Gaming How do you want the new smash bros games to be like? Melee or Brawl?

[ashxu]

I don't care honestly, I like Brawl and I don't like Melee and I'm looking forward to the new Smash.

Want a competitive fighting game? Get Mortal Kombat or Street Fighter.

MK9 has been dead to the competitive scene for quite awhile now. Everyone jumped ship to Injustice and even then Injustice is probably on the lower end of the popularity scale.

Melee/P:M is a decent competitive game, it has some really arbitrary rules but it's there.

 

[BORTZ]

Is it too much to as for something new? A game the plays like neither predecessor?

 

[frogboy]

The two minutes I got to play at the Best Buy demo seemed to be not quite as fast as Melee, but nowhere near the sluggishness of Brawl. I was quite satisfied, as that's exactly how I hoped it would be.

Also hurray, because Fox got nerfed soooooooooo hard ;O;

 

[VLinh]

I was thinking of the idea that Nintendo could include a separate mode within the main game with Melee's physics and properties to appeal to the Melee players. Sure it would add more work, but I think it would be great for having a variety

 

[the_randomizer]

Like Brawl, only no random tripping.

 

[MarioFanatic64]

Melee can be too fast to process at times. I never saw a problem with the slower movement of Brawl as you have the time to properly come up with a strategy. All I can say for sure about Melee is that it's essentially luck-based button mashing.

 

[Bimmel]

Melee can be too fast to process at times. I never saw a problem with the slower movement of Brawl as you have the time to properly come up with a strategy. All I can say for sure about Melee is that it's essentially luck-based button mashing.

By any means - that in fact is brawl, not melee.

Smashballs, tripping and some unbalanced characters - need more evidence?

 

[WiiCube_2013]

Gameplay wise. Would you rather have fast paced pow pow like melee, or like brawl, slow and floaty.


I would want it to be REALLY competitive. So, I choose melee.
We're going to have a hell of a debate.

A mix of the two.

But overall, just an addictive good time brawly fun is all I ask.

 

[MarioFanatic64]

By any means - that in fact is brawl, not melee.

Smashballs, tripping and some unbalanced characters - need more evidence?

I'm guessing you're of the "Fox only, no items, Final Destination" type.

 

[tatripp]

I just hope they include more random slipping, metroid levels, Mario clones, slow online play, and suicidal luigis.

 

[hippy dave]

I hope they make it a Tetris crossover.

 

[Haloman800]

>Competitive Smash

Just stop

>greentexting on GBAtemp

just no

 

[placebooooo]

I would love for it to be like melee. In melee, not only was it fast paced, but one character had an advantage over the other. In brawl, all characters are "almost" in some way equal to one another. My main character, sheik, is who i used to play with in melee, but when it comes to brawl, i dont play with him at all. Additionally, i believe that the 3ds version is going to be like the brawl version. I remember it was confirmed that way at least somewhere online...

 

[Felipe_9595]

The amount of stupidity in this thread is amusing. Get over it guys, we have Curse, Cloud9, Team Liquid and a bunch of other big name teams between the e-Sport availing Smash a competitive game, saying the opposite and crying against it makes you look bad. Competitive Smash IS a reality.

Also,for whoever said Mortal Kombat, isn't competitive, it is.

I would like a new game, we will not get Melee, so i want something new compared to Brawl.

 

[FAST6191]

The amount of stupidity in this thread is amusing. Get over it guys, we have Curse, Cloud9, Team Liquid and a bunch of other big name teams between the e-Sport availing Smash a competitive game, saying the opposite and crying against it makes you look bad. Competitive Smash IS a reality.

Also,for whoever said Mortal Kombat, isn't competitive, it is.

I would like a new game, we will not get Melee, so i want something new compared to Brawl.

I am not seeing anybody denying that it exists, just that those designing the competitions would probably struggle to design a die rolling contest, the competitions themselves are filling with cretins a lot of the time (though probably not as bad as general fighting games, not as bad is not good though) and that the games are not best tuned for it (though I stand by the earlier remark of those designing competitions around this are not good at their job).

 

[Bimmel]

I'm guessing you're of the "Fox only, no items, Final Destination" type.

Sorry if I made a impression like that - 'cause thats not the case. Just an ordinary player, nothing more.

Just wanted to point out that melee is everything but not very luck-based for me. What makes you think so?

 

[lampdemon]

In brawl, all characters are "almost" in some way equal to one another.

Meta Knight says otherwise.

 

[MarioFanatic64]

Sorry if I made a impression like that - 'cause thats not the case. Just an ordinary player, nothing more.

Just wanted to point out that melee is everything but not very luck-based for me. What makes you think so?

Sorry then. It's just that a majority of people who dislike Brawl's mechanics are the type who are so competitive they forget to have fun with Smash. I'm glad to know you aren't like that, but I do prefer Brawl over Melee just based on the speed. My fingers can't catch up with the speed of Melee and the highest CPU level I can handle is 5 or 6, whereas in Brawl I'm good enough to take on any character CPU at highest level, regardless of the advantage/disadvantage.

 

[lampdemon]

Sorry then. It's just that a majority of people who dislike Brawl's mechanics are the type who are so competitive they forget to have fun with Smash. I'm glad to know you aren't like that, but I do prefer Brawl over Melee just based on the speed. My fingers can't catch up with the speed of Melee and the highest CPU level I can handle is 5 or 6, whereas in Brawl I'm good enough to take on any character CPU at highest level, regardless of the advantage/disadvantage.

Are you kidding? The CPUs in melee are dumb as a rock, even the lv9 ones. Brawl improved a lot on the CPU AI.

 

[MarioFanatic64]

Are you kidding? The CPUs in melee are dumb as a rock, even the lv9 ones. Brawl improved a lot on the CPU AI.

That's just how it works for me, man. Melee is way too fast. I kick ass with Brawl CPU's.