Gaming Are flashcarts illegal?

Shinigami357 · Oct 19, 2010

Man, this whole topic has gone out of proportion. Seriously, it's naive and insulting to anyone of any intelligence. Just to be clear, a lot of things are illegal, I repeat, A LOT Of THINGS ARE ILLEGAL. A lot of people violate rules/laws that are so inane some people who work to uphold the law don't even know them. The legality (or otherwise) of your flashcards isn't even the topic anymore anyway, it's just become trolling. In fact, , the whole legal/illegal issue is unworthy of discussion because in most cases, it's a friggin gray area.

PS
To the judgmental people out there... SCREW YOU!!!

Rydian · Oct 19, 2010

What got your undies in a knot? XD

kevan · Oct 19, 2010

People like you Rydian People like you

EnigmaBlade · Oct 19, 2010

Ouch o.o somebody is grouchy.

kevan · Oct 19, 2010

Grr, im not grouchy!

Anyway this topic is useless now. Question was answered.
This thread should be the talk about how we wish that flashcarts
and pirating were legal thread.

ShadowSoldier · Oct 19, 2010

You know something is up when countries deem them legal, and others don't. You know something is wrong with the world when some countries, game retailers are allowed to stock them in their store, while others don't accept past customs.

I think the OP worded the thing wrong. He should have said "are they illegal in your country" or something like that.

Dunny · Oct 19, 2010

ArKRaveN · Oct 19, 2010

Dunny said:

I guess that settles it

Shinigami357 · Oct 19, 2010

Dunny said:

WIN

croagunk.master · Oct 19, 2010

bloodred said:
I was wondering a question that have been In my head for a while I was wondering are flashcarts illegal some people have flashcarts and do not buy the game at all
but some of us use it for backup like me lol and for homebrew ???

You make your flashcart legal/illegal. Executing homebrew on your flashcart is perfectly legal. Whereas putting ROMs(Nintendo DS Game backups) on your flashcart makes it illegal.

ecko · Oct 19, 2010

wikipedia said:
Private ownership

In some countries, it is legal for an individual to personally make backup copies of a game they own. Individuals may make backup copies for various reasons, perhaps as insurance against losing the game or as redundancy in the event that the original game's medium becomes unreadable. See the section on ROMs and Preservation.

However, in the U.S. it has been illegal since 1983 for a user to create their own backups of video game ROMs onto other cartridges. This was decided in the court case of Atari v. JS&A

source:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ROM_image#Legal_status

basically it comes down to that you can make backups of games you own, its just that you cant put it on other cartridges which includes flashcarts.
however it's hard to say if this makes a flashcart illegal, as it can also be used for other things except for games

Bluelaserman · Oct 19, 2010

We don't put the backups onto the flashcart though, we put it on a memory card

Supreme Dirt · Oct 19, 2010

Here in Canada, our copyright makes backing up a CD illegal. It's not enforced, so we have a grey area so large it makes the Rockies look like mounds of dirt.

Flash carts are not illegal in Canada.

Totoy_Kamote · Nov 9, 2010

Piracy is illegal and flashcarts are mostly used for pirating games... so technically it's illegal...

ACDCGAMER · Nov 9, 2010

Generally, flashcarts themselves aren't illegal with the exception of a few countries outlawing them. The reason they're looked down upon is because they are prevalently used for pirating games, which in itself is deemed illegal.

Blastoise · Nov 9, 2010

rikardo03 said:
Piracy is illegal and flashcarts are mostly used for pirating games... so technically it's illegal...

No. Thats like saying blank discs and DVD burners are illegal because they are mostly used for burning copyrighted material.

Flashcarts are not illegal but downloading ROMS is.

Totoy_Kamote · Nov 9, 2010

Blastoise said:
rikardo03 said:

Piracy is illegal and flashcarts are mostly used for pirating games... so technically it's illegal...

Click to expand...

No. Thats like saying blank discs and DVD burners are illegal because they are mostly used for burning copyrighted material.

Flashcarts are not illegal but downloading ROMS is.

hmmn...

yeah i think your right...

so the only illegal flashcarts are the ones with pirated roms right?

it's like Blank Discs with Pirated stuff in it...

Etalon · Nov 9, 2010

Piracy and sodomy are fun, but illegal in some countries.

Well: Who cares?

Cuber · Nov 9, 2010

ShadowSoldier said:
Ok let me ask you this. Don't think it would be stupid if they lied to me? Lets say they were downloading, ok? Hypothetically.

Now lets say I'm coming over. Or we're going to play some games. They would have to delete the stuff off of their flashcard, and off of their computer just for me not to see it. They're not tech savvy, so they can't exactly hide it in some obscure place.

I would... and I'd have two micro SD's to and swap them to hide it! There's be no deleting then...

Evo.lve · Nov 9, 2010

Where I live, they ARE against the law. Do I give a goddamn shit? No. Do I still use a flashcart? Yes. End of story.

Gaming Are flashcarts illegal?

Current "give a fuck" level: Honey Badger

Resident Furvert™

Imagination rules the world

Well-Known Member

Imagination rules the world

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Current "give a fuck" level: Honey Badger

croagunk.master

Guest

Well-Known Member

I shoot BLUE LASERS MAN!!!!

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Former Akaio Fanboy

Well-Known Member

All that you could be.

Similar threads

Popular threads in this forum