Review cover The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess HD (Nintendo Wii U)
User Review

Product Information:

  • Release Date (NA): March 4, 2016
  • Release Date (EU): March 4, 2016
  • Release Date (JP): March 10, 2016
  • Publisher: Nintendo
  • Developer: Tantalus, Nintendo EPD
  • Genres: Action-adventure

Game Features:

Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative
Twilight Princess was an ambitious and confusing game to say the least. Is it good enough to warrant a third version, and does that version remedy the confusion of the original?
LOZTP-Share_icon.jpg

People had been expecting this game for years, some believing in a 3D version, others wanting a true HD remaster. But, as always, people had a beef with this game when it was announced and all the way up to its release, claiming low polygon counts, horrible screenshots, and above all, claiming it looked no different from the original version. To arbitrate these claims, I'll divide this review into two sections, judging the game as a standalone experience and as a remaster of the original.

As a standalone game

Twilight Princess is a roller coaster, full of ups and downs. It's the game that sees you jousting a massive hog rider, escaping from prison into Hyrule Castle's filthy sewers, sumo wrestling a massive Goron chief, and single-handedly slaying an entire goblin army in a hidden village. But it's also the game that takes two and a half hours to get to the first dungeon, that constantly taunts you with treasure chests filled with a whopping 10 rupees, and that gives you items which have absolutely no use outside of the specific dungeon you get them in.

Twilight Princess seemed like a $50 box of gimmicks when it first was released, boasting wiggle-waggle Wii Remote controls, werewolf Link, and an "edgy" atmosphere compared to its predecessor. It was released on the Wii alongside of the GameCube as a last ditch effort to give the console a decent game to launch with. To confuse things even more, the Wii version was entirely mirrored from the GC version to accommodate motion controls. Fans were utterly perplexed. But what came out of it was an actually good game which succeeded to tell its story in a way that constantly fit its self-proclaimed dark atmosphere. Its central gimmick, Link's wolf transformation, actually ended up mixing up the gameplay a significant and refreshing amount in the second half of the game. Its puzzles were perfectly designed and the combat was fantastic and complex even with its ridiculous motion controls.

TLoZTPHD_Feb042016_02.jpg

6.jpg 12719367_1020336861360777_7005685769810255496_o__xlarge.jpg WiiU_ZeldaTPHD_scrn_10.0.jpg

At its center, Twilight Princess is a fantastic and long game, but unfortunately there's a huge amount of fluff in it. Instead of making some side-quests optional, Nintendo decided to make them mandatory. They are stuffed in between the dungeons and leave the player wishing he could actually get to the dungeon without having to backtrack all the way across Hyrule Field. That said, the game really picks up after the first three temples. The ability to freely transform from human to wolf and back provides the layer of depth that the game could have had from the start; for the length of the first three temples, the game provides a formula of a wolf section, then a human section, then a wolf section and so on. The wolf sections are monotonous and long, and the human sections are short but sweet. But once you pass the third temple, you can switch forms at will, warp wherever you need to go, and experience some of the most fun dungeons the series has to offer.

The second half of this game is absolutely fantastic, addicting, and fun. The game is very long and has tons of areas to explore. Exploring is half the fun, as there are tons of secrets and caves to be uncovered and spelunked around the massive Hyrule Field. It has genuinely emotional and frightening moments, with a large sense of uncertainty always present in the air. The music is fantastic at every moment, from the somber Midna's Lament to the extravagant and exciting Hyrule Field theme. This version of the game finally presents Twilight Princess in a way that eliminates confusion and brings out the best in the game. This is Twilight Princess as it should be experienced, and it's a ton of fun.

As a remaster

There was a similar outlash against this game as there was against Wind Waker HD. No doubt you have seen the countless complaints on numerous message boards arguing that this version looks no different at all from the original. But the facts are simple and easy to see. This version looks amazingly clean and ten times better than the original would ever look on a HDTV. The environments look beautiful. It's hard to show with screenshots, but in motion this game looks absolutely fantastic and is definitely worth a buy if you're itching to replay the original. The lighting is miles better than the engine of the original, and the game succeeds in matching its atmosphere graphically at every point. The models are polished, and there's actually a decent amount of anti-aliasing in the engine. This is what the original developers set out to achieve, and it is probably the best-looking Zelda game to date. Watch a gameplay video, and the results are clear that Nintendo greatly succeeded in reviving this game graphically.

zelda-hd.jpg

The-Legend-of-Zelda-Twilight-Princess-HD-screenshot-Hero-Mode-2.jpg tp7.jpg The-Legend-of-Zelda-Twilight-Princess-HD-2-1280x720.jpg

The controls are much better than the original, entirely eliminating gimmicky motion controls and greatly simplifying inventory management using the gamepad. Item combos are made much more easily, and switching items is an absolute breeze. There's even a button on the gamepad to instantly switch Link's forms. The minimap has greatly improved as well (by the way, the map is not mirrored like the Wii version). Rather than being forced to stare at the tiny map in the corner to see relevant information, the gamepad shows a full map of the current area including chests, doors, attractions, and many more points of interest, which were an issue in the original. My only problem with the map system was that you still have to pause the game to see a map of all of Hyrule rather than just the current area, which would have been nice to look at while travelling. The problem is mostly mitigated by warping later in the game, however. The gamepad is put to full use in the game, featuring inventory and map management similar to the original Wii U Zelda demo shown at E3. Gyro aiming is an absolute godsend as well; it is much more accurate and quick than using the control stick.

But outside of graphics and controls, not much else has changed in this remaster. There is a single extra dungeon unlocked by tapping the Wolf Link amiibo, an optional Hero Mode which resolves this game's easy difficulty by making enemies do double damage and eliminating heart drops, and other amiibo functions which restore hearts and arrows by tapping various Zelda figures. The Ganondorf amiibo causes enemies to do double damage on top of the hero Mode increase, providing the ultimate challenge for the Zelda hotshots out there. There are also 50 extra collectible Miiverse stamps which give completionists a bit more of a run for their money. I wish some of the more annoying parts of the game (as previously stated) would have been eliminated. For example, it infuriates me that the game still reminds you what a blue rupee is once every new play session. It seems like Nintendo was intent on keeping the game mostly intact for the most part, but unfortunately there are some annoyances that really should have been changed regardless of how the original game presented them.

Verdict

What I Liked ...
  • Fantastic graphical improvements
  • Great controls
  • A superb base game
What I Didn't Like ...
  • Lacks some necessary changes
  • Too much filler
  • Very slow start
7
Gameplay
Twilight Princess has tons to explore, great combat, and wonderfully designed dungeons. However, there is so much padding in between fun parts of this game that sometimes I want to throw my controller in frustration. The HD version put no effort into fixing this flaw.
9
Presentation
This is probably the best-looking Wii U game to date and certainly the best-looking Zelda game. I would even say it outclasses emulators and HD texture packs on most computers. Its atmosphere always matches its story, which is dark and well-told.
7
Lasting Appeal
The game is only fairly long, and there's a lot of unnecessary filler. However some extra collectibles were added in the HD version as well as more difficulty modes to satisfy more hardcore fans of the series and provide an extra challenge for new players.
8
out of 10

Overall

Twilight Princess was a confused and under-appreciated game in its time, but this version is definitive, updating its overreaching graphics and making it an absolute blast to play and explore. This is a worthy remaster of the original; while it leaves some critical annoyances unchanged, it brings the game to a modern age and shows that even after ten years , it's still a fantastic entry in the series.
L
There was a lot of discussion about the game making minimal graphical improvements over the original.
This is probably the best-looking Wii U game to date

I will no longer criticise the game's graphics.
 
  • Like
Reactions: endoverend
it infuriates me that the game still reminds you what a blue rupee is once every new play session.
I played the game 30 hours and that did not happen. Not for blue, not for yellow or red.

Not updated, European version.
 
I played the game 30 hours and that did not happen. Not for blue, not for yellow or red.

Not updated, European version.
Yes you are correct. This is one of the many fixes in the HD remaster on Wiiu.
No idea what ther eviewer was on but this is probably the worst review of a game in ages.
It start with the assumption that TP was a Wii original. It was NOT.
It;s a gamecube game as sated in the manual of the game.
This is also a remaster of that GAMECUBE game no the Wii port.

To me, the game did not lose it;s charm in the "remaster" process.
IN my book one of the best Action adventure games,
( what with this side quest Bull? THIS IS NOT AN RPG. everything is mandatory like every action adventure game for main story progression and is standard Zelda and genre fair. )

Texture work is fantastic as it was in the original, only gripe I have i wished they would´ve add was extra artwork unlockables or dioramas etc. A worthy remake.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jindex
I played the game 30 hours and that did not happen. Not for blue, not for yellow or red.

Not updated, European version.
Pretty sure you have to exit the game and restart for this to happen. It's a minor complaint, anyway. It definitely does it when opening tiny chests.
 
It start with the assumption that TP was a Wii original. It was NOT.
It;s a gamecube game as sated in the manual of the game.
This is also a remaster of that GAMECUBE game no the Wii port.
I mention several times in the review that the game was released on both Wii and GC initially: "It was released on the Wii alongside of the GameCube as a last ditch effort to give the console a decent game to launch with. To confuse things even more, the Wii version was entirely mirrored from the GC version to accommodate motion controls."
 
Pretty sure you have to exit the game and restart for this to happen. It's a minor complaint, anyway. It definitely does it when opening tiny chests.
Ah, now I get it. :-)

We are talking about different things here. When one open a chest, it will always be displayed what you get, no matter what is in the chest.
But if you collect it without a chest, it won't be displayed anymore. As far as I can remember, that was the case in the GC/Wii version.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jindex
Ah, now I get it. :-)

We are talking about different things here. When one open a chest, it will always be displayed what you get, no matter what is in the chest.
But if you collect it without a chest, it won't be displayed anymore. As far as I can remember, that was the case in the GC/Wii version.
Yeah, sorry about the confusion :P
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bimmel
I really need to point out that at least one of your screenshots is straight from dolphin-emu.org, and quite possibly running with HD textures.

A subtle jab at the fact that Nintendo's TPHD is just a $50 texture pack?

Edit: Wow. This is amazing. You're not the only one to do this, at least 5 other sites are doing the same thing, 2 of them being store pages. And the Australian site for ebgames has a screenshot with the GameCube buttons still on the HUD, being stretched because the emulator is running in widescreen mode.

Pure gold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jindex
I really need to point out that at least one of your screenshots is straight from dolphin-emu.org, and quite possibly running with HD textures.

A subtle jab at the fact that Nintendo's TPHD is just a $50 texture pack?

Edit: Wow. This is amazing. You're not the only one to do this, at least 5 other sites are doing the same thing, 2 of them being store pages. And the Australian site for ebgames has a screenshot with the GameCube buttons still on the HUD, being stretched because the emulator is running in widescreen mode.

Pure gold.
It just happens when you're searching for images, it's kinda annoying to have to examine the content and source of each and every image while you're more focused on the content of the review.
 
It just happens when you're searching for images, it's kinda annoying to have to examine the content and source of each and every image while you're more focused on the content of the review.
I just find it very interesting that even sales websites seem to be doing this without realizing it. I can't expect everyone to scrutinize every screenshot they work with, but it makes you wonder how a Dolphin screenshot made it into circulation of these reviews in the first place.
 
I just find it very interesting that even sales websites seem to be doing this without realizing it. I can't expect everyone to scrutinize every screenshot they work with, but it makes you wonder how a Dolphin screenshot made it into circulation of these reviews in the first place.
Maybe because when you search twilight princess HD the HD texture pack shows up? Lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: ubergeek77
No mention of how you want to shoot the horse after playing the mandatory horse-controlled sections?

Really, I'd have to disagree about the controls. They are far far worse than they were on the wii. The horse turns on a dime and the only conceivable way to control the silly thing is to shift the camera. Controlling with the actual control stick is annoying at best. I'm a pro at Agro (Shadow of the Colossus) and other odd horse controls, but this is intensely silly. slightly annoying sections in the original game were unbearably bothersome and frustrating in this version.

The wii controls were indeed lacking, but these are about 3 times as crappy.
 
No mention of how you want to shoot the horse after playing the mandatory horse-controlled sections?

Really, I'd have to disagree about the controls. They are far far worse than they were on the wii. The horse turns on a dime and the only conceivable way to control the silly thing is to shift the camera. Controlling with the actual control stick is annoying at best. I'm a pro at Agro (Shadow of the Colossus) and other odd horse controls, but this is intensely silly. slightly annoying sections in the original game were unbearably bothersome and frustrating in this version.

The wii controls were indeed lacking, but these are about 3 times as crappy.
I don't understand, did the Wii version not have the same horse problems? As far as I can recall I was cursing the horse out just as much on both versions.
 
I don't understand, did the Wii version not have the same horse problems? As far as I can recall I was cursing the horse out just as much on both versions.
Aye, they were both terrible. Perhaps it's my generous memory, but I recall the wii controls being slightly less nerve breaking. Or there was a way of at least accommodating the bad with them. I never played the gamecube version, though, which would probably be the better comparison between controls. Either way, why they didn't bother to attempt to fix, or a kindly tweak, it is beyond me.
 
Aye, they were both terrible. Perhaps it's my generous memory, but I recall the wii controls being slightly less nerve breaking. Or there was a way of at least accommodating the bad with them. I never played the gamecube version, though, which would probably be the better comparison between controls. Either way, why they didn't bother to attempt to fix, or a kindly tweak, it is beyond me.
Yeah I'd say the main problem with this game is just the stuff it didn't fix. I mean graphics are great and all but stuff like that drags down the experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: osaka35
Review cover
Product Information:
  • Release Date (NA): March 4, 2016
  • Release Date (EU): March 4, 2016
  • Release Date (JP): March 10, 2016
  • Publisher: Nintendo
  • Developer: Tantalus, Nintendo EPD
  • Genres: Action-adventure
Game Features:
Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative

Reviews

  1. PlayStation 5

    Sonic Origins

    Taxman finally gets his shot at recreating Sonic 3 & Knuckles. It's the exciting release every Sonic fan has been waiting for, right?
  2. Hardware

    Corsair H150i Elite Capellix

    Summer is here, so it might be time to look into upgrading your PC's cooling. Does Corsair have what it takes to beat the Summer heat?
  3. Xbox Series X|S

    Industria

    Indie developer Bleakmill’s debut title Industria is now available on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S. Described as an FPS with a surreal Lynichan atmosphere, does it have what it takes to be your new...
  4. Nintendo Switch

    Mario Strikers: Battle League Football

    Mario and friends strike back in the latest entry to the almost-forgotten footballing frenzy.
  5. Hardware

    Turtle Beach Stealth 700 Gen 2 MAX

    The Stealth 700 Gen 2 MAX from Turtle Beach is an officially licensed gaming headset for Xbox, but is also compatible across a range of devices with Bluetooth connectivity. Let’s take a closer look!
General chit-chat
Help Users
    NeoGaming @ NeoGaming: yo you still here