywhere on the box, and can only be found briefly mentioned on Retro-Bit’s website, which was a tad confusing.

attachFull164056

Quality-wise, these brand new controllers feel almost exactly like the original Saturn controllers feel, which is both a blessing and a curse. On the one hand, the buttons have a nice clicky feel and the D-pad feels about as good as a circle D-pad can feel, but on the other nothing was really done to improve upon the rather poor shoulder buttons. Like the original controllers, they have practically 0 travel and very little tactile feedback, which makes it quite difficult to tell if you’re actually hitting the shoulder button or not. There have been a few times I’ve found myself holding down the L button on my controller without even noticing, which would occasionally result in missed inputs depending on the game I’m playing.

Verdict

What We Liked ...
  • Good quality controllers that feel like the original.
  • Based on slimmer, better feeling JP controller.
  • USB version supports both DirectInput and Xinput.
  • Long, sturdy cable for console version.
What We Didn't Like ...
  • Lack of information on the box for the USB version.
  • USB controller's cable is just a tad too long.
  • Awful shoulder buttons.
8.5
out of 10

Overall

The Retro-Bit Sega Saturn controllers look, feel, and play just like official controllers. If you’re looking for a brand new controller for your Saturn, or if you’re looking for that authentic Saturn feel with emulation, then I would definitely suggest picking up a Retro-Bit Saturn controller.
USB cord is a bit too long? Didn't even know that could be a problem... Also, with today's modern tech, the squishy buttons are quality? I guess if you're looking at the Originals explicitly and comparing based on that.
Most people aren't sitting 10ft away from their PC when using a USB controller. There's a good 5+ft extra cable that just gets twisted and tangled when I'm sitting back playing games at my desk, so yes, it's much too long.

And not sure which Saturn controllers you've been using, but they definitely don't have squishy buttons, and neither do the Retro-bit controller.
 
Most people aren't sitting 10ft away from their PC when using a USB controller. There's a good 5+ft extra cable that just gets twisted and tangled when I'm sitting back playing games at my desk, so yes, it's much too long.

And not sure which Saturn controllers you've been using, but they definitely don't have squishy buttons, and neither do the Retro-bit controller.
I apologize, I meant the shoulder buttons. Edited previous post to clarify.
 
- Lack of information on the box for the USB version.
- USB controller's cable is just a tad too long.
- Awful shoulder buttons.

I was hoping third con will be just as insignificant
 
  • Like
Reactions: SS4
The long cable on the USB version is probably more to satisfy folks with emulation devices of choice hooked up to their TV than direct to a PC.
I wish my Retrobit N64 cord was longer.. Just 5 feet more it'd be perfect.
 
This vs. the 8BitDo 6-button Genesis controller? I know, the latter uses BT (which Windows 10 is a bitch with in my case, as it doesn't matter if the adapter is plugged in or not, the BT will somehow always be "turned off" and there's 10 million solutions online for a problem that should have been top priority for Microsoft to implement correctly in this day and age of everything being pretty much wireless that isn't open-back headphones with AMPs/DACs), but I'm wondering if there's a way to get around that on not just Windows, but also some of the adapters for the ODroid XU4.
 
This vs. the 8BitDo 6-button Genesis controller? I know, the latter uses BT (which Windows 10 is a bitch with in my case, as it doesn't matter if the adapter is plugged in or not, the BT will somehow always be "turned off" and there's 10 million solutions online for a problem that should have been top priority for Microsoft to implement correctly in this day and age of everything being pretty much wireless that isn't open-back headphones with AMPs/DACs), but I'm wondering if there's a way to get around that on not just Windows, but also some of the adapters for the ODroid XU4.

I've also been on the fence about both since I already have some SLS Saturn USB pads. My plan is to wait for the bluetooth Saturn and Dreamcast controllers planned for release by Retrobit because they also plan to sell wireless adapters for both consoles. I would be afraid the 8bitdo would not be able to connect to the Retrobit wireless receivers and have not seen 8bitdo mention intentions for releasing any other retro receivers beyond the NES, SNES, and Genesis variants.
 
I've also been on the fence about both since I already have some SLS Saturn USB pads. My plan is to wait for the bluetooth Saturn and Dreamcast controllers planned for release by Retrobit because they also plan to sell wireless adapters for both consoles. I would be afraid the 8bitdo would not be able to connect to the Retrobit wireless receivers and have not seen 8bitdo mention intentions for releasing any other retro receivers beyond the NES, SNES, and Genesis variants.

I'm not really interested in those. I'd rather see better support for BT on Windows 10. The problems with BT don't even end with what I described. For example, my PC has issues with the Sony BT (MDR950-BT) headphones that my phone never had, which is fine if I listened to music on Spotify via my phone, but usually I listen to music when driving off of my phone!
 
Wow, I'm surprised there's already a review out for this cus I thought it was gonna come out in august (or maybe that is the wireless variant...).

Also I feel the review ended really quickly. I was getting into reading it and then boom verdict pops up. Anyways, good points were brought up.

I don't think the bad shoulder button is much of a problem when people buying it do it for the authenticity, there's plenty of controllers with good shoulder buttons out there you can buy for the same price.

And cable length? Really? First gamers complain about NES classic controllers having too short cables, and now the Saturn has too long cables :rofl:

Also, this review and the announcement of the next 10 games for the Mega Drive/Genesis on the same day??! A great day for retro sega fans.
 
Review cover
Product Information:

Reviews

  1. Alone in the Dark is a Survival Horror game available for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series S/X and PC.

  2. Step into post-apocalyptic Northern Finland in Rauniot, Act Normal Game’s debut point-and-click title. Let’s click away!

  3. Australia-based indie developer Drop Bear Bytes’ debut title, Broken Roads, launches today on PC and consoles. Does this new cRPG have what it takes to stand toe-to-toe to its contemporaries?

  4. Ereban: Shadow Legacy is Baby Robot Games’ debut title that merges classic stealth mechanics with a fast-paced ability to merge with shadows. Should you allow it to sneak into your PC gaming library?

  5. South Park is back in the gaming sphere with the followup to Obsidian’s hit duo of RPGs, South Park: Snow Day!

Site & Scene News

General chit-chat
Help Users
    Xdqwerty @ Xdqwerty: aeiou