It is theroticlly possible to fix it only with OTP and hard-mod. Since you only need to modify one file in the SLC filesystem. But the tools to do so don't exists yet, but I am working on something that may be available soon. You can follow the hard-mod thread.
EDIT: just to add on that. It is IMPOSSIBLE to fix bricked Wii U without the OTP or REAL NAND dump (one of them is required), the software dumped NAND isn't enough! Because that dump isn't complete and is impossible to fix it without the OTP. I am trying to modify an existing tool to do a full and proper NAND dump, will update if it works.
So OTP > NAND "dump"
So to recap
- rednand incomplete NAND backup (no ECC data) = completely useless by itself (but maybe one day there could be a software to add ECC data to it?)
- real NAND backup via hardmod = sufficient by itself to unbrick if and when the right software tools are available (plus hardmod to flash)
- OTP backup (how? hardmod or homebrew?) = sufficient by itself to unbrick if and when the right software tools are available (plus hardmod to flash)
so either one of real NAND backup or OTP backup is sufficient?
Anyway I can hear the sound of hundreds of gbatempers with an incomplete NAND backup obtained via rednand and their false sense of safety. Cue Lisa Simpson and the tiger-repelling rock.
And to wrap up: as I suspected, to this day, to this week, to this month of March 2017, there are zero confirmed wiiU unbricks of any kind and having a (botched or real) NAND backup wouldn't give the OP's kids a WiiU back by next weekend.
Tomorrow, maybe. Maybe someone will even start selling hardmod kits.
And as always, to noobs like myself:
- don't use rednand, it's just superstition and problems (f*** the wiiuguide)
- don't backup your nand, it's just superstition at the moment and the rednand-made backup is completely useless
- don't use mocha via browser exploit you cheapstake, setup haxchi or CBHC while we still can access the eShop
don't use rednand
don't use rednand
don't use rednand