We're all familiar with it - the band/artist who goes on making new albums of ever decreasing quality and digging a massive hole in their reputation and credibility. Admittedly, once you have a fan base who'll buy anything you put out it must be tempting to go on recording rubbish and putting it out there because it's a nice earner. However, for the fans who actually like decent music and not just recycled rubbish or music which attempts to latch on to a current trend, it's surely better to keep a musicians output sacrosanct rather than dilute it into oblivion...(cough, cough....Stones......)
And conversely which bands do you think should reform? Which bands/artists bowed out before their time at the peaks of their career?
I feel like i have loads but for starters -
Three who should split - Marilyn Manson, Weezer and Metallica.
Manson hasn't put out anything decent since Mechanical Animals. Every single album since has been declining in quality....i know people like Holywood but although it has a few ok tracks it's nothing compared to the albums it followed. Manson himself is an embarrassment and to think he'll ever recapture his former glory is beyond reality.
Weezer - i don't even really think this needs much explanation. If they'd have split after Green it'd have left a gaping hole in our hearts. Instead they plundered the awful song handbook for years to come....sad to see Rivers Cuomo lose his touch so much.
Metallica. Oohh controversy....Should have split after Black. I didn't like the Black album myself but can understand why people do...everything following that release has been pretty much dire, and an embarassment to their early releases. Whilst Death Magnetic was ok to iffy, i'd much rather have never ever have experienced Load, Reload and St. Anger than hear the middling good stuff on DM. Plus they're continually flogging a dead horse with live CD sales.
And one to reform - Nocte Obducta (seeing as apparently Refused are getting back together you get an obscure choice...). You won't have heard of them but they were great (if you like Metal that is...) For those mildly interested check out their two Nektar albums...and if you prefer proggy post-rock then Sequenzen Einer Wanderung may pique your interest.
(Edited because i realised my first choice for reformation was still active....:facepalm
And conversely which bands do you think should reform? Which bands/artists bowed out before their time at the peaks of their career?
I feel like i have loads but for starters -
Three who should split - Marilyn Manson, Weezer and Metallica.
Manson hasn't put out anything decent since Mechanical Animals. Every single album since has been declining in quality....i know people like Holywood but although it has a few ok tracks it's nothing compared to the albums it followed. Manson himself is an embarrassment and to think he'll ever recapture his former glory is beyond reality.
Weezer - i don't even really think this needs much explanation. If they'd have split after Green it'd have left a gaping hole in our hearts. Instead they plundered the awful song handbook for years to come....sad to see Rivers Cuomo lose his touch so much.
Metallica. Oohh controversy....Should have split after Black. I didn't like the Black album myself but can understand why people do...everything following that release has been pretty much dire, and an embarassment to their early releases. Whilst Death Magnetic was ok to iffy, i'd much rather have never ever have experienced Load, Reload and St. Anger than hear the middling good stuff on DM. Plus they're continually flogging a dead horse with live CD sales.
And one to reform - Nocte Obducta (seeing as apparently Refused are getting back together you get an obscure choice...). You won't have heard of them but they were great (if you like Metal that is...) For those mildly interested check out their two Nektar albums...and if you prefer proggy post-rock then Sequenzen Einer Wanderung may pique your interest.
(Edited because i realised my first choice for reformation was still active....:facepalm