Battlefield 3 vs Guild Wars 1 vs Modern Warfare 3

[bjorno]

Hello everyone.
I wonder which game of the three you like the most and which game do you like the least and very important, why?


1. Battlefield 3
2. Guild Wars 1
3. Modern Warfare 3
4. None


Lets discuss.

 

[Devin]

This is just asking for a huge flame. I don't like any of them, was hyped for most of them but now I don't play any of them.

Edit: We need a none of the above choice.

 

[bjorno]

This is just asking for a huge flame. I don't like any of them, was hyped for most of them but now I don't play any of them.

Edit: We need a none of the above choice.

Nice suggestion mate Added none.

 

[Joe88]

one of those games does not belong

 

[Magmorph]

Guild Wars is 6 years old and isn't even a shooter. This is a strange selection of games.

 

[ZAFDeltaForce]

You're comparing an FPS, an FPS and an MMO? Wtf?

Anyway, I've never tried Guild Wars, and I prefer BF3 over MW3

 

[BORTZ]

Couldnt care less about any of them. Also wtf, Guild Wars?

 

[bjorno]

Guild Wars because I wonder if people like that game more than a fps like BF3 or MW3 even if it is old.
I might buy one of the three but I can't decide yet..

 

[Arnold Schwarzen]

Played all of them and personally enjoy Battlefield 3 the most. While it does look the best visually I look at gameplay here and BF3 wins for me. It's like an HD version of BF2 (not exact but close) which is my favorite multiplayer game of all time. MW3 is also good but much of the same as MW2 really. Of course I'll still pick up a copy for myself later when it drops in price. And Guild Wars is a nice free MMORPG but not my kind of game. But those that enjoy that style may love Guild Wars. There is also a Guild Wars 2 right around the corner. That's my open minded opinion.

 

[Mazor]

It's like an HD version of BF2 (not exact but close) which is my favorite multiplayer game of all time.

You're the first person I've seen say this. I've seen a lot of people say stuff like "BF3 is just like Bad Company 2 whereas I was hoping for it to be the true successor of BF2".

I loved and played the fuck out of both BF1942 and BF2 back when they were huge but I've been very skeptical about BF3 and the thoughts I've read haven't helped. Regardless, I do intend to play it myself at some point when I have the time.

At any rate, according to you (or others as well, more input wouldn't hurt), is BF3 actually more like BF2 than it is like Bad Company 2?

 

[prowler]

I literally laughed at Guild Wars in there.

My vote is for Guild Wars anyway.

 

[Sterling]

I guess you guys can tell which one I like. (Hint: Avatar)

 

[awssk8er]

These can't really be compared...

I mean Guild Wars and Battlefield are exactly alike. Those two can be.

I don't see how Modern Warfare fits into the whole thing...

 

[deathking]

get bad company 2 on a steam sale for 10 bucks its better then 3 imo and that ea origin thing really sucks

 

[Gahars]

one of those games does not belong

One of these games is not like the other...

I propose that Once Upon A Monster be added to list; it couldn't be any more irrelevant.