Review cover Jiikae Custom Switch Joy-Cons (Hardware)
Official GBAtemp Review

Product Information:

When you want your Nintendo Switch to stand out, there's no better option than getting some cool-looking Joy Cons.

attachFull171974

 

In the past, we've taken a look at controller skins; vinyl decals that you apply to your controller, in hopes of making a normally drab gamepad have a little more color and personality. While there are plenty of options in that department, there's a lot of people who don't like the look or feel of controller skins. That's why we're reviewing something a little different, today: custom-made Joy-Cons, for the Nintendo Switch. Etsy user Jiikae has a shop where they sell painted gamepads and Joy-Cons, in a variety of different colors and styles. Ranging from a transparent purple that brings back the nostalgia of the 1990s, to an adorable Pikachu themed pattern, there are some definitely unique options to choose from. We got the chance to demo one of Jiikae's Joy-Con designs, to see how they stack up.

Whenever you talk about the Joy-Cons, one of the first topics that will get brought up is how they lack a D-pad. Opting instead for four arrow buttons, Nintendo's decision put off a lot of gamers who preferred the traditional style of a directional pad. There are a handful of options out there, for third-party Joy-Cons that offer a D-pad, but they come with compromises, such as lacking gyro-sensor capabilities, being made from cheaper materials, not having HD rumble, and most importantly, not being able to be used wirelessly. That's where Jiikae steps in, taking the hardware of a regular Joy-Con, and transplanting it into a new shiny shell, with the choice to add the much-beloved D-pad.

attachFull172373

Review imageReview image

 

The Joy-Cons that I received were the deep-blue variant; a very lovely color, mixed with the fun of 90s-era transparent hardware. You can see all the bits and pieces working beneath the shell--the board, the wires, the battery--and I've always been partial to enjoying that style, ever since I owned my old Atomic Purple Game Boy Color. They look absolutely great, whether you're using them in portable mode, connected to the tablet, or slotted nicely into the Joy-Con grip. Both the purple and blue Joy-Cons are distinct enough to stand out, while not being too over the top. 

Just as the arrow buttons have been replaced, so too, have the ABXY buttons. For the purple, you can go with the typical black buttons with white text that they come with normally, or you can opt for the colorful Super Famicom themed face buttons. As for the blue, you can get ones that match the theme, which have a frosted look, while the letters of each respective button are engraved, rather than painted on. 

So, we've established that the controllers look great, but what about the quality? When I attempted to try my hand at replacing my own Joy-Cons' shell, prior to these arriving, I'd made the mistake of trying to cheap out on the shell, resulting in a plastic that was gritty to the touch, and squeaked whenever any pressure was applied. Not only that, but there was a noticeable bump which required me to file down some plastic in order for the pieces to fully snap shut. I lacked the tools to do that, so I was left with an awkward bootleg-feeling set of controllers. Fortunately, Jiikae appears to have the process down flawlessly, as his Joy-Cons have a quality shell--both smooth and durable, and the buttons are perfectly clicky. There weren't any imperfections that stood out to me. All the pieces fit together just as they do on a normal Joy-Con, resulting in something that looks and feels premium.

Already got a pair of Joy-Cons, and you're not looking to get a brand new set? Then you're in luck, because Jiikae also lets you send in your Joy-Cons to be transformed into whatever you desire, for a lesser cost. This is a good middle ground for those who want to get a custom shell for a little bit cheaper, yet are daunted by doing the task themselves or tend to be a little clumsy, like me. 

attachFull172372

Review imageReview image

So, considering the fact that a pair of Joy-Cons retail for around $70, and that it's another $30 or so to get shells off of Amazon, the base cost of $115 (for the Atomic Purple D-pad set) is pretty great, with the rest of the comparative price going towards paying for the labor of making sure the housing is replaced correctly by someone who knows exactly what they're doing. I'm a huge fan of how these Joy-Cons turned out, sporting their beautiful blue transparent shell and textured buttons. For anyone who's looking to get a shiny new set of Joy-Cons that have a little flair, or just have a desire for a D-pad without any drawbacks, I would not hesitate in recommending Jiikae.

Where to buy

Etsy Seller Page - Jiikae

Atomic Purple Joy-Cons

Dark Blue Transparent Joy-Cons

Verdict

What We Liked ...
  • Looks stylish.
  • Shell housing feels like good quality.
  • D-pad.
What We Didn't Like ...
  • N/A
9
out of 10

Overall

Jiikae's Joy-Cons are well-made, and reasonably priced. If you've ever been interested in having some Joy-Cons in an awesome custom shell, you should definitely check out what Jiikae has to offer.
What's the difference with these cases compared to the DIY shells you can get from China?
I don't see a mention of the supplier but these shells are likely made in the same factories in China and you're really just paying extra for the install service. Not sure where those clear buttons come from though, never seen them before.
 
Translucent is the correct term since not all visible light shines through:P

Been personally waiting for translucent shells that are matte like the Gameboy line of shells. For how it blurs the electronics inside and for the scratch and fingerprint resistance, and durability.
 
There is one big Con to these joycons, they do send to the netherlands and some other countries as well. This should have been noted by the reviewer.
 
I'm sure they're just buying shells in bulk from AliExpress and installing them. That said, those translucent buttons look nice. Not a huge fan of translucent shells, I would personally like to see more "limited edition" type designs themed after certain games/franchises rather than just the colors already available and some basic translucent ones. Nintendo haven't been making limited edition consoles, the best you can get is limited edition Pro Controllers and docks, the console itself is still only available in black and the JoyCons only in color variations. So it's left to other people to make fancier designs.

I think I've seen Etsy sellers selling custom painted JoyCons though which is definitely something I'm interested in, being able to get something truly unique that no one else has. Would like to see fully custom painted Switches and docks as well (they may exist, I haven't really looked)
 
M
iS there a review for the bass top ones?
 
I think there’s little doubt that he’ll be buying the same shells, from one of the companies who sell them on their own from places like Amazon or AliExpress.

What you’re paying for, aside from the obvious component costs, is someone who will take the time to make sure they are assembled to a high quality finish. Not everyone can do it themselves, some parts are quite fiddly and it is easy to destroy your controller. If your one of those people then it’s worth paying him for his time.
 
that price goes into the "Con" category, me thinks.
I realize its etsy and these things are made to order, but like WOW it's double the price of an official set here.
 
I think there’s little doubt that he’ll be buying the same shells, from one of the companies who sell them on their own from places like Amazon or AliExpress.

What you’re paying for, aside from the obvious component costs, is someone who will take the time to make sure they are assembled to a high quality finish. Not everyone can do it themselves, some parts are quite fiddly and it is easy to destroy your controller. If your one of those people then it’s worth paying him for his time.

So much this. I bought a set of d-pad shells myself to use on a joycon set that needed the left joycon disconnect fix. I figured that since I had to disassemble the left joycon anyway why not put on a d-pad shell, and if somehow I messed it up it was already not working great anyway. I also have worked on electronics quite a bit. Modding playstations and xboxes and whatnot, solid with small components and a soldering iron.

Long story short it worked out just fine. But it takes quite a bit of time and there are a number of points where you can easily make a mistake and break something. Putting joycons back together is not easy, and it's entirely possible to lose parts-- screws, springs, etc.

When you look at the cost here, in this case $115 for a new pair, the math really makes it clear how good a value it is to have it done for you. Obviously someone who does this procedure over and over is going to have it down and be able to do it quickly without making mistakes. Doing it once, by yourself, not so much. And then look at the price. $115 for a pair. New joycons are $80. A shell set is $20. So you're looking at roughly $15 bucks to have someone do the install for you, and if they mess it up it's on them. Totally worth it if you have any interest or need in buying a second or new set of joycons.

The only way it makes sense to take on replacing the shells yourself is if you don't need or want to buy another set and are okay working with small components. The first time you do it it will easily take you 45 minutes to an hour to do, and it's pretty intense. If you can justify buying a new joycon set, buy them pre-modded. If you are trying to save money and want to try it yourself, go for it-- just keep in mind that it's a little intense and will take you some time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chary
Hmm. The silver joycons look amazing. It's a shame he doesn't offer the dpad mod on those ones.
 
Review cover
Product Information:

Reviews

  1. Alone in the Dark is a Survival Horror game available for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series S/X and PC.

  2. Step into post-apocalyptic Northern Finland in Rauniot, Act Normal Game’s debut point-and-click title. Let’s click away!

  3. Australia-based indie developer Drop Bear Bytes’ debut title, Broken Roads, launches today on PC and consoles. Does this new cRPG have what it takes to stand toe-to-toe to its contemporaries?

  4. Ereban: Shadow Legacy is Baby Robot Games’ debut title that merges classic stealth mechanics with a fast-paced ability to merge with shadows. Should you allow it to sneak into your PC gaming library?

  5. South Park is back in the gaming sphere with the followup to Obsidian’s hit duo of RPGs, South Park: Snow Day!

Site & Scene News

General chit-chat
Help Users
    K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2: https://youtube.com/shorts/WOppJ92RgGU?si=KE79L6A_3jESsGQM