pokemon yellow remake

so i said in the old firegold thread that i'd do a yellow remake, but due to the limitations of ds romhacking i got the idea to use ''PSP'' (pokemon script project) to make a fully customized yellow remake tha could contain everything i want including gen 5 pokemon, new regions( i could even make a full anime game) and it has a dualscreen black/white engine, but that would be on pc, it would be really faster, easier to do as opposed to a half assed non map editable(i mean changing the actual map tiles etc) rom hack.
so just vote what you would prefer to see!
i actually prefer to do this on pc and i could also add online and mystery gift...

previous comments

Warning! Spoiler inside. 

coolness: it would be nice if you create a wii version of the game
aminemaster:that would exceed the wii homebrew development capabilities...
i can make a pc version or a ds romhack, which will be portable but very watered down
wasim:Anyway do the HG hack
aminemaster: well i will do the HG hack when a map editor is avaible, because if not i cannot change the appearences and cannot add cinnabar and mt moon and such, no new maps i think i understand why macho gave up, but that's just until DMGE gets released...
i think the fangame would be more approppriate, i'll remake this thread into general off topic discussions...

please think about it, i think the pc one is way better and wiser, since we can't graphically change any maps, we can just do the scripts and events...

Edited by aminemaster, 02 February 2012 - 10:14 PM.

i just don't understand why people want a watered down version that has nothing new exept for the yellow story and pokemon, you can't even mod a map!
is it for portability?
will showing you screens be conviencing?

Edited by aminemaster, 02 February 2012 - 06:43 PM.

I voted on DS, because it would make it 'feel' more like a real Pokemon game. And I would love to re-play Yellow on the move

But if you do end up making it on PC, I would suggest not having dual screens, what's the point? Since PC has the possibility for larger resolutions, why not just have one window and adapt the engine for this. It would look cleaner and play easier, rather than having to click on the bottom screen every now and then etc.

No but it is portable. ^^

I voted for PC version though

Ah! you posted.
Voted for DS.

i don't like playing pokemon on my pc. And i usually don't play games on my computer.

matt382, on 02 February 2012 - 06:43 PM, said:

no need to click on the bottom screen, with the dual screens it just gives a pokemon feel, there are also gen 3-4 versions without dual screen but with less powerful graphics, and trust me i realized if i make it on ds it won't have a yellow feel, no cinnabar etc, it would have the exact same kanto as HG

if i could vote for the wii than i would have voted for wii but for now will i vote for the PC version

Dark Langin, on 02 February 2012 - 06:44 PM, said:

reasonable

wasim, on 02 February 2012 - 06:45 PM, said:

trust me it's better than you can imagine, and if we wait until the 3ds/vita gets hacked i bet it can emulate it very well.
edit: for dual screen thingy there are 2 versions avaible
the gen 5 version:

gen 4 version:(little glimpse of former work on yellow pc)

Edited by aminemaster, 02 February 2012 - 06:51 PM.

I've played a few Pokemon games on my PC, like the ones made with RPG Maker XP using Poccil's kit. They were good, but it just isn't the same feeling as playing on a DS. Maybe I'm just weird like that hahaa :')

matt382, on 02 February 2012 - 06:52 PM, said:

watch my spoilers in the above post
it's not the exact feel but it's very similiar, just look at the spoilers please.

aminemaster, on 02 February 2012 - 06:47 PM, said:

Unless it doesn't take too much CPU i'll play it. ( so i can play winamp while playing it )

I initially voted for the DS version but after seeing the screenshots for the PC based game I realized that the PC version would be better.

wasim, on 02 February 2012 - 06:54 PM, said:

it doesn't take cpu at all

Hmm first time I've seen this kit. It's pretty good.

i'll let this poll go on for like a week, ok?