Official Review PlayStation Vita Updated

A Rose in the Twilight (PlayStation Vita)
Official GBAtemp Review

Name: A Rose in the Twilight
Item: A Rose in the Twilight
Rating: 6
Author: Prans

Product Information:

Release Date (NA): April 14, 2017
Release Date (EU): April 14, 2017
Publisher: NIS America, Inc.
Developer: Nippon Ichi Software, Inc.
Genres: Puzzle Platformer
Also For: Computer

Game Features:

Single player

Local Multiplayer

Online Multiplayer

Co-operative

Nippon Ichi is back with another 'cute gore' game, this time of the puzzle platformer genre.

attachFull83366

Nippon Ichi? Check. 'Cute Gore', check. Appeal?

The visuals of A Rose in the Twilight strongly reminded me of Yomawari: Night Alone, and sure enough it's from the same developer. While belonging to different genres, both games bear themes of the supernatural and the same art style which I like to call 'cute gore' because of cute depiction of the protagonist, even some enemies, but deaths are brutal and blood is free-flowing; offering the protagonist as a blood sacrifice in atrocious ways to clear up a passage, or committing suicide to go back to a checkpoint are things you have to do in this new title to progress. Those are features you won't typically associate with a cute, little protagonist. Since I really, really liked Yomawari, I was all the more curious as to whether this new title would bring the same appeal.

Did it? Short story, not really. Long story, read on.

attachFull83203

Offer blood to continue

A Curse, A Friend, A Story

Without much of a preamble, the game gives you control over a little girl, Rose, who just woke up in the dungeon of a castle in ruins. Oh, and she also has a giant rose attached to her back for some reason. As she wanders around the deserted dungeon, Rose comes across a giant rock golem. Initially scared of the latter, Rose's fears are quickly dissipated as she discovers the good nature of the golem. The two adventure in the castle together, forming an inseparable bond. Indeed, you'll need to get both Rose and the golem to the exit of each level in order to complete it.

attachFull83202

The Rose-golem symbiosis

You will slowly uncover the questions that have built up during your playthrough like the story behind Rose's curse, the origin of the golem, the reason for the castle's state of ruin, and others. The storytelling is mostly visual and based from cutscenes obtained via blood memories (memory stored in the blood of the castle's staff corpses) and some diary entries that you can find on your way. Additional information can be obtained from notes and books scattered throughout the levels which add some backstory to the lore of the game. There are even little twists that unfold as you progress and depending on how you look at it, three different endings! (the first one is a bit tricky but the second one should be obvious since the game carries on after the credits roll, after which you'll play to reach the final ending).

attachFull83204

Whee! Story time!

To solve each level's puzzle you have to use the characters' individual strengths and each complements the other. For instance, the tough golem can pickup Rose and other objects and is virtually invincible and won't die unless if it falls down a bottomless pit but its gigantic size restricts its access to some areas. The smaller Rose on the other hand is overly-fragile and her survival depends on your ruse of applying the level design and the golem's help to your advantage. Nevertheless, you'll have to resort to death, suicide even, in order to progress and Rose will reincarnate from the nearest flower. But Rose's curse is also her forte. The rose on her back can absorb blood from certain objects to freeze them and it can even be transferred to other objects which can then be activated or picked up by the golem. You can also easily switch between the characters at any time. This can be crucial in several puzzles where you have to quickly change from the golem to Rose or else you're caput!

attachFull83210

A very touching friendship!

Puzzled

Which brings us to the core of the game: puzzles. Each level is a unique puzzle crafted for you to use your cunning to solve. But that's not all that is required, unfortunately. Several levels left me scratching my scalp more often than I'd expect until the solution clicked in my mind, but many more weren't solved by any number of scalp-scratching and imaginary clicks - but required surgical precision of the blood sucking, time-freezing gimmick, accurately timed jumps or memorizing sequences and hitting the right strings at the right time. The latter is particularly evident with the final boss which took an eternity to ~~beat~~ memorize and apply the winning sequence.

attachFull83215

This 'puzzle' reminded me of the surgery exam that I don't have

The game is also very slow paced; almost too literally since you cannot do more than walk. Sure it's a puzzle game and you need not rush it for fear of missing key items but when you have to grab an item all the way up a platform and come back down all with the help of a sluggish elevator and your slow strolls, advancing quicker would be appreciated. And if you die and respawn at a distant checkpoint in the process, all the more frustrating, not challenging!

Still a better love story than Twilight

A Rose in the Twilight offers a puzzle game that is often challenging and unique as it is frustrating, in a visual style that has become synonymous with NIS. It didn't appeal to me as much as I thought it would but I liked it for its touching story and the original way it unfolds, and I despised it for the broken mechanic that reminded me that it could have been a better game.

attachFull83216

I'm glad

Verdict

What We Liked ...

Unique puzzles at each level
Touching story
Original storytelling technique

What We Didn't Like ...

Frustrating mechanics
Slow paced
Monotonous environment

Gameplay

The puzzles are all different from level to level and get gradually tougher to solve. But the flawed mechanic, precision and luck that many entail undermine what could have been a much more fun and challenging experience.

Presentation

I've grown to become fond of NIS' deceptively cute appearance in their trademark 'cute gore' presentation of their games. The story telling is also done in an interesting way in this title..

Lasting Appeal

This is mostly a one-shot game unless you want to best your stage completion times but you'll have to bear with the mechanic all over again! Arrgh!

out of 10

Overall

Sometimes captivating, other times frustrating, the puzzles in A Rose in the Twilight use an interesting but flawed mechanic and delivers a touching story that you have to piece together.

Reactions: s157, chavosaur and T-hug

s157
Apr 4, 2017

Was it worth the buy? I need a reason to use my vita again. The atmosphere of it looks pleasantly ominous.

Prans
Apr 4, 2017

s157 said:
Was it worth the buy? I need a reason to use my vita again. The atmosphere of it looks pleasantly ominous.

The atmosphere is one of the highlights of the game and it sets the tone for the story. Worth a buy? It's really up to you if you'll enjoy it enough or not. But worth a try, at the very least.

Guess I'll have to try and see. I enjoy a lot of games regardless of their review score, so I'll just have to judge myself. I'm hoping the atmosphere and story can overtake rather flawed gameplay like The Last Guardian did for me.

Reactions: Prans

I disagree with this review on some points, but I think I have to wait for the actual release to share my thoughts in detail. Enjoyable game, but I don't know if it's $40 worth of one. It is hitting Steam, fortunately, so there'll probably be a better deal there within a few months.

My friend reviewed this a few days ago and he really loved the puzzles. So I dunno.
I'll have to try it sometime (well, not the type of game I'd pay full price though, so maybe when it goes on sale).

Reviews

PlayStation 5
Alone in the Dark (2024)

Alone in the Dark is a Survival Horror game available for PlayStation 5, Xbox Series S/X and PC.
Computer
Rauniot

Step into post-apocalyptic Northern Finland in Rauniot, Act Normal Game’s debut point-and-click title. Let’s click away!
Computer
Broken Roads

Australia-based indie developer Drop Bear Bytes’ debut title, Broken Roads, launches today on PC and consoles. Does this new cRPG have what it takes to stand toe-to-toe to its contemporaries?
Computer
Ereban: Shadow Legacy

Ereban: Shadow Legacy is Baby Robot Games’ debut title that merges classic stealth mechanics with a fast-paced ability to merge with shadows. Should you allow it to sneak into your PC gaming library?
PlayStation 5
South Park: Snow Day!

South Park is back in the gaming sphere with the followup to Obsidian’s hit duo of RPGs, South Park: Snow Day!

More reviews

Product Information:

Game Features:

Nippon Ichi? Check. 'Cute Gore', check. Appeal?

A Curse, A Friend, A Story

Puzzled

Still a better love story than Twilight

Verdict

Overall

Alone in the Dark (2024)

Rauniot

Broken Roads

Ereban: Shadow Legacy

South Park: Snow Day!