How is it appropriate to talk about roms and emulation?

kbf

Well-Known Member
OP
Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2008
Messages
1,210
Trophies
1
XP
2,338
Country
Canada
I understand that asking for roms is against the rules. But what about mentioning them in a post? often i'm not sure if I should say "backups" can you get in trouble just for saying you have roms? as in for example let's say you're following a tutorial and you go "ok so I just take my rom and do this/put it here?" so is only asking for them against the rules? is their mention of them discouraged from the site? are you even allowed to mention them?


Just trying to understand the ethic-icy around here. And what are everyones thoughts about it being against the rules in the first place?
 

raulpica

With your drill, thrust to the sky!
Former Staff
Joined
Oct 23, 2007
Messages
11,056
Trophies
0
Location
PowerLevel: 9001
XP
5,716
Country
Italy
Yeah, mentioning them is okay. There are plenty of legal ways of dumping your own games for emulation/backup purposes and that's what we assume most users are doing.

Obviously writing something like "lol I got dis pokaymanz r0m from a website" CLEARLY tells us that user X has pirated a game and as such his/hers post will be removed and the user warned/banned accordingly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TotalInsanity4

V0ltr0n

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2016
Messages
484
Trophies
0
Age
39
XP
542
Country
United States
You can talk about roms etc, just not ask for links. Also cannot provide or ask for links to sites that host warez. The rule is only in place so that gbatemp can avoid a takedown
 
  • Like
Reactions: Quantumcat

DinohScene

Gay twink catboy
Global Moderator
Joined
Oct 11, 2011
Messages
22,530
Trophies
4
Location
Восторг
XP
22,724
Country
Antarctica
Mentioning ROMs is allowed.
Mentioning warez sites isn't.
That should include posts containing "that iso site" "that chaos site" etc!

Rules state that members can't mention them.
Rules said:
Members may also NOT mention torrent or warez-containing sites or channels by name or otherwise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vipera

kbf

Well-Known Member
OP
Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2008
Messages
1,210
Trophies
1
XP
2,338
Country
Canada
You can talk about roms etc, just not ask for links. Also cannot provide or ask for links to sites that host warez. The rule is only in place so that gbatemp can avoid a takedown


but what about stuff like wii USB helper and CIAangle/freeshop? aren't those things allowed to be talked about on here?
 

Oleboy555

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2017
Messages
907
Trophies
0
Location
Amsterdam
Website
3ds.guide
XP
2,303
Country
Netherlands
Yeah, mentioning them is okay. There are plenty of legal ways of dumping your own games for emulation/backup purposes and that's what we assume most users are doing.

Obviously writing something like "lol I got dis pokaymanz r0m from a website" CLEARLY tells us that user X has pirated a game and as such his/hers post will be removed and the user warned/banned accordingly.
whta about the pirating game on the edge of the forum?
 

Zero72463

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2016
Messages
1,383
Trophies
0
XP
1,496
Country
United States
Yeah, mentioning them is okay. There are plenty of legal ways of dumping your own games for emulation/backup purposes and that's what we assume most users are doing.

Obviously writing something like "lol I got dis pokaymanz r0m from a website" CLEARLY tells us that user X has pirated a game and as such his/hers post will be removed and the user warned/banned accordingly.

A lot of people here say they pirate, but they don't get banned. Or is it just for mentioning the site?
 

kbf

Well-Known Member
OP
Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2008
Messages
1,210
Trophies
1
XP
2,338
Country
Canada
A lot of people here say they pirate, but they don't get banned. Or is it just for mentioning the site?

I don't think you could really go after anyone for saying that because the company would have to prove that you have stolen their intellectual property and I just don't see most companies going after a single forum user for admitting to piracy.

Iv'e had Nintendo suspect I had homebrew on my wii or I might have slipped it by accident i'm not sure(it was for a repair) and all they said is that they couldn't help me if it was modded.
 

Tom Bombadildo

Dick, With Balls
Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
14,575
Trophies
2
Age
29
Location
I forgot
Website
POCKET.LIKEITS
XP
19,216
Country
United States
A lot of people here say they pirate, but they don't get banned. Or is it just for mentioning the site?
Specifically going around telling everyone "I pirated this game from XYZ website LOLOLOLOL" is warn/banworthy, just saying "yeah sometimes I pirate stuff", not so much (unless it's irrelevant to the discussion, of course).

but what about stuff like wii USB helper and CIAangle/freeshop? aren't those things allowed to be talked about on here?
Those things still require "legitimate" things, like Titlekeys that people should dump themselves from games they own. We don't allow users to post title keys or anything here, as that would be against the rules.
 

kbf

Well-Known Member
OP
Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2008
Messages
1,210
Trophies
1
XP
2,338
Country
Canada
Specifically going around telling everyone "I pirated this game from XYZ website LOLOLOLOL" is warn/banworthy, just saying "yeah sometimes I pirate stuff", not so much (unless it's irrelevant to the discussion, of course).


Those things still require "legitimate" things, like Titlekeys that people should dump themselves from games they own. We don't allow users to post title keys or anything here, as that would be against the rules.


so basically you can have the chest full of treasure but not the key haha.
 

migles

All my gbatemp friends are now mods, except for me
Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2013
Messages
8,033
Trophies
0
Location
Earth-chan
XP
5,299
Country
China
Yeah, mentioning them is okay. There are plenty of legal ways of dumping your own games for emulation/backup purposes and that's what we assume most users are doing.

Obviously writing something like "lol I got dis pokaymanz r0m from a website" CLEARLY tells us that user X has pirated a game and as such his/hers post will be removed and the user warned/banned accordingly.
i never seen an user getting is post removed or warned because they say "i got rom from internet"
 

Alex658

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2010
Messages
1,206
Trophies
1
Age
29
Location
Colombia
XP
1,194
Country
Colombia
i never seen an user getting is post removed or warned because they say "i got rom from internet"

You don't get to see when somebody gets warned. Only the mods and the person in question can.

I have seen multiple posts removed just for mentioning that iso site's real name. So there's that.
 

naughty_cat

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2013
Messages
218
Trophies
0
Age
36
XP
600
Country
Egypt
As far as the video gaming industry is concerned, "roms/backups" and "piracy" are 2 very different things. Also it should be noted that the "ethical" side of the matter is actually quite different from the "legal" side.

Back in the good old days, people used to record whatever they could view on their TV using their VCR's , and it wouldn't be called piracy until someone would start to sell a recording of copy-righted material and actually make illegal profit out of it, which was "ethically" different from sharing your favourite tv shows with your friends and family without actually charging them, or setting the VCR to record your favourite TV show while you were away at work or something... And a REAL pirate had to be someone that retained an actual physical existence out in the real world, selling actual physical copies of copy-righted material, thus it was far more practical and economic to leave it up to the actual physical law enforcement agencies to get out there and go after people who could for sure be proven guilty with the crime of piracy...

However, after DVD's, the internet and the advent of digital formats came along, things started to change dramatically, since people could easily have access to "100% free media" from within the safety of their own home... as opposed to going out there into the slums or wherever you could buy "cheaper,not free" copies at the risk of entangling with dubious "pirates/criminals". Thus the laws and the entertainment industries began to steadily draw very clear lines and limitations around the market and the various media products... Back in the old days almost nearly any God given, run of the mill vcr could record anything from TV right out of the box, and blank vhs tapes, cassette tapes, and blank discs was a lucrative industry in its own right... Nowadays a single flash drive can store bulks of mixed media of any type of format, and recording TV shows is somewhat tricky and requires purchasing additional equipment...

Video games happens to be a very specific case scenario, partly because video games, unlike movies and music, were never aired directly to people's TV sets, and their native format started out as 1st party proprietary cartridges, which were never available in "blanks"... and no video gaming console has ever given paying customers the ability to record and share their games, or back them up (at least until the end of the 1990's), thus the concept of "sharing" your game was always rendered 100% illegal.
Another one of the many things that sets video games apart is "regional lockout"... Quite a lot of decent titles (such as all those cool Japanese RPG's that were never released outside Japan) were far more easily accessible via pirate/warez channels, and this is mostly because, simply, most people outside Japan don't speak Japanese... And even if one was to purchase a legal copy of a foreign game and have it imported all the way from Japan at additional costs, they would eventually still have to back it up in order to be able to implement English subtitles, or perform the so called "un-dubbing" process (And mind you all that during the cartridge days this was not possible... It's only when games started to come out on compact discs that people started to be able to do it the legal way, since there weren't any practical means of extracting the game from the cartridge onto the computer - and this is still true for 3DS as well as SWITCH games! - But, with that being said, one could still pay for the Japan-only game and put it on the shelf, thus abiding to the good morals and ethics of a good consumer, and then go on ahead and download the same game via a pirate/warez channel, which is is still "technically" breaking the law! This is one of the case scenarios that justify the clear cut difference between what is "ethical" and what is "legal")

Sorry for the tedious long post, it's just that this is one of the rather important subject matters that is hardly ever discussed with proper justice... and this thread just seemed to hit the spot for me...
 

kbf

Well-Known Member
OP
Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2008
Messages
1,210
Trophies
1
XP
2,338
Country
Canada
As far as the video gaming industry is concerned, "roms/backups" and "piracy" are 2 very different things. Also it should be noted that the "ethical" side of the matter is actually quite different from the "legal" side.

Back in the good old days, people used to record whatever they could view on their TV using their VCR's , and it wouldn't be called piracy until someone would start to sell a recording of copy-righted material and actually make illegal profit out of it, which was "ethically" different from sharing your favourite tv shows with your friends and family without actually charging them, or setting the VCR to record your favourite TV show while you were away at work or something... And a REAL pirate had to be someone that retained an actual physical existence out in the real world, selling actual physical copies of copy-righted material, thus it was far more practical and economic to leave it up to the actual physical law enforcement agencies to get out there and go after people who could for sure be proven guilty with the crime of piracy...

However, after DVD's, the internet and the advent of digital formats came along, things started to change dramatically, since people could easily have access to "100% free media" from within the safety of their own home... as opposed to going out there into the slums or wherever you could buy "cheaper,not free" copies at the risk of entangling with dubious "pirates/criminals". Thus the laws and the entertainment industries began to steadily draw very clear lines and limitations around the market and the various media products... Back in the old days almost nearly any God given, run of the mill vcr could record anything from TV right out of the box, and blank vhs tapes, cassette tapes, and blank discs was a lucrative industry in its own right... Nowadays a single flash drive can store bulks of mixed media of any type of format, and recording TV shows is somewhat tricky and requires purchasing additional equipment...

Video games happens to be a very specific case scenario, partly because video games, unlike movies and music, were never aired directly to people's TV sets, and their native format started out as 1st party proprietary cartridges, which were never available in "blanks"... and no video gaming console has ever given paying customers the ability to record and share their games, or back them up (at least until the end of the 1990's), thus the concept of "sharing" your game was always rendered 100% illegal.
Another one of the many things that sets video games apart is "regional lockout"... Quite a lot of decent titles (such as all those cool Japanese RPG's that were never released outside Japan) were far more easily accessible via pirate/warez channels, and this is mostly because, simply, most people outside Japan don't speak Japanese... And even if one was to purchase a legal copy of a foreign game and have it imported all the way from Japan at additional costs, they would eventually still have to back it up in order to be able to implement English subtitles, or perform the so called "un-dubbing" process (And mind you all that during the cartridge days this was not possible... It's only when games started to come out on compact discs that people started to be able to do it the legal way, since there weren't any practical means of extracting the game from the cartridge onto the computer - and this is still true for 3DS as well as SWITCH games! - But, with that being said, one could still pay for the Japan-only game and put it on the shelf, thus abiding to the good morals and ethics of a good consumer, and then go on ahead and download the same game via a pirate/warez channel, which is is still "technically" breaking the law! This is one of the case scenarios that justify the clear cut difference between what is "ethical" and what is "legal")

Sorry for the tedious long post, it's just that this is one of the rather important subject matters that is hardly ever discussed with proper justice... and this thread just seemed to hit the spot for me...


No that's a great post, always glad to see a lot of thought put into something.



Although that reminds me iv'e heard that companies have legal rights over your physical property because the copywrite protects it as property as well but i'm not sure if that's true because iv'e never seen a company literally try to force itself to take something away phsyical you bought for violating a contract/law.

--------------------- MERGED ---------------------------

I don't like the hypocrisy of saying "what if I'm using backups!". I would be surprised if there is one active user here with a hacked 3DS who doesn't use illegally obtained ROMs. Let them discuss their stuff. It's like when some tobacco stores are selling bongs or grinders. It shouldn't matter as long as they aren't idolizing illegal acts in public or contribute to "commercial piracy" in private (as in, paying for actual warez, directly or indirectly, should always be wrong).

But I agree that saying stuff like "that iso site" should be forbidden too.



I almost agree but on the other hand there's plenty of warez sites still up that have been around for years.
 

FAST6191

Techromancer
Editorial Team
Joined
Nov 21, 2005
Messages
36,798
Trophies
3
XP
28,321
Country
United Kingdom
Leaving aside the discussion of ROMs then why would emulation be a problem? It is perfectly legal in most places and there are several laws and bits of case law which would back it up.
 

The Catboy

GBAtemp Official Catboy™: Boywife
Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
27,909
Trophies
4
Location
Making a non-binary fuss
XP
39,184
Country
Antarctica
but what about stuff like wii USB helper and CIAangle/freeshop? aren't those things allowed to be talked about on here?
First, FreeShop is legal
Actually all of these homebrews fall under a legal grey area. Ultimately they give the power to break the law, but do not endorse, support, nor encourage piracy.
 
D

Deleted User

Guest
The way I've always seen it is as long as you don't go requesting copyrighted content or linking to it then you're all good. The Wii sub-forum has an entire section dedicated to backup loading. Nobody gets their posts edited for saying "the cool site". But if I post a link to www.[the cool site].com then my post will get a {snip} in it and I'll probably receive a warning.
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum

General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
    SylverReZ @ SylverReZ: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftyFz0yBxj8