Ok, having this on Xbox One and Switch, I can say I don't have a preference. The Switch one gets played more because I can put my Switch in my pocket... And I vary rarely game on TV unless its a fighting game, and even then... Either way, the home button thing never really bothered me because I only usually go back to the home screen after I put it to sleep, and I never noticed the frame drops on the special stages either. To be honest, the minor complaints everyone has with this game, should tell you that we finally got the Sonic we always wanted, and Sega has acknowledged issues with those minor things and will probably fix them, if not have already submitted the fixes.