Review cover 8BitDo Xbox Dual Charging Dock (Hardware)
Official GBAtemp Review

Who doesn't like to keep their controllers juiced?

attachFull346569

When it comes to buying a new console there is something a lot of people skimp on: battery solutions. Picking up that freshly sealed new piece of hardware often puts you in a tunnel vision mode whereby you have capped off your spending limit and don't really want to splash out on another expense on the same day. Ironically if you did invest in a battery pack you would be unknowingly saving yourself heaps of time, money and issues further down the line.

Review imageReview image

Not Reinventing The Wheel

Battery packs are nothing new. Ever since the inception of mainline wireless controllers back in the early 90's there has been a demand on batteries to power them, and in turn a demand for higher capacity and less user interaction: aka changing and disposing of them.

8BitDo has brought to the table its own, sleek, sexy-looking see-through dock and nominal-capactiy battery solution for Xbox players around the globe, and I'm going to test whether it packs enough punch in terms of value for money and playtime, compared to standard batteries and even other battery packs I happen to have reviewed too.

attachFull346573

Review imageReview imageReview image

Transparency Is Key

8BitDO has opted to go for 1100mAh power in this offering, bringing forth a roughly 15 hr playtime paired with 3 hr charge time. While it's clearly not a bad ratio, I always feel that by now battery packs should charge far faster by now. Three hrs is not an eternity but equally when you're in the zone, you run out of juice, you can't just bang it down for 20-30 mins and expect to pick up where you left off for the next session. If you did leave it for 20-30 you would find yourself with about 10-15% charge and roughly an hour's worth of power to continue your questing, but then again: you would have taken a well-earned break.

The highest-rated battery pack I have seen in the wild recently is 2600mAh which boasts 45+ hours of playtime, but I have not read good things about them and they require removing and placing in a dedicated external charger to recharge them. While 40+ hrs sounds ideal the mere fact that you have to remove them to charge automatically de-merits them and pushes them down the list of the most desirable accessories in my humble opinion. I think 8BitDo are on the right track with this product.

attachFull346572

A One For All Solution

Thankfully this 8BitDo dual charge dock comes with backs for Series S/X pads as well as the now antiquated original Xbox One controllers. You wouldn't think the controllers were that different, but yes, Microsoft saw fit to adjust the battery back design by just enough that you have to purchase different packs for different gen controllers, and there is still no standard controller with a built-in battery, like on Sonys PS3/Ps4/PS5 consoles, but that's a whole other argument/debate!

Supplied with 2 batteries, they snap in easily and feel incredibly solid. The backs push on and snap into place offering you a method to magnetically connect them to the dock and charge them without cables. No, you cannot charge the batteries with a cable as you would any other "Play and Charge" packs. This is the only real negative I have here, it would have been great to have that option, but sadly it doesn't work via plugging in a USB-C cable to the controller. Perhaps a magnetic-style trickle-charging cable could be suggested as an intermediary solution to make it play and charge? If it happens, you heard it here first!

Should you absolutely hammer your batteries by charging and discharging over 2000 times, you can order more batteries via 8BitDo's link on Amazon. Currently a preorder, you can replace those rechargeable units individually rather than having to splurge out on an entirely new dock and batteries, as is the case for the majority of docks with batteries out there on the high street.

The dock plugs into the mains, which in my opinion is the best option in terms of freeing up USB ports on your console, and supplying ample power to charge your batteries the quickest way possible because if it takes 3hrs on mains imagine how long it would take trickle charging via 5v USB ports!

The Final Word

8BitDo's dual Xbox charger is compact and acts as a controller storage/tidy too keeping your peripherals in check when not in use, and with built-in overcharge/heating and current protection, you can rest assured that your batteries won't fry if you leave them on the dock for extended periods and more importantly: that the battery life won't degrade without use, and they will be charged and ready for action whenever you are.

I love the simplicity, the ease of use and the fact that customers cannot get this wrong when buying a new battery pack for their kids, and the fact that it will force those gaming addicts to ease off a bit rather than plug and play through the re-charging stages: as sometimes kids need to touch grass, take a break and enjoy the IRL world around them too!

Verdict

What We Liked ...
  • Supports both Xbox controller types
  • Dimmable dock
  • 15+ hrs of use per charge
What We Didn't Like ...
  • 3hr charge time
  • No "Play and charge" functionality
9.5
out of 10

Overall

With no option to play and charge in the box, this is almost a flawless product. I love the aesthetic, I love the tidiness of the set-up, but the 3hr wait time, while not the worst, is not ideal for hardcore gamers.
So you're disappointed that a charging dock has "No "Play and charge" functionality"? We've been using our charging docks all wrong, everyone! :O

And you only have one controller and force yourself to wait until it's charged? You poor soul! Does anyone have a spare controller they can donate?
 
I know, right! You know what they should do? They should make a controller that charges with solar power! That way your controller will never die as long as you have a bright light over head! :D
 
So you're disappointed that a charging dock has "No "Play and charge" functionality"? We've been using our charging docks all wrong, everyone! :O

And you only have one controller and force yourself to wait until it's charged? You poor soul! Does anyone have a spare controller they can donate?
You can go to any video game store right now and purchase charge stations with batteries that include this functionality, either via a separate dedicated port on the pack *or* directly via the controller port. It’s one small PCB and one pin, not hard to implement. To give one example, PowerA Play & Charge kits do both - they can be charged with a USB cable or the dedicated dock. They even have a charge indicator LED on them, so you can check the level of charge without a controller, or without looking at the dashboard.

https://www.powera.com/p/xbox/xbox-series-xs/charging/play-charge-kit-for-xbox-1518375-01/

Sadly they’re NiMH as far as I know, so not ideal if you want them to charge quickly.
 
You can go to any video game store right now and purchase charge stations with batteries that include this functionality, either via a separate dedicated port on the pack *or* directly via the controller port. It’s one small PCB and one pin, not hard to implement. To give one example, PowerA Play & Charge kits do both - they can be charged with a USB cable or the dedicated dock. They even have a charge indicator LED on them, so you can check the level of charge without a controller, or without looking at the dashboard.

https://www.powera.com/p/xbox/xbox-series-xs/charging/play-charge-kit-for-xbox-1518375-01/

Sadly they’re NiMH as far as I know, so not ideal if you want them to charge quickly.
Yes, I am aware that many charging docks have batteries that can be charged as you play, but the primary focus of a charging dock is to charge it while it's docked. Otherwise you might as well just plug the controller directly. And what kind of self respecting hard core gamer has only one controller? I buy a dual charge dock, I make sure to have a second controller for said dock, if not for the off chance that I make a friend and invite him/her over to play, at least for my own personal convenience.

Is having a sense of humor common around here? I thought I made it evident by way of the silly smiley face guy... :unsure:
 
Yes, I am aware that many charging docks have batteries that can be charged as you play, but the primary focus of a charging dock is to charge it while it's docked. Otherwise you might as well just plug the controller directly. And what kind of self respecting hard core gamer has only one controller? I buy a dual charge dock, I make sure to have a second controller for said dock, if not for the off chance that I make a friend and invite him/her over to play, at least for my own personal convenience.

Is having a sense of humor common around here? I thought I made it evident by way of the silly smiley face guy... :unsure:
You made it seem like that’s not a valid complaint. Since there are pre-existing solutions that have this functionality, it’s absolutely a relevant con that should be mentioned. Someone shopping for a charge solution might actually care about whether or not they can play and charge. It’s the job of a reviewer to pluck out those small flaws of a given product to educate the consumer. Maybe as a result 8Bitdo will realise that this is a simple way to improve their product and broaden their customer base. There’s no negative to mentioning it, everybody wins - the consumer and the manufacturer.
 
You made it seem like that’s not a valid complaint. Since there are pre-existing solutions that have this functionality, it’s absolutely a relevant con that should be mentioned. Someone shopping for a charge solution might actually care about whether or not they can play and charge. It’s the job of a reviewer to pluck out those small flaws of a given product to educate the consumer. Maybe as a result 8Bitdo will realise that this is a simple way to improve their product and broaden their customer base. There’s no negative to mentioning it, everybody wins - the consumer and the manufacturer.
Well... Other people think I'm funny... I'm just posting for entertainment and internet back pats :sleep:
 
This is the one I use. Same capacity, same charge time, 1/4 the price:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B09GM6KPZ8?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_title

With 4 batteries, 2 players can basically play forever. With 8 batteries, 4 players can play forever.
Not really comparable products, its not a dock just a charger for battery packs. If you're going to be removing the battery packs every time you may as well just get some actually good rechargeable batteries like eneloops,etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KiiWii
Not really comparable products, its not a dock just a charger for battery packs. If you're going to be removing the battery packs every time you may as well just get some actually good rechargeable batteries like eneloops,etc.
Interesting. I guess I never really understood the point of a dock. For controllers with replaceable batteries I don't mind swapping since I want to be able to keep playing infinitly without a wire, so I keep spare batteries around. For controllers without replaceable batteries I got a cheap 8 port phone charger and just plug them all into that.
 
I guess it just doubles as somewhere convenient to put the controllers and also charges them. It does look nicer than just having them sitting on the desk/table if you care about that kind of thing. I've never really seen the point in the controller battery packs in general though. They are rarely quality cells and can only be used in the one device. Makes more sense to me just to have a pool of rechargeable AA's for the controllers.
 
Fine for convenience, but rechargeable batteries are still better.

Plus, they could've made a black colored battery pack for black controllers. Maybe they did, I dunno.
 
Fine for convenience, but rechargeable batteries are still better.

Plus, they could've made a black colored battery pack for black controllers. Maybe they did, I dunno.
Can you elaborate? Most rechargeables have a 1.2V nominal voltage per cell for a total of 2.4V for two, as opposed to the 3V the controller expects, so even at higher mAh capacity you might end up with a lower Wh figure without even realising it on first glance. Not only that, you have to keep taking them out of the controller to charge, so I imagine at some point wear and tear will catch up to you. Speaking from experience there, as repeated use took the life of two of my GBA battery compartment lids - I’ve been weary of it ever since.

Just to give people a better idea on what I mean by nominal voltage, Wh = Ah*V. The original Microsoft pack (v2) is 1600mAh and operates at full 3V, so it’ll provide you with 4.8Wh of power. Two rechargeables at 1.2V each would have to be 2000mAh (assuming full efficiency on two perfect cells) each or more (more realistically, they won’t be identical) in order to reach that figure, and they’ll likely be NiMH, so they’ll charge significantly slower compared to any Lithium-based pack. mAh figures on rechargeables are very deceptive in the sense that people think bigger number automatically means better, but the math doesn’t always check out. Moreover, the capacity claims are often grossly exaggerated on the wrapper, especially on the off-brand AA’s. I can say that Eneloop batteries are quite exceptional.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marc_LFD and KiiWii
i also find it ludicrous that anyone would want or care about play and charge IN THE DOCK.. are you gonna be holding the dock or playing with the controller motionless in it?? as Xerocard said, you can just plug in the controller...
 
i also find it ludicrous that anyone would want or care about play and charge IN THE DOCK.. are you gonna be holding the dock or playing with the controller motionless in it?? as Xerocard said, you can just plug in the controller...
Yeah, that’s… that’s play & charge… that’s what everyone means. Not every pack is compatible with that feature, in order to use it they need to have one of two things - an external port *or* an enable pin on the side of the pack. The controller will refuse to charge anything unless it knows it’s rechargeable. This is to prevent the controller from charging non-rechargeables and causing a fire or explosion risk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sith
i also find it ludicrous that anyone would want or care about play and charge IN THE DOCK.. are you gonna be holding the dock or playing with the controller motionless in it?? as Xerocard said, you can just plug in the controller...
I think the point is that with this plugging in the controller via USB wont also charge the battery whereas with some others it does.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sith
oh i thought all rechargeable packs could use the charging circuit in the controller like that.. now i understand and i agree this feature should be there. thank you foxi and spectral.
 
I don’t like that the handles slide into hard plastic. It would look good as a decorative piece for limited edition controllers but only if they were not used often or at all. over time the handles get some grime and that ends up on the dock and any dirt may end up scratching the controller when docking or undocking it.

Also a barrel plug is unacceptable at this price point in this day in age. My 20$ GameStop branded charger even uses Type C.

Also at 40$, they could have bothered to use Lithium-Ion or Polymer packs rather than NiMh.
 
I don’t like that the handles slide into hard plastic. It would look good as a decorative piece for limited edition controllers but only if they were not used often or at all. over time the handles get some grime and that ends up on the dock and any dirt may end up scratching the controller when docking or undocking it.

Also a barrel plug is unacceptable at this price point in this day in age. My 20$ GameStop branded charger even uses Type C.

Also at 40$, they could have bothered to use Lithium-Ion or Polymer packs rather than NiMh.
What’s the problem with barrel plugs? In my experience they’re a hundred times more reliable than any implementation of USB. It’s a charge dock, not a space ship - it only needs a positive and a negative contact. I agree as far as the hard transparent plastic bit is concerned, and for the same reason - it’s a controller dock, not a space ship.
 
What’s the problem with barrel plugs? In my experience they’re a hundred times more reliable than any implementation of USB. It’s a charge dock, not a space ship - it only needs a positive and a negative contact. I agree as far as the hard transparent plastic bit is concerned, and for the same reason - it’s a controller dock, not a space ship.
With stuff being type C nowadays, I am used to routing my stuff to a 10 port usb charger rather than multiple charging bricks I need to plug in taking up more outlet space.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Foxi4
With stuff being type C nowadays, I am used to routing my stuff to a 10 port usb charger rather than multiple charging bricks I need to plug in taking up more outlet space.
Huh. Haven’t thought about it that way - fair enough. I use long power strips instead, but I can see how standardising everything to one connector type could be convenient.
 
Review cover

Reviews

  1. Hardware

    Tribit StormBox Micro 2

    Cramming a ton of features into a small package is a difficult feat on its own, but the Tribit StormBox Micro 2 manages all that and then some.
  2. Hardware

    Epomaker CoolKiller CK98 Keyboard

    Did Epomaker learn its lessons from the last RGB-ified outing, with the new CoolKiller keyboard?
  3. Nintendo Switch

    Dredge

    Indie title Dredge sails you out on a fishing adventure; but what looks like a cosy trip in the open seas can turn into a fight for survival after dark. Will you conquer the seas?
  4. Computer

    ShowGunners

    Turn-based is definitely not my go-to, but ShowGunners definitely piqued my interest so I had to give it a whirl!
  5. Computer

    Case of the Golden Idol

    Case of the Golden Idol was one of the most acclaimed games of 2022. With its first DLC releasing today, does it still live up to the hype?
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    Hope they made lots of spaget
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    Chill dog
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    Chilli dog
  • Skelletonike @ Skelletonike:
    Damn, I'm loving the new zelda.
  • xtremegamer @ xtremegamer:
    loving the new zelda, i started a game, it was so fucking good, so i
    am waiting on my friend to get home so we can start a new one together
  • Skelletonike @ Skelletonike:
    I just dislike that they don't let me choose the voices before the game starts. Happened with botw as well, had to change to japanese and restart.
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    But the important question is can you choose gender
  • Skelletonike @ Skelletonike:
    Same way you can choose Gerald's gender.
  • Skelletonike @ Skelletonike:
    *Geralt, damn autocorrect.
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    But can he be trans? Lol
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    Zelda transforms into link
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    Link I'm not the princess your looking for.... *Pulls a crying game*
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    *skirt up* it's exactly what I always wanted
  • Skelletonike @ Skelletonike:
    Just scanned all my zelda amiibos, took a while but didn't get anything that cool, did get the lon lon ranch hylian fabrics though.
  • Skelletonike @ Skelletonike:
    It was pretty funny when I scanned wolf link and got a shit load of meat.
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    @Skelletonike, btw I ran that custom for mgs4 on the deck I'm amazed it got that far in game
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    Plug in*
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    Your favorite activity
  • BentlyMods @ BentlyMods:
    My fav actvity is:

    mario-dancing.gif
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    Do the Mario lol
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    🍑
  • K3N1 @ K3N1:
    Whoever developed Bramble was smoking that good shit fucking gnomes
    K3N1 @ K3N1: Whoever developed Bramble was smoking that good shit fucking gnomes