Review: Black Mirror (PlayStation 4)

Black Mirror: Official GBAtemp Review

PlayStation 4 1,693 view 3 likes 10 comments
Reviewed by Christopher Otero, posted Jan 8, 2018, last updated Jan 8, 2018
Jan 8, 2018
  • Release Date (NA): November 28, 2017
  • Release Date (EU): November 28, 2017
  • Publisher: THQ Nordic
  • Developer: KING Art
  • Genres: Point-and-click, Horror, Adventure
  • ESRB Rating: Mature
  • PEGI Rating: Sixteen years and older
  • Also For: Computer, Xbox One
  • Single player
    Local Multiplayer
    Online Multiplayer
    Co-operative
Black Mirror is a point and click adventure/horror game and a re-imagining of the original 2003 series. Arriving at Black Mirror castle, you find that there is something beyond the realm of the physical world lurking within the walls and a madness that has consumed generations of the Gordon family.
Christopher Otero
review_banner_black_mirror_game.jpg

Welcome to Black Mirror Castle

The game starts interestingly enough; a man fleeing for his life among old ruins, strange stone structures and self immolation. Sadly, Black Mirror fails to provide anything more compelling than that. Afterwards, you control David as you explore the castle and its grounds, trying to discover the mysteries of the Gordon clan and your late father's madness. Heavily inspired by the works of Lovecraft and Poe, the story sadly lacks the horror and interest of the authors. The small cast of characters are as interesting as the story itself; not at all. Almost everyone, save for the gardener Rory, are incredibly dull and add very little to narrative. It's hard to say that the game is anticlimactic, as there is no climax at all. There is no real build up, as hard as it tries to get you invested. It just goes at the same pace from beginning to end. It's very disappointing given the Lovecraftian atmosphere they try to create (and I love Lovecraft's works), but never seem to capture the hopelessness and horror it was going for.

Black Mirror_20180104130835.jpg
Black Mirror_20180104131357.jpg Black Mirror_20180104150138.jpg Black Mirror_20180104153323.jpg Black Mirror_20180104155617.jpg Black Mirror_20180104160927.jpg Black Mirror_20180104162338.jpg Black Mirror_20180104221812.jpg Black Mirror_20180104160447.jpg Black Mirror_20180104160535.jpg

As far as gameplay goes, it's simple enough. Examine points of interest, find items and speak to the flat characters to gather information. Some puzzle solving is thrown in as well, which isn't anything amazing but isn't terrible either. One of the most biggest faults in the game is the lack of direction, particularly in the beginning. Given vague objectives such as "Find out more about the little boy" but no real direction to go is frustrating beyond belief. After exploring every room multiple times, aimlessly, I finally found what I was to do. Understandably they can't give you too much as it is a mystery but a sort of inner monologue with a hint or idea of what you might be looking for would have helped greatly. There are a few quick time events of sorts, in which you have to press the corresponding button, hold it down or tap it repeatedly. As the game progresses on, David begins to suffer strange visions of past events and must piece together what they mean by examining the specters. The visions can be deadly if approached the wrong way, or you linger by them too long. These are few and far between, adding very little to break the painful slowness and general dullness of the game. Control of David is also frustrating, often times not moving in the desired direction at all, which can have some negative consequences.


Madness

From a visual standpoint, just like the story of the game, it is lacking. The best way it describe it is early last-gen. Not that it takes away from Black Mirror as there is already little there but it doesn't help either. From odd character movements and facial patterns to a weird shine on everyone's face as if they've been soaked in oil, it isn't a graphically pleasing experience. A minor annoyance was David's shuffling during dialogue. What starts as him looking at the NPC becomes him glancing at them sideways, his eyes always on the NPC in the most unnatural way possible.
Perhaps one of the only really good things about Black Mirror is the soundtrack. Rather minimal, there are a few nicely scored tracks in the game, but a decent selection of music can only do so much to add to an abysmal atmosphere and story. A few graphical hiccups plague Black Mirror as well. Textures disappearing, framerate drops and skips, gaps between the textures and some odd ghosting effect that definitely was not intended when you move, are just a few of the issues present. I will say that the castle and the areas you explore do look pretty nice and atmospheric, but again, it doesn't do much to add to the experience.

Black Mirror_20180104130743.jpg
Black Mirror_20180104134631.jpg Black Mirror_20180104161635.jpg Black Mirror_20180105135352.jpg Black Mirror_20180105140421.jpg Black Mirror_20180105151541.jpg Black Mirror_20180104131149.jpg Black Mirror_20180104151148.jpg Black Mirror_20180104222204.jpg Black Mirror_20180105135741.jpg

On the topic of all of the issues, there are also numerous bugs in the game as well. On six separate occasions the game crashed, for no apparent reason at all. I had done nothing ridiculous, nothing to try to bug it out, but it happened all the same. The most prevalent issue was that in cut scenes in which you are talking to an NPC, after you have exhausted all topics and go to leave the conversation, the game glitches out in the most awkward way possible. Unable to move and still in the cut scene somehow, you are forced to watch the NPC stare at David, as he does in the game, begin to shuffle in a circle to his right in the slowest way possible until you reset the game and try again. This happened more times than I cared to count and was incredibly painful when I had to talk to the same person over and over until the game finally decided to let me end mine, David and the NPC's suffering by letting me walk away. Needless to say, it was horrible.


Broken Mirror

Black Mirror clocks in with under 5 1/2 hours of game, though I would wager it could be finished in much less time. Regardless of if you have played the original series or not, I cannot recommend this game at all. With sub-par graphics, a dull and uninteresting story, forgettable characters and quite a few issues present throughout, Black Mirror falls short of it's Lovecraftian inspiration. If you must play it, wait for it to go on sale.

Black Mirror Launch Trailer

Verdict
Pros
+ Decent soundtrack
+ Not very long
Cons
- Bugs and graphical issues
- Dull story
- Equally dull cast
- Some awkward controls
3 Presentation
From the bland story and uninspired characters to the many graphical issues and generally unappealing look of the game, Black Mirror offers an overall boring and uninteresting experience.
5 Gameplay
The point-and-click and puzzle solving aspects of the game are pretty decent but don't add anything new or interesting. Movement is an issue as well and the lack of direction is frustrating at times.
3 Lasting Appeal
Long enough to kill an afternoon, but beyond that, I highly doubt anyone would be going back for another playthrough after completion.
3.4
out of 10
Overall (not an average)
Black Mirror comes up short as both an adventure and horror game. Bugs and graphical issues don't help the already exceptionally dull story. I can only imagine it does very little justice for the original series it is based off. Whatever you do, don't go to Black Mirror castle.
Share
TheKawaiiDesu, Issac and T-hug like this.
10 comments

  • shaunj66
  • leon315
  • Taleweaver
  • MajinCubyan
  • leon315
  • SirNapkin1334
  • HamBone41801
  • r1vver
  • HamBone41801
  • gamesquest1