nathancnc said:Yes the PP+ is charged directly, but it the charger is a smart charger, much like the one in the 3ds itself.....thats why it has 3 leads on the bottom instead of 2. AAMOF most chargers will charge the battery to near full, then don't really turn off, they just go down to a small "trickel" charge until it has been removed from a power source.
I can confirm that this is what both the stock 3ds charge port, and PP+ do......along with the DS/DSL/DSi/XL...and every PSP model aswell as PSP Go.
So it most likely was just a short in the PP+ Cradle.....this was an issue with the very first batch, and Nyko will replace it free of charge, just give them a call.
All I know is that my 3DS never seemed to charge well when I used to dock/Charge Base. Light would be green but the battery would be near empty. Happened a number of times. Seeing as I just got my 3DS back (and now have to send it back because the outer shell was damaged during repair), I'm probably just going to stick with the stock battery for awhile. This is the first I've heard of the dock "shorting out". One would think a product recall was in order. This makes Nyko look bad for not informing customers of an issue that can cause damaged to their 3Ds.
Edit: Filled out complaint form on nyko.com. If they don't get back to me by Weds I'll be making some angry phone calls.
PS I still suggest that people charge their PP+ directly though the 3DS if they have an "early" model dock. Even after I get my battery and dock replaced, I'm probably going to do so.