Review cover S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chornobyl GBAtemp review
Computer

Product Information:

  • Release Date (NA): September 5, 2024
  • Release Date (EU): September 5, 2024
  • Publisher: GSC Game World
  • Developer: GSC Game World
  • Genres: First-Person Shooter
  • Also For: Xbox Series X|S

Game Features:

Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative
S.T.A.L.K.E.R 2 has been in production for 14 years, was it worth the wait?

attachFull476278

S.T.A.L.K.E.R 2 Heart of Chernobyl, or S2HC as we shall address it in this review, was first announced in 2010, was meant to be released in 2012, got cancelled, reappeared in 2018 with a release date of 2018, was delayed by the Ukraine war; and now, at the end of 2024, the game has finally made it to gamers on PC and Xbox consoles, but was it worth the wait?

S2HC is a game that has Half-Life 2 vibes about it. Visually, it has a definite air of Valve with desolate settings, murky colour palette, physics-driven objects, and ragdoll-powered NPCs. The game leans into fire effects, reflections, layers of grass, highly detailed models, geometry and textures, but is it all style and no substance? Mostly, it's complicated, in my opinion anyway.

attachFull476798

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview image

Stalking Staples


What begins as an exciting and adventurous foray into the radioactive landscape of Chornobyl, with A-Life AI-driven events that unfold as you encounter them, quickly becomes an orienteering chore, with random supernatural objects striking you in the head, mutants are complete bullet sponges that drop nothing and you have no damned idea what's going on most of the time.

The story beats begin with you, Skif, taking up the mission of investigating an anomaly that has appeared and decimated your home, and you are smuggled into "the zone" by a scientist, Professor Hermann, to study these anomalies and ultimately solve the mystery by force, and make some cash on the way.

The game itself is pretty standard PC FPS fodder, with the main objectives consisting of running to a POI and investigating whatever is going on or collecting something. I won't go into what the objectives are or what you have to do because I don't want to share any spoilers as per usual.

Where the game excels is through its atmosphere. The environments are alive and kicking with enemies and things to check out. Decrepit buildings, outlook towers, and flogged-out vehicles litter the landscapes along with cave systems and desolate buildings. Chornobyl looks incredibly detailed and extremely well populated with flora, fauna, characters and enemies.

The A-Life system means that NPCs are getting on and doing stuff by themselves. An example of A-Life building the world is that you might see NPCs doing something on day one, but you'll come across them again several days later with far better stats and gear, or worse dead. The latest patch updates A-Life to version 2.0 and brings fixes and new mechanics that make the simulation of the population even more believable.

NPCs have purpose, missions and objectives they're partaking in outside of your vicinity. Within your immediate environment, they engage you and either attack or retreat depending on your gear and abilities. It's a clever system that has been pioneered since 2007, and does bring something to the game that you won't see in many other titles.

attachFull476799

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview image

Radioactive Waste, Almost


My most prominent issue with S2HC was the obscene number of times I died at the beginning. EIGHT times in 24 minutes.

It turns out that half the problem was quest items I am required to collect not spawning, and bloodsuckers spawning directly next to me, killing me instantly without me getting a warning whatsoever. This led me into a spiral of simply not wanting to continue with the ridiculously drawn-out process of waiting for the game to load again after each death.

Yes, it takes forever to load, even off of an SSD. Booting the game up took almost 20+ minutes to compile shaders, and then dying and waiting to reload an old save took time to load back in, but just to have it happen on loop, was extremely frustrating and draining.

Bear in mind that I am a console player, and a PlayStation owner at that, so it's rare I delve into PC gaming, and all the aforementioned migraine-inducing issues I struggled through are more than likely why I stick to the simplicity of console gaming. It's not unheard of, but it is rarely this raw and broken when a game is released on a console.

There was a part of me that nearly gave up on this review. I was this close to jacking it all in because I was so pissed off with my experience with this game as a whole. Thankfully, with the latest V1.1 patch and an overwhelming desire to delete my progress and start it all again, I wiped my painstakingly poor one-hour and thirty-four-minute profile and then finally managed to eke out a few proper hours of gameplay that would let me form at least a reasonable overview of the game as a whole with its emergent gameplay.

I'm glad I did persevere, and I'm glad that the V1.1 patch came to my rescue in the 11th hour, otherwise, this piece might have gone straight into the trash. As a result, I managed to forge my way several hours into the storyline and had quite a few encounters that proved the game's mechanics to me.

I think that S2HC is a game that will continue to grow and evolve, but surely that shouldn't be the case, the devs already had a lot of time behind this title.

attachFull476800

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview imageReview image

Patch After Patch


As mentioned above; I find this game extremely divisive. On the one hand, it looks great, it has a story that is actually engaging, an impressive arsenal of weapons, gadgets, and items, supernatural mystery, and a massive open world to explore. On the other hand, the game is overly confusing from the get-go, the controls are quite frankly a nightmare for non-keyboard and mouse gamers, and (pre-patch) it locked up, crashed, or you died every two minutes, even in rookie mode!

I had countless issues even getting the game to run. I thought it might be issues with my laptop, or drivers or, something, but it turns out the game was an acknowledged buggy mess at launch.

To initially download S2HC, I had to wait an astonishingly lengthy four hours for it to download and install when I had a stable 150Mbps internet connection, which should barely take 2 hours. Once I eventually began the game I was met with a crash followed by an instant patch to install, which I had hoped would be a QOL patch, fixing up minor things that were missed before release, and hopefully smoothing out the experience for me, but alas it wasn't the silver bullet I wished for. Sure it prevented crashes, but now I was exposed to the jankiness of the game's ruthless difficulty.

Given the game came out in September and I was only installing it at the beginning of November, there would be two months of feedback for the developers to sift through, address, and drip feed patches. Thankfully they have listened and are actively appeasing the community regularly.

To date, there have already been three major patches with varying sizes. The first and second, 1.0.1 and 1.0.2 were 14 GB and 8 GB respectively and were designed to address crashes and major issues. The latest patch, version 1.1 which was released on the 19th of December, was a whopping 110 GB in size and claims to fix over 1800 things, balancing the game more and making it far more accessible to first-time players with a more lenient currency system, more interactions, and less obstructive monster encounters that were completely unfair; as I initially found out.

The base game weighs in at 130 GB alone, and the developers state that 160 GB is the preferable storage size to have squirrelled away for this title, but I can foresee a lot more patches incoming, including the multiplayer modes, but notably not a cooperative mode, that the developers have promised will come post-launch, eventually.

attachFull476801

Review imageReview imageReview imageReview image

A Clear Basis for Greatness


Generally, S2HC is a fantastically massive game with plenty to unveil in the world of Chornobyl. You have boss encounters, NPCs all over the place with distinct personalities and traits, and plenty of missions to get to grips with. Resources were sparse at first, but with a recently re-jigged currency system to make it more fair, you can now get more for your money to stock up with, and better trades than you could originally meaning slightly less taxing, and more rewarding, progression.

Overall animations are sublime, with gun and reload animations, and even little moments like eating food out of a can with a knife, all very well observed and well implemented. Your hunger meter reminds you to keep your health up and your radioactive meter dictates when you need to take something to drop those levels and get back to safety.

There is so much granular detail, on everything, like dirt and scuffs on equipment, layers of dust on screens, and corpses strewn everywhere with a story behind their death poses. The water is reflective and shimmery, energy effects crackle and flare across the scenery, fire engulfs the environments, dirt and dust plumes around you, and sparks punctuate the industrial biome where needed.

Textures are also incredibly well made. I noticed animated textures used to simulate bubbling chemicals and flaming embers. I think it's rare to see in modern games, usually a texture is static and lighting or emitter effects layered to it, but this appears to achieve similar effects with what could essentially be a looping gif-like texture. Clever stuff!

I love the fact that if you find cool stuff, it's purposefully tricky to access, so you can find a clever way into, around, or through the bunkers and buildings, avoiding booby traps, to obtain these things. alternatively, you can cheese them, locks can be broken, walls hopped, and using clever physics you can get into buildings in ways the developers probably didn't intend you to.

It's the expansive 60-square-kilometre open world that makes this game something to keep going back to. It's got character, and charm that demonstrates the developer's passion for this world they have created.

One thing I noticed that slightly irked me, was that grass and foliage go straight through characters when you're wading through the vegetation, it's minor I guess, in the grand scheme of things, but to be honest I found it quite distracting when following other characters to certain places, and even when trying to hunt NPCs and mutants from a distance. With a game of this scale it's one immersive effect they seem to have glazed over.

It will take you roughly 40+ hours to complete the storyline, depending on your proficiency in S.T.A.L.K.E.R games, but it has replayability thanks to it never feeling the same each time, though story beats that ask you to make choices all seem to lead to the same path, rather than truly branching off into alternate outcomes.

Verdict

What We Liked ...
  • Incredible systems, and amazing detail
  • Openworld exploration is nice
  • Plenty to do and find
What We Didn't Like ...
  • Technical issues aplenty
  • Difficulty spikes
  • Constant patching
7
Gameplay
It's a serviceable FPS with a story that won't set the world on fire, but the game has a lot going for it, and a lot of time and effort has gone into making it incredibly granular and packed full of systems, features and details that make the game stand out.
8
Presentation
Graphically incredible, with depth and detail across every surface. It's a jaw-dropping joy to behold when it's all working.
7
Lasting Appeal
The Newly updated A-Life 2.0 system is, technically, an incredible thing, so no playthrough should feel the same when it comes to random encounters. The storyline is branching, but I have yet to see anything drastically different depending on your actions. There are heaps of easter eggs and secrets to find, as well as high-end gear and plenty of weapons to obtain.
7
out of 10

Overall

S2HC has so much going for it but it is let down by being plagued with problems. I imagine within 12 months, this game will be patched to the hilt and at least twice as good to look at and play as it is currently.
Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to sign up today.
Sign up
I've never played a Stalker game before, and after starting to play this, I was at first frustrated by how unforgiving this game is. The lack of resources, high repair and item cost at vendors, and those damn dogs just kept eating up my ammo, and myself. I have died many times in the early few hours of playing, I even made the mistake of wearing an artifact without realizing it was giving me radiation poison. Now I'm 20+ hours in and find the game very fun and challenging.. Resources and vendor prices are actually fair once you play for awhile, and know what to look for while exploring. Upgrading weapons/ gear, and raiding all stashes helps alot also. Item carry weight limitations is my only complaint now, but I'm sure eventually I can find a better suit with more carry weight. (Playing with Gamepass on Series X)
 
I had loads of fun with the game, but ended up having one progression- and one game-breaking bug.
I played the gamepass version and the cloud saving system deleted my progress from one whole day, where I played around four hours. Saves were just gone the next day. Ended up speed-running those parts using cheats to where I was before.
And then, close to the end of the game, I ended up in a quest where a faction that should've been hostile just wasn't. They didn't attack and thus, the quest progress wasn't registered correctly. Had to unpack some archive with game files to find the correct trigger for the quest and trigger hostility as well as that specific quest progress point manually, so I could kill them and correctly grab the keycard that I needed.
That was definitely not cool. After that I just rushed to the end and forgot about it. But the beginning, first two thirds were a lot of fun, until the big issues started.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: CoolMe and SDA
I was waiting for the 1.1 patch, and the holidays to be over. I'll be diving in very soon!

FYI, the review states:
Given the game came out in September and I was only installing it at the beginning of November,
The game was released on 20 November...I'm very pleased they released a lot of bug fixes very quickly.

My other nitpick is that reviewers should list exactly what their test platform was, especially if it was a PC. What was the CPU, GPU, and now even, what was the disk. When you make a statement:

t takes forever to load, even off of an SSD
...my reaction today is, if you are using a regular SSD, of course it is going to be slow. NVMe disks are now over 10x faster than a regular SSD, and that old spinning HDD? You can forget about even playing games today with those old things.
 
Shader compilation is CPU dependent, not just NVME speed
First one took me less than 5 minutes on a 13900K and a NVME 4.0 drive. Subsequent compilations are less than 20 seconds
Loading save games is almost instant

Still buggy though. I had to use a console command to teleport an NPC to me to get a cutscene to start. I don't wanna be soft-locked again though so for now I'm just doing side missions and going after stashes. Hopefully another patch comes out soon
 
  • Deleted by linuxares
  • Reason: Go away with this stupidity
  • Deleted by linuxares
  • Reason: Reply to deleted post
Nice review. The more I played the game the more I started to hate it to the point I can't continue until all the bugs get fixed. I am in one area that is indoors were barely anything is going on and where my performance absolutely tanks for no reason. Its full of soldiers with the worst AI ever, either they are right in front of you and cant see you or spot you a mile off while you are around a corner. Until the performance, AI and looting is fixed I will just sit on it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SylverReZ
Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to sign up today.
Sign up
Review cover
Product Information:
  • Release Date (NA): September 5, 2024
  • Release Date (EU): September 5, 2024
  • Publisher: GSC Game World
  • Developer: GSC Game World
  • Genres: First-Person Shooter
  • Also For: Xbox Series X|S
Game Features:
Single player
Local Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer
Co-operative

Reviews

  1. S.T.A.L.K.E.R 2 has been in production for 14 years, was it worth the wait?

  2. A budget flavour of 8BitDo’s Ultimate Controller, we look at both the 2.4G and Bluetooth versions of this popular gamepad.

  3. An 8000 series Ryzen CPU in a familiar boxy form factor, we check out Geekom’s more budget AE8 Mini PC.

  4. With a more ergonomic form factor than Anbernic's other offerings, the CubeXX tries to capture the retro crowd with its square screen.

  5. I'm a sucker for anything N64, so imagine my glee when I saw this!

Site & Scene News

General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    BigOnYa @ BigOnYa: @K3Nv3 You ever try Gamepass/ Xcloud on your steamdeck? If so, how is it?